Parke, Emily C. (Author)
Plutynski, Anya James (Author)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Volume: 97
Pages: 101-110
Microbial factors have been implicated in cancer risk, disease progression, treatment and prevention. The key word, however, is “implicated.” Our aim in this paper is to map out some of the tensions between competing methods, goals, and standards of evidence in cancer research with respect to the causal role of microbial factors. We discuss an array of pragmatic and epistemic trade-offs in this research area: prioritizing coarse-grained versus fine-grained explanations of the roles of microbiota in cancer; explaining general versus specific cancer targets; studying model organisms versus human patients; and understanding and explaining cancer versus developing diagnostic tools and treatments. In light of these trade-offs and the distinctive complexity and heterogeneity on both sides of the microbiome-cancer relationship, we suggest that it would be more productive and intellectually honest to frame much of this work, at least currently, in terms of generating causal hypotheses to investigate further. Claims of established causal connections between the microbiome and cancer are in many cases overstated. We also discuss the value of “black boxing” microbial causal variables in this research context and draw some general cautionary lessons for ongoing discussions of microbiomes and cancer.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Cornwall, Claudia;
(2013)
Catching Cancer: The Quest for Its Viral and Bacterial Causes
(/isis/citation/CBB001213235/)
Article
Flavia Marcacci;
(2018)
La scienza e l’ipotesi assoluta. Metodologia e logica della ricerca nell’Almagestum novum di Giovanni Battista Riccioli
(/isis/citation/CBB197851371/)
Article
André Ariew;
Yasha Rohwer;
Collin Rice;
(2017)
Galton, reversion and the quincunx: The rise of statistical explanation
(/isis/citation/CBB685480860/)
Article
Rabeharisoa, Vololona;
Bourret, Pascale;
(2009)
Staging and Weighting Evidence in Biomedicine: Comparing Clinical Practices in Cancer Genetics and Psychiatric Genetics
(/isis/citation/CBB000953579/)
Article
Joana Formosinho;
Adam Bencard;
Louise Whiteley;
(2022)
Environmentality in biomedicine: Microbiome research and the perspectival body
(/isis/citation/CBB106997198/)
Article
Mary S. Morgan;
(2019)
Exemplification and the use-values of cases and case studies
(/isis/citation/CBB151505081/)
Book
Rhodri Leng;
Gareth Leng;
(2020)
The Matter of Facts: Skepticism, Persuasion, and Evidence in Science
(/isis/citation/CBB306641216/)
Article
Labinger, Jay A.;
Weininger, Stephen J.;
(2005)
Controversy in Chemistry: How Do You Prove a Negative? The Cases of Phlogiston and Cold Fusion
(/isis/citation/CBB001032168/)
Article
Peter Achinstein;
(2023)
Disregarding evidence: Reasonable options for Newton and Rutherford?
(/isis/citation/CBB649526523/)
Article
Moran Levy;
(2022)
Adequate trials: How the search for a cure shaped leukemia diagnosis
(/isis/citation/CBB342218958/)
Article
Manuela Rizzi;
Matteo Gallazzi;
Francesca Tosetti;
Lorenzo Mortara;
(2020)
The tumor-endothelium cell interaction in pioneering studies and the revisited concept on the angiogenesis process during tumor progression and metastasis
(/isis/citation/CBB704955825/)
Article
Giamila Fantuzzi;
(2017)
Cancer is a propagandist
(/isis/citation/CBB627868817/)
Article
Wunderlich, Volker;
(2011)
“Er korrigiert meine Anschauung und führt sie weiter fort.” Kommentare von David von Hansemann zu der Schrift von Theodor Boveri Zur Frage der Entstehung maligner Tumoren (1914)
(/isis/citation/CBB001220462/)
Article
Sara Green;
Mie S. Dam;
Mette N. Svendsen;
(2021)
Mouse avatars of human cancers: the temporality of translation in precision oncology
(/isis/citation/CBB113220248/)
Book
Agnes Arnold-Forster;
(2021)
The Cancer Problem: Malignancy in Nineteenth-Century Britain
(/isis/citation/CBB230458927/)
Article
Morgan, Gregory J.;
(2014)
Ludwik Gross, Sarah Stewart, and the 1950s Discoveries of Gross Murine Leukemia Virus and Polyoma Virus
(/isis/citation/CBB001421646/)
Article
Neeraja Sankaran;
Ton van Helvoort;
(2016)
Andrewes's Christmas Fairy Tale: Atypical Thinking About Cancer Aetiology in 1935
(/isis/citation/CBB089322763/)
Article
Jack S. Cohen;
Peter F. Daly;
(2022)
History of Research on Phospholipid Metabolism and Applications to the Detection, Diagnosis, and Treatment of Cancer
(/isis/citation/CBB937672031/)
Article
Sharma, Padmanee;
Allison, James P.;
(2012)
Lloyd J. Old (1933--2011)
(/isis/citation/CBB001320473/)
Article
Natasa Kustrimovic;
Daniela Gallo;
Andrea De Lerna Barbaro;
Eliana Piantanida;
Lorenzo Mortara;
Maria Laura Tanda;
(2023)
The discovery of TNF-alpha: A historical perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB446223292/)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Social Studies of Science
Medicina Historica
Angewandte Chemie International Edition
Archives Internationales d'Histoire des Sciences
Be the first to comment!