Witteveen, Joeri (Author)
Müller-Wille, Staffan (Author)
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Volume: 42
Issue: 4
Pages: 43
What is it to make an error in the identification of a named taxonomic group? In this article we argue that the conditions for being in error about the identity of taxonomic groups through their names have a history, and that the possibility of committing such errors is contingent on the regime of institutions and conventions governing taxonomy and nomenclature at any given point in time. More specifically, we claim that taxonomists today can be in error about the identity of taxonomic groups in a way that Carl Linnaeus (1707–1778), who is routinely cited as the “founder” of modern taxonomy and nomenclature, simply could not be. Starting from a remarkable recent study into Linnaeus’s naming of Elephas maximus that led to the (putative) discovery of a (putative) nomenclatural error by him, we reconsider what it could mean to discover that Linnaeus misidentified a biological taxon in applying his taxon names. Through a further case study in Linnaean botany, we show that his practices of (re)applying names in taxonomic revisions reveal a take on determining “which taxon is which” that is strikingly different from that of contemporary taxonomists. Linnaeus, we argue, adopted a practice-based, hands-on concept of taxa as “nominal spaces” that could continue to represent the same taxon even if all its former members had been reallocated to other taxa.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Veuille, Michel;
Drouin, Jean-Marc;
Deleporte, Pierre;
Silvain, Jean-François;
(2008)
Linnaeus: Systématique et biodiversité
Article
Toma, Constantin;
Murariu, Dumitru;
(2007)
300 Years since the Birth of Carl von Linné---Founder of the Binomial Nomenclature
Article
Delange, Yves;
(2007)
Carl Linné ou le génie de la classification des régnes du vivant
Article
Müller-Wille, Staffan;
Reeds, Karen;
(2007)
A Translation of Carl Linnaeus's Introduction to Genera Plantarum (1737)
Article
Breidbach, Olaf;
Ghiselin, Michael T.;
(2006)
Baroque Classification: A Missing Chapter in the History of Systematics
Book
Prat, Daniel;
Raynal-Roques, Aline;
Roguenant, Albert;
(2008)
Peut-on classer le vivant?: Linné et la systématique aujourd'hui
Article
Müller-Wille, Staffan;
Charmantier, Isabelle;
(2012)
Natural History and Information Overload: The Case of Linnaeus
Book
Michael Ohl;
(2018)
The Art of Naming
Thesis
Cirillo, Thomas McCulloch;
(2012)
Categorizing Difference: Classification, Biology, and Politics in Aristotelian Philosophy
Chapter
Hoquet, Thierry;
(2008)
Traduire Linné aujourd'hui. Texte de science ou objet philosophique et historique?
Book
Ereshefsky, Marc;
(2000)
The Poverty of the Linnaean Hierarchy: A Philosophical Study of Biological Taxonomy
Article
Winsor, Mary P.;
(2001)
Cain on Linnaeus: The scientist-historian as unanalysed entity
Article
Millie Schurch;
(2019)
‘All the Productions of That Nature’: Ephemera, Mycology and Sexual Classification at the Bulstrode Estate
Article
Funk, Holger;
(2012)
Towards Bibliographical Accuracy: A Clarification of Some Obscure References in Linnaeus's Musa Cliffortiana (1736)
Article
Myers, Charles W.;
Stothers, Richard B.;
(2006)
The Myth of Hylas Revisited: The Frog Name Hyla and Other Commentary on Specimen Medicum of J. N. Laurenti, the “Father of Herpetology”
Article
McDowell, Paula;
(2012)
Of Grubs and Other Insects: Constructing the Categories of “Ephemera” and “Literature” in Eighteenth-Century British Writing
Article
Theodore W. Pietsch;
Hans Aili;
(2023)
Peter Artedi's early observations of the spotted hyena and other exotic animals during a visit to London (1734–1735)
Article
Stéphane Schmitt;
(2022)
Les travaux zoologiques de Jacob Theodor Klein (1685-1759) et leur réception en France: Une opposition mesurée au linnéisme
Book
Michael Köhncke;
(2019)
Rattus, Mus und Pantholops – Säugetiere und ihre Namensgeber. Ein Blick in die Geschichte der Zoologie von 1758 bis 1849. Dargestellt an den Autorender Säugetiergattungen in Wort und Bild. 100 biographische Skizzen und 500 Gattungen.
Chapter
Frängsmyr, Tore;
(2001)
Linnaeus and the Classification Tradition in Sweden
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Noesis: Travaux du Comité Roumain d'Histoire et de Philosophie des Sciences
Annals of the History and Philosophy of Biology
Book History
Journal for Eighteenth-Century Studies
Be the first to comment!