Is animal culture a real entity or is it rather just in the eye of the beholder? The concept of culture began to be increasingly used in the context of animal behaviour research around the 1960s. Despite its success, it is not clear that it represents what philosophers have traditionally thought to be a natural kind. In this article I will show, however, how conceiving of animal culture in this fashion has played a role in the “culture wars”, and what lessons we can draw from this. First, an analysis of the epistemological landscape of author keywords related to the concept of animal cultures is presented, thus vindicating the centrality of the concept in describing a broad range of findings. A minimal definition that encompasses the multiple strands of research incorporating the notion of culture is proposed. I then systematically enumerate the ways in which culture thus conceived cannot be considered a natural kind in the study of animal behaviour. This is accomplished by reviewing the efforts and possibilities of anchoring the elusive idea in specific mechanisms, homologies, selection pressures, homeostatic property clusters, or alternatively, its reduction or elimination. Finally, a plausible interpretation of the scientific status of the animal culture concept is suggested that is compatible with both its well established use in animal behaviour research and its inferential limitations. Culture plays the role of a well-established epistemic kind, a node that connects different areas of research on common themes.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Clement Levallois;
(2018)
The Development of Sociobiology in Relation to Animal Behavior Studies, 1946–1975
(/isis/citation/CBB162818555/)
Article
Vicedo, Marga;
(2009)
The Father of Ethology and the Foster Mother of Ducks: Konrad Lorenz as Expert on Motherhood
(/isis/citation/CBB000951597/)
Book
Nicolas Langlitz;
(2020)
Chimpanzee Culture Wars
(/isis/citation/CBB054916365/)
Article
Weinstein, Deborah F.;
(2004)
Culture at Work: Family Therapy and the Culture Concept in Post-World War II America
(/isis/citation/CBB000671302/)
Article
Anna Klassen;
(2021)
Methodological Signatures in Early Ethology: The Problem of Animal Subjectivity
(/isis/citation/CBB504631735/)
Article
Wilson, David A. H.;
(2002)
Experimental Animal Behaviour Studies: The Loss of Initiative in Britain 100 Years Ago
(/isis/citation/CBB000202701/)
Article
Bradshaw, G. A.;
(2010)
An Ape Among Many: Animal Co-Authorship and Trans-species Epistemic Authority
(/isis/citation/CBB001023610/)
Article
Montgomery, Georgina M.;
(2005)
Place, Practice and Primatology: Clarence Ray Carpenter, Primate Communication and the Development of Field Methodology, 1931--1945
(/isis/citation/CBB000670732/)
Article
Sealy, Spencer G.;
(2009)
Cuckoos and Their Fosterers: Uncovering Details of Edward Blyth's Field Experiments
(/isis/citation/CBB000931235/)
Book
Werber, Niels;
(2013)
Ameisengesellschaften: eine Faszinationsgeschichte
(/isis/citation/CBB001551279/)
Article
Toivanen, Juhana;
(2011)
Peter of John Olivi on the Psychology of Animal Action
(/isis/citation/CBB001210525/)
Book
Schulkin, Jay;
(2005)
Curt Richter: A Life in the Laboratory
(/isis/citation/CBB000600030/)
Article
Jorge Torres;
(2021)
Philia: the biological foundations of Aristotle’s ethics
(/isis/citation/CBB084805314/)
Thesis
Munz, Tania;
(2007)
Of Birds and Bees: Karl von Frisch, Konrad Lorenz and the Science of Animals,1908--1973
(/isis/citation/CBB001561473/)
Article
Dewsbury, Donald A.;
(2002)
The Role of Evidence in Interpretations of the Scientific Work of Karl Lashley
(/isis/citation/CBB000202773/)
Article
Rapchan, Eliane Sebeika;
(2012)
Cultura e inteligência: reflexões antropológicas sobre aspectos não físicos da evolução em chimpanzés e humanos
(/isis/citation/CBB001420597/)
Article
Pettit, Michael;
(2010)
The Problem of Raccoon Intelligence in Behaviourist America
(/isis/citation/CBB001023005/)
Article
Gordon L. Miller;
(2021)
The rain calls of frogs and the reigning paradigm of American herpetology
(/isis/citation/CBB960366223/)
Article
Roling, Bernd;
(2011)
Syllogismus Brutorum: Die Diskussion der animalischen Rationalität bei Albertus Magnus und ihre Rezeption im Mittelalter und in der frühen Neuzeit
(/isis/citation/CBB001200457/)
Article
Gillaspy, James Arthur, Jr.;
Brinegar, Jennifer L.;
Bailey, Robert E.;
(2014)
Operant Psychology Makes a Splash---In Marine Mammal Training (1955--1965)
(/isis/citation/CBB001420017/)
Be the first to comment!