This article examines two forensic casebooks from nineteenth century China. Forensic cases are among the favored sources for progressive narratives sketching out the development of forensic knowledge as a process through which anomalies are detected and explained, and new facts are ultimately incorporated into the existing corpus of knowledge. This article is aimed at providing an alternative view. It first argues that cases revealing a serious discrepancy vis-à-vis the official manual for autopsies are extremely few. It later demonstrates that, instead of accumulating facts challenging the authoritative manual, forensic case compilers primarily addressed the question of weighing evidence. They singled out cases which shed light on how to make a decision in the face of several competing, but already-known symptoms. Each case displays how the weighing process worked out depending on its particular and unrepeatable circumstantial configuration, with no intent to convey generalizable information. Collecting precedents is thus not intended to form new claims as opposed to the canonical manual, but to make it more applicable to a complex reality. Forensic case compilers, therefore, did not evaluate the official manual in terms of correctness or inaccuracy, exhaustiveness or deficiency. What really mattered was flexibility in using the book depending on the actual circumstances.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Thesis
Asen, Daniel;
(2012)
Dead Bodies and Forensic Science: Cultures of Expertise in China, 1800--1949
(/isis/citation/CBB001562783/)
Article
Yang, Xiaoming;
Li, Shuxue;
(2005)
An Qingqiao's Explanation of Precession
(/isis/citation/CBB000630308/)
Chapter
Joachim Kurtz;
(2010)
Messenger of the Sacred Heart: Li Wenyu (1840–1911), and the Jesuit Periodical Press in Late Qing Shanghai
(/isis/citation/CBB711159352/)
Article
Chu, Pingyi;
(2003)
Remembering Our Grand Tradition: The Historical Memory of the Scientific Exchanges between China and Europe, 1600--1800
(/isis/citation/CBB000340661/)
Thesis
Sela, Ori;
(2011)
Qian Daxin (1728--1804): Knowledge, Identity, and Reception History in China, 1750--1930
(/isis/citation/CBB001562728/)
Article
Gao, Hongcheng;
(2009)
Study on the Integral Problem about the Quadratic Curve by Xia Luanxiang---Besides Discussion on the Early Comprehension to Calculus of Traditional Chinese
(/isis/citation/CBB000933550/)
Article
Chen, Hsiu-fen;
(2011)
Between Passion and Repression: Medical Views of Demon Dreams, Demonic Fetuses, and Female Sexual Madness in Late Imperial China
(/isis/citation/CBB001231843/)
Thesis
Shing-ting Lin;
(2015)
The Female Hand: The Making of Western Medicine for Women in China, 1880s–1920s
(/isis/citation/CBB532007965/)
Article
Dong, Guicheng;
(2005)
Tentative Discussion on the Understanding of Reformists about the Development of Science and Technology
(/isis/citation/CBB000502039/)
Article
Li, Di;
(2004)
Posthumous Scientific Manuscripts of Zou Boqi
(/isis/citation/CBB000502065/)
Book
Christopher A. Reed;
Cynthia Brokaw;
(2010)
From Woodblocks to the Internet: Chinese Publishing and Print Culture in Transition, Circa 1800 to 2008
(/isis/citation/CBB667455096/)
Article
Wang, Wenzhi;
Mei, Jianjun;
(2009)
A Preliminary Study of “Kodo Zuroku”
(/isis/citation/CBB000933556/)
Chapter
Florence Bretelle-Establet;
(2014)
Les épidémies en Chine à la croisée des savoirs et des imaginaires : le Grand Sud aux xviiie et xixe siècles
(/isis/citation/CBB279296261/)
Book
C. Michele Thompson;
(2015)
Vietnamese Traditional Medicine: A Social History
(/isis/citation/CBB013500686/)
Article
Luo, Jianjin;
(2003)
On the Development of the Formulae for Sums of Integers
(/isis/citation/CBB000774899/)
Article
Chiang, Howard H.;
(2010)
Liberating Sex, Knowing Desire: Scientia Sexualis and Epistemic Turning Points in the History of Sexuality
(/isis/citation/CBB001035641/)
Book
Renshaw, Michelle;
(2005)
Accommodating the Chinese: The American Hospital in China, 1880--1920
(/isis/citation/CBB000600049/)
Thesis
Fan, Fa-ti;
(1999)
British Naturalists in China, 1760--1910
(/isis/citation/CBB001562714/)
Article
Kurtz, Joachim;
(2003)
New Terms for Telling the Truth: Notes on the Formation of Modern Chinese Logical Terminology, 1886-1911
(/isis/citation/CBB000410986/)
Article
Wen-Ji Wang;
(2016)
Neurasthenia and the Rise of Psy Disciplines in Republican China
(/isis/citation/CBB602525418/)
Be the first to comment!