Article ID: CBB490328457

Kleist vs. Musschenbroek – a difficult way to truth (2018)

unapi

On October 11, 1745, a German scientist Ewald Georg (Jürgen) Kleist in Cammin in Pommern (today Kamień Pomorski) discovered both the phenomenon of storing electricity in a glass vessel with water, and a new device – an electric capacitor. Kleist quickly and correctly announced his discovery to the scientific community.The greatest help in confirming the discovery and its publication was received by Kleist from Daniel Gralath who was active in the first Polish Society for Experimental Physics Societas Physicae Experimentalis in Gdańsk.At the beginning of 1746, in the Dutch Leiden, in the workshop of the famous professor Pieter Musschenbroek, an experiment was conducted similar to the one in Cammin. The information about the Leiden experiment quickly reached Paris, the centre of European science of that time, and which lead to a proclamation of a new, very important physical discovery.  The experiment gained wide publicity in Europe thanks to numerous public repetitions. The French promoter of the Leiden experiment was physicist Jean-Antoine Nollet.The discoverer’s fame was unjustly attributed to Musschenbroek and Leiden, although Daniel Gralath reported Nollet’s letter about Kleist’s priority. From the moment of discovery to modern times, scientific publications in the field of physics and history of science often misrepresent the person of the discoverer, the place of discovery and its name.The aim of the article is to present a broad overview of the reports, descriptions and opinions contained in scientific publications about the discovery. In the review presented in the article, 117 books are divided by country of issue, language and time of publication. The most frequent errors were classified and assigned to the analyzed publications. The result turned out to be surprising, as only 6 items were free of errors, and in the remaining, 254 errors were found. Unfortunately, in both former and contemporary publications, Kleist is sometimes ignored, and even if noticed, his discovery is usually depreciated in various ways. It may come as a surprise that the first two works on the history of electrical research written in the eighteenth century by Daniel Gralath and Joseph Priestley correctly and profoundly convey the course of events and the priority of Kleist’s discovery. It turns out that the French untrue version of the history of this finding is still alive, especially in European countries, so that pupils, students and physics enthusiasts receive a false message about this important discovery.In the circle of reliable researchers in the history of science, the priority of Kleist’s discovery is widely recognized, but even they have a problem with naming the electric capacitor discovered by the Cammin physicist differently than the Leiden jar. One of the reasons for the poor knowledge of Kleist and his experiment is scant scientific literature on the subject and the ignorance of the source texts written by the Cammin explorer. This gap is bridged by a scientific monograph written by the author of the present article. The text of this paper complements the information presented in the author’s book entitled Ewald Georg Kleist – Wielki odkrywca z małego miasta (A great discoverer from a small town): Kamień Pomorski 1745 (Warszawa: Instytut Historii Nauki PAN, Stowarzyszenie Elektryków Polskich, Zachodniopomorski Uniwersytet Technologiczny w Szczecinie, 2018).

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB490328457/

Similar Citations

Article Cibelle Celestino Silva; Peter Heering; (2018)
Re-examining the Early History of the Leiden Jar: Stabilization and Variation in Transforming a Phenomenon into a Fact (/isis/citation/CBB231128053/)

Article David Evan Pence; (2022)
Closing the Loop: Ewald von Kleist and the Origins of the Leyden Jar (/isis/citation/CBB256458041/)

Article Coenen, Anton; Fine, Edward; Zayachkivska, Oksana; (2014)
Adolf Beck: A Forgotten Pioneer in Electroencephalography (/isis/citation/CBB001420788/)

Article Michael Bycroft; (2019)
Hindsight, Tradition, and National Styles in the Prehistory of the Leyden Jar (/isis/citation/CBB278674357/)

Article Home, R. W.; (1979)
Nollet and Boerhaave: A note on 18th century ideas about electricity and fire (/isis/citation/CBB000007054/)

Article Bertucci, Paola; (2005)
Sparking Controversy: Jean Antoine Nollet and Medical Electricity South of the Alps (/isis/citation/CBB000610413/)

Chapter Carmen J. Giunta; Vera V. Mainz; Julianna Poole-Sawyer; Gregory S. Girolami; (2021)
Periodicity in Britain: The Periodic Tables of Odling and Newlands (/isis/citation/CBB055966538/)

Chapter Mary Virginia Orna; Marco Fontani; Carmen J. Giunta; Vera V. Mainz; Gregory S. Girolami; (2021)
Discovery of Three Elements Predicted by Mendeleev’s Table: Gallium, Scandium, and Germanium (/isis/citation/CBB197646237/)

Article Roland Jackson; (2020)
Eunice Foote, John Tyndall and a question of priority (/isis/citation/CBB580452378/)

Article Laura Elizabeth Smith; E. Allen Driggers; (2023)
‘Ex Pede Herculem’: Sloths, Slavery, and Southern Fossil Collection in The Nineteenth Century (/isis/citation/CBB397135024/)

Article Yoshiteru Maeno; Yoji Hisamatsu; Kazuhiro Egashira; (2023)
Kenji Yoshihara (1929-2022): Shedding Light on the Work of Masataka Ogawa on His Discovery of the Element "Nipponium." An Obituary-Tribute (/isis/citation/CBB410779174/)

Article John van Wyhe; (2016)
The impact of A. R. Wallace's Sarawak Law paper reassessed (/isis/citation/CBB120840296/)

Authors & Contributors
Mainz, Vera V.
Giunta, Carmen J.
Girolami, Gregory S.
Laura Elizabeth Smith
Yann Piot
Pence, David Evan
Concepts
Electricity; magnetism
Scientific priority
Discovery in science
Experiments and experimentation
Leyden jar
Chemical elements
Time Periods
18th century
19th century
21st century
20th century
17th century
Places
United States
South America
Switzerland
Poland
France
Great Britain
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment