In this paper, three problems that have hardly been noticed or even gone unnoticed in the available literature in the cosmology of Philolaus are addressed. They have to do with the interrelationships of the orbits of the Earth, the Sun, and the Moon around the Central Fire and all three of them constitute potentially insurmountable obstacles within the context of the Philolaic system. The first difficulty is Werner Ekschmitt’s claim that the Philolaic system cannot account for the length of the day (νυχϑήμερον). It is shown that this problem can be solved with the help of the distinction between the synodic day and the sidereal day. The other two problems discussed in this paper are concerned with two hitherto unnoticed deficiencies in the explanation of lunar eclipses in the Philolaic system. The Philolaic system cannot account for long-lasting lunar eclipses and according to the internal logic of the system, during lunar eclipses the Moon enters the shadow of the Earth from the wrong side. It is almost unbelievable that nobody, from the Pythagoreans themselves up to recent authors, has noticed these two serious deficiencies, and especially the latter, in the cosmology of Philolaus the Pythagorean.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Samos, Aristarco de;
Commandino, Federico;
Massa Esteve, María Rosa;
(2007)
Sobre los tamaños y las distancias del sol y la luna
Book
Brunier, Serge;
Luminet, Jean-Pierre;
(2000)
Glorious Eclipses: Their Past, Present and Future
Article
K. Rupa;
S.K. Uma;
Padmaja Venugopal;
S. Balachandra Rao;
(2023)
References to 'Parallel Phenomenon’ in Indian Astronomy and Inscriptions
Article
Mozaffari, S. Mohammad;
(2013)
Limitations of Methods: The Accuracy of the Values Measured for the Earth's/Sun's Orbital Elements in the Middle East, A.D. 800--1500, Part 1
Article
Phillip S. Horky;
(2024)
Order and chaos in the ancient Greco-Roman philosophical imagination
Article
Stephenson, F. Richard;
Baylis, Joshua T.;
(2012)
Early Chinese Observations of Occultations of Planets by the Moon
Article
R. N. Iyengar;
Sunder Chakravarty;
(2021)
Transit of sun through the seasonal nakṣatra cycle in the Vṛddha-Gārgīya Jyotiṣa
Article
Benítez, Sixto Ramón Giménez;
Alejandro Martín López;
Granada, Anahi;
(2006)
The Sun and the Moon as Marks of Time and Space among the Mocovíes of the Argentinian Chaco
Article
Britton, John P.;
(2007)
Studies in Babylonian Lunar Theory: Part I. Empirical Elements for Modeling Lunar and Solar Anomalies
Article
Carman, Christián C.;
(2014)
Two Problems in Aristarchus's Treatise On the sizes and distances of the sun and moon
Article
Berggren, J. L.;
Sidoli, Nathan;
(2007)
Aristarchus's On the Sizes and Distances of the Sun and the Moon: Greek and Arabic Texts
Article
Vance R. Tiede;
(2018)
ΒΩΜΟΣ ΔΩΔΕΚΑ ΘΕΩΝ / Altar of the Twelve Gods: An Astro-Archaeological Analysis
Article
Pier Franco Nali;
(2022)
Annibale Riccò and the catoptric proof of the Earth’s curvature
Article
Miguel Á. Granada;
(2022)
Johannes Kepler. The Sun as the Heart of the World
Article
Topper, David;
(2003)
Colluding with Galileo: On Mueller's Critique of My Analysis of Galileo's Sunspots Argument
Article
Themis G. Dallas;
(2018)
Are the Moons of Ninnion a Representation of Earthshine?
Article
Lars Gislén;
C. J. Eade;
(2019)
The calendars of Southeast Asia. 5: Eclipse calculations, and the longitudes of the Sun, Moon and planets in Burmese and Thai astronomy
Article
Leslie V. Morrison;
F. Richard Stephenson;
Catherine Y. Hohenkerk;
(2020)
Fotheringham’s 1920 Accelerations of the Sun and Moon Revisited
Article
Lu Dalong;
(2020)
The Solar and Lunar Theories of Qizheng Tuibu (1477)
Article
Ralph Neuhäuser;
Dagmar L. Neuhäuser;
(2024)
Occultation records in the Royal Frankish Annals for A.D. 807: Knowledge transfer from Arabia to Frankia?
Be the first to comment!