In this paper, I examine disputes over recent claims that male circumcision reduces HIV risk to suggest a complicated relationship between risk individualization and categorization. Whereas randomized controlled trials (RCTs) conducted in sub-Saharan Africa appear to have provided key evidence for the World Health Organization’s endorsement of male circumcision as an HIV prevention strategy, RCTs alone did not provide evidence for the underlying causal mechanism. For that, medical authorities have turned to histo-immunological studies of the foreskin’s biomolecular vulnerability to HIV, thus molecularizing risk. Some actors used these studies both as a way of shoring up results of RCTs conducted in sub-Saharan Africa and as an important rationale in arguments for making neonatal circumcision more widely available. Others, however, resisted this move to generalize the RCT results to other parts of the world, citing both contextual differences in HIV transmission patterns and conflicting scientific details regarding the biomolecular basis of the foreskin’s susceptibility. Nevertheless, by locating an abstract notion of relative risk in the body itself, I argue that histological studies of foreskin have played a key role in stabilizing male circumcision status as a new risk category, largely independent of a given individual’s risk profile.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Brives, Charlotte;
(2013)
Identifying ontologies in a clinical trial
(/isis/citation/CBB362744143/)
Article
Clay Davis;
(December 2020)
Homo adhaerens: Risk and adherence in biomedical HIV prevention research
(/isis/citation/CBB559629478/)
Article
Christopher Rutty;
(2022)
“It Works! Now What?” Insulin Development, Production, and Distribution at Connaught Laboratories, University of Toronto, 1922–24
(/isis/citation/CBB378275066/)
Article
Jenna M. Grant;
(April 2016)
From subjects to relations: Bioethics and the articulation of postcolonial politics in the Cambodia Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis trial
(/isis/citation/CBB531101853/)
Article
Petty, JuLeigh;
Heimer, Carol A.;
(2011)
Extending the rails: How research reshapes clinics
(/isis/citation/CBB060848255/)
Article
Jill A. Fisher;
(March 2015)
Feeding and Bleeding: The Institutional Banalization of Risk to Healthy Volunteers in Phase I Pharmaceutical Clinical Trials
(/isis/citation/CBB066653855/)
Book
Robert Aronowitz;
(2015)
Risky Medicine: Our Quest to Cure Fear and Uncertainty
(/isis/citation/CBB544783309/)
Article
Knight, Mary;
(2001)
Curing Cut or Ritual Mutilation? Some Remarks on the Practice of Female and Male Circumcision in Graeco-Roman Egypt
(/isis/citation/CBB000671236/)
Article
Kaya Şahi̇n;
(2019)
To Observe, to Record, to Depict: Memorializing the Circumcision of an Ottoman Prince, C. 1582–C. 1600
(/isis/citation/CBB043544269/)
Article
Leah DeVun;
(2015)
Erecting Sex: Hermaphrodites and the Medieval Science of Surgery
(/isis/citation/CBB201497383/)
Article
Robert Darby;
(2011)
Scientific Advice, Traditional Practices and the Politics of Health-Care : The Australian Debate over Public Funding of Non-Therapeutic Circumcision, 1985
(/isis/citation/CBB239283399/)
Article
Rodriguez, Sarah W.;
(2008)
Rethinking the History of Female Circumcision and Clitoridectomy: American Medicine and Female Sexuality in the Late Nineteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB000930401/)
Article
Katharine Park;
(2023)
The Myth of the “One-Sex” Body
(/isis/citation/CBB629564037/)
Article
Darby, Robert;
(2005)
Pathologizing Male Sexuality: Lallemand, Spermatorrhea, and the Rise of Circumcision
(/isis/citation/CBB000671040/)
Article
Baumgarten, Elisheva;
(2005)
Marking the Flesh: Circumcision, Blood, and Inscribing Identity on the Body in Medieval Jewish Culture
(/isis/citation/CBB000830189/)
Article
Sandra Eder;
(2018)
Gender and Cortisone: Clinical Practice and Transatlantic Exchange in the Medical Management of Intersex in the 1950s
(/isis/citation/CBB390437615/)
Article
Darby, Robert;
(2003)
“Where Doctors Differ”: The Debate on Circumcision as a Protection against Syphilis, 1855--1914
(/isis/citation/CBB000770488/)
Article
Frederiksen, Bodil Folke;
(2008)
Jomo Kenyatta, Marie Bonaparte and Bronislaw Malinowski on Clitoridectomy and Female Sexuality
(/isis/citation/CBB001032346/)
Article
Cuperschmid, Ethel Mizrahy;
Campos, Tarcisio Passos Ribeiro de;
(2007)
Os curiosos xenoimplantes glandulares do doutor Voronof
(/isis/citation/CBB000831533/)
Book
Forth, Christopher E.;
Crozier, Ivan;
(2005)
Body Parts: Critical Explorations in Corporeality
(/isis/citation/CBB000820036/)
Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Canadian Journal of Health History/Revue canadienne d’histoire de la santé
Social History of Medicine
Science, Technology and Human Values
Be the first to comment!