Caruana, Louis (Author)
Substantia: An International Journal of the History of Chemistry
Volume: 1
Issue: 1
Pages: 49-53
Galileo Galilei’s contribution during the early stages of the scientific revolution and his clash with the Catholic Church have been discussed, studied, and written about for many decades. There are indications however that recent work in this area has tended to underestimate the fact that Galileo had a particular style. By style here I mean a particular combination of behavioural features that are specific to a person or a historical period. Style of course can be related to behaviour in general, but what is relevant in this paper is the combination of dispositions that determine a particular way of engaging in science, as discussed by scholars like A.C. Crombie. Galileo, I will argue, had a scientific style marked by overconfidence. He tended to downplay the importance of obvious contradictory evidence that undermined his claims, and he did this by producing auxiliary hypotheses that sometimes verged on the extravagant. If we focus on this somewhat neglected aspect of his style, some interesting new questions emerge: To what extent did Galileo depend on such auxiliary hypotheses? How insecure did they render his position? And how ad hoc were they? In this paper, I explore these questions by comparing two important debates: one about the nature of water and buoyancy, the other about cosmology. Since the main features of the cosmology debate, the one involving Galileo’s defence of heliocentrism, are well known, I will dedicate more time to the water debate, before proceeding to highlight the elements of style that are common to both debates, and to evaluate the relevance of these elements for current understanding of scientific practice.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Chapter
Patricia Radelet-de-Grave;
(2015)
La chute des corps, le mouvement des corps célestes et l'unification des mondes
(/isis/citation/CBB951522195/)
Chapter
Pietro Daniel Omodeo;
(2015)
Riflessioni sul moto terrestre nel Rinascimento: tra filosofia naturale, meccanica e cosmologia
(/isis/citation/CBB678565435/)
Article
Joseph Zepeda;
(2019)
Galileo’s Letter to the Grand Duchess Christina: Genre, Coherence, and the Structure of Dispute
(/isis/citation/CBB853350918/)
Article
Franco Giudice;
(2020)
Tobie Matthew, Francis Bacon, and Galileo's Letter to Benedetto Castelli
(/isis/citation/CBB844150617/)
Article
Luigi Guerrini;
(2004)
Momenti poco noti del dibattito intorno al "Dialogo dei massimi sistemi del mondo"
(/isis/citation/CBB959940502/)
Thesis
Sugar, Gabrielle;
(2012)
The New Universe: Conceptions of the Cosmos in the Literary Imagination of Early Modern England
(/isis/citation/CBB001567357/)
Article
Nunzio Allocca;
(2014)
La luna e il libro della natura. Su Italo Calvino e l’eredità di Galileo
(/isis/citation/CBB365165189/)
Book
Danielson, Dennis Richard;
(2014)
“Paradise Lost” and the Cosmological Revolution
(/isis/citation/CBB001510030/)
Book
Anna De Pace;
(2020)
Galileo lettore di Copernico
(/isis/citation/CBB163414161/)
Chapter
Asim Gangopadhyaya;
(2019)
Il contributo di Galileo alla meccanica
(/isis/citation/CBB589493169/)
Book
Bucciantini, Massimo;
(2003)
Galileo e Keplero: filosofia, cosmologia e teologia nell'Età della Controriforma
(/isis/citation/CBB000950726/)
Chapter
Ivana Gambaro;
(2016)
Sulla natura dei corpi celesti: Una disputa secentesca nell’ambiente scientifico italiano
(/isis/citation/CBB869829992/)
Article
Nonnoi, Giancarlo;
(2001)
La scienza e la filosofia galileiane nel “New World” di John Wilkins
(/isis/citation/CBB000101192/)
Chapter
Thomas B. Settle;
(2015)
On the Medieval Empirical Know-how Behind Precise Early Modern Science: The Case of Galileo
(/isis/citation/CBB902599052/)
Book
Edmondo Lupieri;
Paolo Ponzio;
(2019)
Chi ha rubato i cieli? : Galileo, la "Lettera a Cristina" e le origini della modernità
(/isis/citation/CBB946509573/)
Chapter
Thomas B. Settle;
(2015)
On the Medieval Empirical Know-how Behind Precise Early Modern Science : the case of Galileo
(/isis/citation/CBB083287804/)
Article
Festa, Egidio;
Roux, Sophie;
(2006)
La moindre petite force peut mouvoir un corps sur un plan horizontal: l'émergence d'un principe mécanique et son devenir cosmologique
(/isis/citation/CBB000931269/)
Article
Spranzi-Zuber, Marta;
(2005)
Galileo's “Dialogue on the Two Chief World Systems”: Rhetoric and Dialogue
(/isis/citation/CBB000670802/)
Book
Biro, Jacqueline;
(2009)
On Earth as in Heaven: Cosmography and the Shape of the Earth from Copernicus to Descartes
(/isis/citation/CBB001032983/)
Book
Maurizio Torrini;
(2021)
Galileo nel Tempo
(/isis/citation/CBB428854625/)
Be the first to comment!