In this paper I will outline a worry that citizen science can promote a kind of transparency that is harmful. I argue for the value of secrecy in citizen science. My argument will consist of analysis of a particular community (herpers), a particular citizen science platform (iNaturalist, drawing contrasts with other platforms), and my own travels in citizen science. I aim to avoid a simple distinction between science versus non-science, and instead analyze herping as a rich practice [MacIntyre, 2007]. Herping exemplifies citizen science as functioning simultaneously within and outside the sphere of science. I show that herpers have developed communal systems of transmitting and protecting knowledge. Ethical concerns about secrecy are inherently linked to these systems of knowledge. My over-arching aim is to urge caution in the drive to transparency, as the concepts of transparency and secrecy merit close scrutiny. The concerns I raise are complementary to those suggested by previous philosophical work, and (I argue) resist straightforward solutions.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Lidia Falomo Bernarduzzi;
Ester Maria Bernardi;
Alberto Ferrari;
Maria Carla Garbarino;
Andrea Vai;
(2021)
Augmented Reality Application for Handheld Devices
(/isis/citation/CBB976743843/)
Book
Lik Sam Chan;
(2021)
The Politics of Dating Apps: Gender, Sexuality, and Emergent Publics in Urban China
(/isis/citation/CBB728064731/)
Article
Vickie Curtis;
(December 2015)
Motivation to Participate in an Online Citizen Science Game: A Study of Foldit
(/isis/citation/CBB708636413/)
Article
Phil Brown;
(2021)
From the Radical Psychology Movement to STS: A Journey From the 1960s in Multiple Parts
(/isis/citation/CBB099951762/)
Article
Jan-Peter Voß;
Nina Amelung;
(October 2016)
Innovating public participation methods: Technoscientization and reflexive engagement
(/isis/citation/CBB261047944/)
Article
Victoria Martin;
Liam Smith;
Alison Bowling;
Les Christidis;
David Lloyd;
Gretta Pecl;
(August 2016)
Citizens as Scientists: What Influences Public Contributions to Marine Research?
(/isis/citation/CBB408786335/)
Article
Denisa Kera;
(2017)
Science Artisans and Open Science Hardware
(/isis/citation/CBB090977579/)
Article
Fan, Fa-ti;
Chen, Shun-Ling;
Kao, Chia-Liang;
Murphy, Michelle;
Price, Matt;
Barry, Liz;
(June 2019)
Citizens, Politics, and Civic Technology: A Conversation with g0v and EDGI
(/isis/citation/CBB489307330/)
Book
Cooper, Caren B.;
(2016)
Citizen science: how ordinary people are changing the face of discovery
(/isis/citation/CBB007572607/)
Book
Busch, Akiko;
(2013)
The incidental steward: reflections on citizen science
(/isis/citation/CBB844467183/)
Book
Eric Topol;
(2015)
The Patient Will See You Now: The Future of Medicine is in Your Hands
(/isis/citation/CBB847674428/)
Article
Jérôme Baudry;
Élise Tancoigne;
Bruno J Strasser;
(June 2022)
Turning crowds into communities: The collectives of online citizen science
(/isis/citation/CBB205266249/)
Book
Karen Bakker;
(2024)
Gaia's Web: How Digital Environmentalism Can Combat Climate Change, Restore Biodiversity, Cultivate Empathy, and Regenerate the Earth
(/isis/citation/CBB288346560/)
Book
Meg Leta Jones;
(2024)
The Character of Consent: The History of Cookies and the Future of Technology Policy
(/isis/citation/CBB023319337/)
Book
Tonia Sutherland;
(2023)
Resurrecting the Black Body: Race and the Digital Afterlife
(/isis/citation/CBB871989303/)
Book
Nicolas Friederici;
Michel Wahome;
Mark Graham;
(2020)
Digital Entrepreneurship in Africa: How a Continent Is Escaping Silicon Valley's Long Shadow
(/isis/citation/CBB944544548/)
Book
Ana-Maria Herman;
(2023)
Reconfiguring the Museum: The Politics of Digital Display
(/isis/citation/CBB118765415/)
Article
Sean A. Valles;
Zachary Piso;
Michael O’Rourke;
(2019)
Coupled Ethical-Epistemic Analysis as a Tool for Environmental Science
(/isis/citation/CBB207222740/)
Article
Charles Dupras;
Katie Michelle Saulnier;
Yann Joly;
(October 2019)
Epigenetics, ethics, law and society: A multidisciplinary review of descriptive, instrumental, dialectical and reflexive analyses
(/isis/citation/CBB595581322/)
Article
Barbara L. Allen;
(November 2018)
Strongly Participatory Science and Knowledge Justice in an Environmentally Contested Region
(/isis/citation/CBB069762669/)
Be the first to comment!