IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB500354678

Madness as Method: On Locke’s Thought Experiments About Personal Identity (2018)

Tabb, Kathryn (Author)

British Journal for the History of Philosophy
Volume: 26
Issue: 5
Pages: 871-889

DOI: 10.1080/09608788.2017.1350936

URI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09608788.2017.1350936

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Consciousness Philosophy Identity Thought experiments Experimental method Methodology of science; scientific method Mental disorders and diseases 17th century Locke, John

John Locke is famous for popularizing the method of the philosophical thought experiment in discussions of personal identity; the cases introduced in the second edition of An Essay Concerning Understanding (1694) are still employed by contemporary philosophers. Here I argue that Locke’s method is nonetheless importantly different from later efforts in ways that can help us better appreciate his larger projects. Rather than pumping the reader’s intuitions in support of his preferred account, Locke’s thought experiments serve to illustrate common errors in assessments of identity that he sees as particularly prevalent and problematic. Locke defends his idea of ‘person’ otherwise, through what I call his ‘lived experiments’: observations about linguistic usage that serve to illustrate the term’s role in practical reasoning. I focus especially on Locke’s example of the forensic status of the madman. Examples like these do not, for Locke, demonstrate the intuitiveness of his analysis, but rather bolster his case that it is the right analysis, given his broader commitments. They serve to illustrate why Locke’s preferred criterion for the identity of persons – sameness of consciousness – contributes to a demonstrative science of morality, where a rival account – sameness of substance – falls short.

...More

Included in

Article Alberto Vanzo (2018) Introduction. British Journal for the History of Philosophy (pp. 805-811). unapi

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB500354678/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Weinberg, Shelley; (2012)
The Metaphysical Fact of Consciousness in Locke's Theory of Personal Identity (/isis/citation/CBB001210531/)

Article Wolfe, Charles; Salter, Alan; (2009)
Empiricism contra Experiment: Harvey, Locke and the Revisionist View of Experimental Philosophy (/isis/citation/CBB001031881/)

Book Timothy M. Harrison; (2020)
Coming To: Consciousness and Natality in Early Modern England (/isis/citation/CBB273148572/)

Book Seigel, Jerrold E.; (2005)
The Idea of the Self: Thought and Experience in Western Europe since the Seventeenth Century (/isis/citation/CBB000930043/)

Book Anstey, Peter R.; (2011)
John Locke and Natural Philosophy (/isis/citation/CBB001231545/)

Book Archer, Margaret Scotford; (2000)
Being Human: The Problem of Agency (/isis/citation/CBB000102323/)

Chapter Dolling, Lisa M.; (2008)
Practical Arrangements and Fictitious Use: Bohr's Photon Box (/isis/citation/CBB000953880/)

Article Hsueh Qu; (2016)
Prescription, Description, and Hume's Experimental Method (/isis/citation/CBB423983702/)

Article Yaël Nazé; (2014)
Structure de l’univers. Quand l’observation guide la théorie… ou pas (/isis/citation/CBB774539576/)

Thesis Hartunian, Lydia B.; (2002)
The Role of Consciousness in Locke's Theory of Mind: Problems and Consequences (/isis/citation/CBB001562543/)

Chapter Meli, Domenico Bertoloni; (2007)
Experiment in Newton's Principia: The First Edition (/isis/citation/CBB001032048/)

Article Maurice A. Finocchiaro; (2020)
Vincenzo Galilei’s Musicology and Galileo’s Science: Methodological Comparison and Contrast (/isis/citation/CBB582052194/)

Article Storriea, Stefan; (2012)
What Is It the Unbodied Spirit Cannot Do? Berkeley and Barrow on the Nature of Geometrical Construction (/isis/citation/CBB001211013/)

Article Gigliotti, Gianna; (2006)
“Videre aude”: Galileo nel neokantismo marburghese (/isis/citation/CBB000931265/)

Article Crignon, Claire; (2013)
The Debate about methodus medendi during the Second Half of the Seventeenth Century in England: Modern Philosophical Readings of Classical Medical Empiricism in Bacon, Nedham, Willis and Boyle (/isis/citation/CBB001213580/)

Thesis Domski, Mary; (2003)
Geometry and Experimental Method in Locke, Newton and Kant (/isis/citation/CBB001561970/)

Book Janiak, Andrew; Schliesser, Erick; (2012)
Interpreting Newton: Critical Essays (/isis/citation/CBB001500334/)

Book Goodey, C. F.; (2011)
A History of Intelligence and “Intellectual Disability”: The Shaping of Psychology in Early Modern Europe (/isis/citation/CBB001221401/)

Article Oberto Marrama; (2017)
Consciousness, Ideas of Ideas and Animation in Spinoza’s Ethics (/isis/citation/CBB564753509/)

Article Carter, Benjamin; (2010)
Ralph Cudworth and the Theological Origins of Consciousness (/isis/citation/CBB001035617/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}