Charlatan epistemology: As illustrated by a study of wonder-working in the late seventeenth-century Dutch Republic (2020)
This article highlights the epistemic concerns that have permeated the historical discourse around charlatanism. In it, I study the term “charlatan” as a multivalent actor’s category without a stable referent. Instead of defining or identifying “the charlatan,” I analyze how the concept of the charlatan was used to make epistemic interventions about what constituted credible knowledge in two interconnected controversies. Focusing on these controversies allows me to thematize how the concept of “the charlatan” expanded beyond medical contexts and to bring a history of knowledge perspective to the history of medicine.The title of the article, “Charlatan Epistemology,” indicates a historical epistemological approach to charlatanism as well as the existence of a charlatan’s embodied epistemology. On the one hand, I historicize the epistemic characteristics of charlatanism, focusing on virtues as well as vices, knowledge as well as ignorance, by addressing the historical and contextual specificities of two case studies and the larger epistemic concerns at play. On the other hand, I show how references to charlatanism implied the existence of specific embodied knowledges, special skills and techniques to manipulate either natural secrets or the human psyche, and I explore the similarities and differences between charlatan epistemology and artisanal epistemology.
...MoreArticle Irina Podgorny; Daniel Gethmann (2020) 'Please, come in.' Being a charlatan, or the question of trustworthy knowledge. Science in Context (pp. 355-361).
Similar Citations
Article
Nathalie Richard;
(2020)
Between learned and popular culture: A world of syncretism and acculturation
(/isis/citation/CBB054498248/)
Article
Irina Podgorny;
Daniel Gethmann;
(2020)
'Please, come in.' Being a charlatan, or the question of trustworthy knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB012504782/)
Book
Jochen Büttner;
(2019)
Swinging and Rolling: Unveiling Galileo's unorthodox path from a challenging problem to a new science
(/isis/citation/CBB548435869/)
Article
Anne-Lise Rey;
(2019)
Les enjeux métaphysiques de la dynamique
(/isis/citation/CBB019359495/)
Article
Christophe Schmit;
(2015)
Les dynamiques de Jean-Jacques Dortous de Mairan
(/isis/citation/CBB695462531/)
Book
C. A. Davids;
Fokko Jan Dijksterhuis;
Rienk Vermij;
Ida H. Stamhuis;
(2020)
Rethinking Stevin, Stevin Rethinking: Constructions of a Dutch Polymath
(/isis/citation/CBB339210458/)
Article
Klerk, Saskia;
(2014)
The Trouble with Opium. Taste, Reason and Experience in Late Galenic Pharmacology with Special Regard to the University of Leiden (1575--1625)
(/isis/citation/CBB001202398/)
Article
Buning, Marius;
(2014)
Inventing Scientific Method: The Privilege System as a Model for Scientific Knowledge-Production
(/isis/citation/CBB001451723/)
Article
Agustí Nieto-Galan;
(2020)
Useful charlatans: Giovanni Succi and Stefano Merlatti’s fasting contest in Paris, 1886
(/isis/citation/CBB339479544/)
Article
Steven Vanden Broecke;
(2022)
Negotiating Theology and Medicine in the Catholic Reformation The Early Debate on Thomas Fienus's Embryology in the Spanish Netherlands (1620–1629)
(/isis/citation/CBB415208832/)
Chapter
Chiara Maria Buglioni;
(2014)
Vedere con i propri occhi. L'ignorante e il folle di Thomas Bernhard come indagine autoptica
(/isis/citation/CBB352956194/)
Chapter
Turner, David M.;
(2013)
Disability Humor and the Meanings of Impairment in Early Modern England
(/isis/citation/CBB001201695/)
Article
Gentilcore, David;
(1995)
“Charlatans, mountebanks and other similar people”: The regulation and role of itinerant practitioners in early modern Italy
(/isis/citation/CBB000069545/)
Book
Gentilcore, David;
(2006)
Medical Charlatanism in Early Modern Italy
(/isis/citation/CBB000741168/)
Article
Gentilcore, David;
(2003)
“For the Protection of Those Who Have Both Shop and Home in This City”: Relations Between Italian Charlatans and Apothecaries
(/isis/citation/CBB000502226/)
Book
Sang-ho Ro;
(2021)
Neo-Confucianism and Science in Korea: Humanity and Nature, 1706-1814
(/isis/citation/CBB508475951/)
Article
Dulce da Rocha Gonçalves;
(2020)
Science between the fairground and the academy: The case of Dutch science popularizer L. K. Maju (1823–1886)
(/isis/citation/CBB074545488/)
Article
Gentilcore, David;
(2003)
Apothecaries, “Charlatans,” and the Medical Marketplace in Italy, 1400--1750: Introduction
(/isis/citation/CBB000502225/)
Book
Klaas van Berkel;
(2017)
Universiteit van het Noorden: vier eeuwen academisch leven in Groningen. Deel 2, de klassieke universiteit, 1876-1945.
(/isis/citation/CBB776135678/)
Article
Victor Petit;
(2019)
Jean Gayon (1949-2018): Itinéraire d’un darwinien
(/isis/citation/CBB150653875/)
Be the first to comment!