Paleobiologists (and other historical scientists) often provide simple narratives to explain complex, contingent episodes. These narratives are sometimes ‘one-shot hypotheses’ which are treated as being mutually exclusive with other possible explanations of the target episode, and are thus extended to accommodate as much about the episode as possible. I argue that a provisional preference for such hypotheses provides two kinds of productive scaffolding. First, they generate ‘hypothetical difference-makers’: one-shot hypotheses highlight and isolate empirically tractable dependencies between variables. Second, investigations of hypothetical difference-makers provision explanatory resources, the ‘raw materials’ for constructing more complex—and likely more adequate—explanations. Provisional preferences for simple, one-shot hypotheses in historical science, then, is defeasibly justified on indirect—strategic—grounds. My argument is made in reference to recent developments regarding the K–Pg extinction.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Enrico Cinti;
Vincenzo Fano;
(2021)
Careful with those scissors, Eugene! Against the observational indistinguishability of spacetimes
(/isis/citation/CBB952356420/)
Book
Samuel Schindler;
(2018)
Theoretical Virtues in Science: Uncovering Reality through Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB140689696/)
Article
Alexander Pechenkin;
(2021)
The Ensemble Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics and Scientific Realism
(/isis/citation/CBB613319171/)
Book
Fagan, Melinda Bonnie;
(2013)
Philosophy of Stem Cell Biology: Knowledge in Flesh and Blood
(/isis/citation/CBB001420098/)
Article
López-Beltrán, Carlos;
(2013)
Exploring Heredity: Diachronic and Synchronic Connections
(/isis/citation/CBB001211935/)
Article
Victor Petit;
(2019)
Jean Gayon (1949-2018): Itinéraire d’un darwinien
(/isis/citation/CBB150653875/)
Article
Causá, Mauro;
Savin, Andreas;
Silvi, Bernard;
(2014)
Atoms and Bonds in Molecules and Chemical Explanations
(/isis/citation/CBB001321116/)
Article
Michael Fry;
(2018)
Predictive Hypotheses Are Ineffectual in Resolving Complex Biochemical Systems
(/isis/citation/CBB002665433/)
Chapter
Walter, Scott;
(2009)
Hypothesis and Convention in Poincaré's Defense of Galilei Spacetime
(/isis/citation/CBB001032108/)
Chapter
Schiemann, Gregor;
(2009)
Werner Heisenberg's Position on a Hypothetical Conception of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001032110/)
Book
Franklin, James;
(2009)
What Science Knows and How It Knows It
(/isis/citation/CBB001032773/)
Article
Carl F. Craver;
David M. Kaplan;
(2020)
Are More Details Better? On the Norms of Completeness for Mechanistic Explanations
(/isis/citation/CBB621951199/)
Article
Fiora Salis;
(2021)
The New Fiction View of Models
(/isis/citation/CBB270986404/)
Article
Alessandra Morrone;
Lisa Zorzato;
(2021)
The Song of the Science Mermaid: A Philosophical Trilogue on the Osteological Paradox
(/isis/citation/CBB676664243/)
Article
Diederik Aerts;
Massimiliano Sassoli de Bianchi;
Sandro Sozzo;
Tomas Veloz;
(2020)
On the Conceptuality Interpretation of Quantum and Relativity Theories
(/isis/citation/CBB847601811/)
Article
Lorenzo Baravalle;
Davide Vecchi;
(2016)
Beyond blindness: On the role of organism and environment in trial generation
(/isis/citation/CBB160352718/)
Article
Steve Elliott;
(2021)
Research Problems
(/isis/citation/CBB597881862/)
Article
Slowik, Edward;
(2013)
Newton's Neo-Platonic Ontology of Space
(/isis/citation/CBB001320863/)
Article
Rouse, Joseph;
(2011)
Philosophy of Science and Science Studies in the West: An Unrecognized Convergence
(/isis/citation/CBB001231685/)
Article
Uebel, Thomas;
(2011)
Carnap and Kuhn: On the Relation between the Logic of Science and the History of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001230055/)
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Foundations of Science
Acta Baltica historiae et philosophiae scientiarum
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Be the first to comment!