Article ID: CBB509621042

Gall’s German Enemies (2020)


Franz Joseph Gall’s (1758–1828) proposal for a new theory about how to represent the mental faculties is well known. He replaced the traditional perception-judgement-memory triad of abstract faculties with a set of 27 highly specific faculties, many of which humans share with animals. In addition, he argued that these faculties are dependent on specific cortical areas, these being his organs of mind. After several years of presenting his new views in Vienna, he was banned from lecturing for what he considered absurd reasons. The edict enticed him to make a scientific journey through the German states, both to present his ideas to targeted audiences and to collect more cases. This trip, started in 1805, was extended to include stops in Denmark, Holland, and Switzerland before finally ending in Paris in 1807. For the most part, Gall was received with great enthusiasm in what is now Germany, but there were some individuals who strongly opposed his anatomical discoveries and skull-based doctrine. In this article, we examine the concerns and arguments raised by Johann Gotlieb Walter in Berlin, Henrik Steffens in Halle, Jakob Fidelis Ackermann in Heidelberg, and Samuel Thomas Soemmerring in Munich, as well as how Gall responded to them.

Included in

Article Paul Eling; Stanley Finger (2020) Gall and Phrenology: New perspectives. Journal of the History of the Neurosciences (pp. 1-4). unapi

Citation URI

Similar Citations

Article Paul Eling; Stanley Finger; (2020)
Franz Joseph Gall's Non-Cortical Faculties and Their Organs (/isis/citation/CBB224301715/)

Article Eling, Paul; Draaisma, Douwe; Conradi, Matthijs; (2011)
Gall's Visit to the Netherlands (/isis/citation/CBB001034913/)

Article Stanley Finger; Paul Eling; (2022)
Phrenology’s frontal sinus problem: An insurmountable obstruction? (/isis/citation/CBB298422709/)

Article Jacob Lauge Thomassen; Simon Beierholm; (2020)
Franz Joseph Gall Came to Copenhagen, and for a Brief Moment the Brain Was the Talk of the Town (/isis/citation/CBB935430086/)

Article Duichin, Marco; (2011)
Notomisti, filosofi, «cacciatori di teste»: Gall, Kant e i primordi della frenologia (/isis/citation/CBB449232524/)

Article Marc Renneville; (2020)
Matter Over Mind? The Rise and Fall of Phrenology in Nineteenth-Century France (/isis/citation/CBB316812365/)

Article Paul Eling; Stanley Finger; (2022)
Franz Joseph Gall on God and religion: “Dieu et Cerveau, rien que Dieu et cerveau!” (/isis/citation/CBB938759518/)

Book Mann, Gunter; Dumont, Franz; (1988)
Gehirn--Nerven--Seele: Anatomie und Physiologie im Umfeld S. Th. Soemmerrings (/isis/citation/CBB000047697/)

Article John van Wyhe; (2020)
Johann Gaspar Spurzheim: The St. Paul of Phrenology (/isis/citation/CBB951876615/)

Article Cornel, Tabea; (2014)
Matters of Sex and Gender in F. J. Gall's Organology: A Primary Approach (/isis/citation/CBB001551835/)

Article Harry Whitaker; Gonia Jarema; (2017)
The Split Between Gall and Spurzheim (1813–1818) (/isis/citation/CBB914152914/)

Article Hagner, Michael; (1992)
The soul and the brain between anatomy and Naturphilosophie in the early 19th century (/isis/citation/CBB000052004/)

Book Gradmann, Christoph; Simon, Jonathan; (2010)
Evaluating and Standardizing Therapeutic Agents, 1890--1950 (/isis/citation/CBB001033393/)

Essay Review Haines, Gregory; (2012)
Setting the Standards for Medicines (/isis/citation/CBB001566764/)

Book Blanchard, Pascal; (2008)
Human Zoos: Science and Spectacle in the Age of Colonial Empires (/isis/citation/CBB001033417/)

Article Piazza, Marco; (2005)
Maine de Biran e Gall. Una tappa emblematica nella ricezione francese della frenologia (/isis/citation/CBB000701026/)

Article Eglė Sakalauskaitė-Juodeikienė; Paul Eling; Stanley Finger; (2017)
The Reception of Gall’s Organology in Early-Nineteenth-Century Vilnius (/isis/citation/CBB855446621/)

Article Harry A. Whitaker; (2020)
La Revanche De Gall (/isis/citation/CBB335548506/)

Book Gudmundur Finnbogason; (2019)
Sympathetic Understanding (/isis/citation/CBB811629680/)

Authors & Contributors
Eling, Paul
Finger, Stanley
Dumont, Franz
Mann, Gunter
Wenzel, Manfred
Whitaker, Harry A.
Journal of the History of the Neurosciences
Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences
Medical History
Jahrbuch für Europäische Wissenschaftskultur
Journal of Evolutionary Economics
Metascience: An International Review Journal for the History, Philosophy and Social Studies of Science
Palgrave Macmillan
Liverpool University Press
University of Iceland Press
Brain localization
Therapeutic practice; therapy; treatment
Science and culture
Gall, Franz Joseph
Spurzheim, Johann Kaspar
Soemmerring, Samuel Thomas von
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Loder, Justus Christian von
Wenzel, Karl
Time Periods
19th century
20th century, early
18th century
20th century
Great Britain
United States

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment