How Mechanisms Explain Interfield Cooperation: Biological–Chemical Study of Plant Growth Hormones in Utrecht and Pasadena, 1930–1938 (2017)
Schürch, Caterina (Author)
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Volume: 39
Issue: 3
Pages: 16
This article examines to what extent a particular case of cross-disciplinary research in the 1930s was structured by mechanistic reasoning. For this purpose, it identifies the interfield theories that allowed biologists and chemists to use each other’s techniques and findings, and that provided the basis for the experiments performed to identify plant growth hormones and to learn more about their role in the mechanism of plant growth. In 1930, chemists and biologists in Utrecht and Pasadena began to cooperatively study plant growth. I will argue that these researchers decided to join forces because they believed to rely on each other’s findings and methods to solve their research problems adequately. In the course of the cooperation, organic chemists arrived at isolating plant growth hormones by using a test method developed in plant physiology. This achievement, in turn, facilitated biologists’ investigation of the mechanism of plant growth. Researchers eventually believed to have the means to study the relation between a substance’s molecular structure and its physiological activity. The way they conceptualized the problem of identifying hormones and unraveling the mechanism of plant growth, as well as their actual research actions are compatible with the new mechanists’ account of mechanism research. The study illustrates that focusing on researchers’ mechanistic reasoning can contribute considerably to explaining the structure of cross-disciplinary research projects.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Jones, Dewi;
(2006)
John Lloyd Williams (1854--1945): Profile of a Snowdonian Botanist
Article
Hu, Zonggang;
(2006)
Dr. Tchen-Ngo Liou's Sino-French Northwest Scientific Expedition in China
Article
Emily Simpson;
(2020)
Ant Mazes and Astronomy: Harlow Shapley's Entomological Experiments at Mount Wilson Observatory and Pasadena, California
Article
Zhang Zhihui;
(2021)
Emigration or return? International mobility and Theodore von Kármán's Chinese students and associates
Book
Ayres, P. G.;
(2005)
Harry Marshall Ward and the Fungal Thread of Death
Article
Justin Begley;
(2021)
John Hill (1714?–1775) on ‘Plant Sleep’: experimental physiology and the limits of comparative analysis
Article
Brown, Harvey;
(2013)
The Theory of the Rise of Sap in Trees: Some Historical and Conceptual Remarks
Article
David P. D. Munns;
(2021)
The age of biology: When plant physiology was in the center of American life science
Article
Perru, Olivier;
(2003)
L'unité dynamique du végétal: Du Petit Thouars (1758-1831)
Article
Munns, David P.D.;
(2015)
The Phytotronist and the Phenotype: Plant Physiology, Big Science, and a Cold War Biology of the Whole Plant
Book
Höxtermann, Ekkehard;
Kaasch, Joachim;
Kaasch, Michael;
(2001)
Berichte zur Geschichte und Theorie der Ökologie und weitere Beiträge zur 9. Jahrestagung der DGGTB in Neuburg a.d. Donau 2000
Article
Leonelli, Sabina;
(2007)
Arabidopsis, the Botanical Drosophila: From Mouse Cress to Model Organism
Article
Hartley, Beryl;
(2010)
Exploring and Communicating Knowledge of Trees in the Early Royal Society
Article
Finlay, Mark R.;
(2011)
Behind the Barbed Wired of Manzanar: Guayule and the Search for Natural Rubber
Article
Jen McComb;
(2018)
Arthur James McComb 1936–2017
Article
Claudia Zatta;
(2022)
Early Greek Philosophy on the Question of Life: Plants’ Physiology and Life from the Presocratics to Aristotle
Book
Brian Gunning;
Roland Jahnke;
Marion Manifold;
Bruce Wellington;
(2021)
First Know the Nature of Things: Celebrating the Life and Work of Denis John Carr (1915-2008) : Botanist, Scholar, Mentor
Article
Benjamin Le Roux;
(2017)
« Lui seul doit être glorifié », science et religion dans l’œuvre d’Henri Devaux (1862-1956)
Article
Werner, Petra;
Holmes, Frederic L.;
(2002)
Justus Liebig and the Plant Physiologists
Article
Koehler, P.;
(2007)
Edward Tangl (1848--1908)
Be the first to comment!