Mother-blaming revisited: Gender, cinematography, and infant research in the heyday of psychoanalysis (2024)
This article examines cinematographic observational studies of infants conducted by a loosely connected group of female psychologists and physicians in the USA from the 1930s to the 1960s. Largely forgotten today, these practitioners realized detailed and carefully planned research projects about infant behavior in a variety of settings—from the laboratory to the well-baby clinic. Although their studies were in conversation with better-known works, such as John Bowlby's research on attachment and René Spitz's films on institutionalized infants, they differed in a close examination of individual characteristics of babies and a critical attitude toward contemporary notions of ‘pathological mothering’. In closely following the work of several researchers, including but not limited to pediatrician Margaret Fries (1898–1987), the clinical psychologist Sibylle Escalona (1915–96) and her team members—child psychiatrist Mary Leitch (1914–?) and avant-garde photographer Ellen Auerbach (1906–2004)—and psychologist Anneliese Korner (1918–2010), I argue that their cinematographic works shed a more nuanced light on the landscape of infant research and child psychiatry in the mid 20th century, and open a way for alternative readings of gender, psychoanalysis, and scientific observation at that time.
...MoreArticle Bonnie Evans; Janet Harbord (2024) Film, observation and the mind. History of the Human Sciences (pp. 3-11).
Similar Citations
Article
Geneviève Aubert;
(2016)
Cinema and Neuroscience: Development and Application of Cinematography in the Field of the Neurosciences
Article
Mieneke te Hennepe;
(2023)
Van Leeuwenhoek – the film: remaking memory in Dutch science cinema 1925–c.1960
Article
Carlos Tabernero;
(2018)
The Changing Nature of Modernization Discourses in Documentary Films
Book
Nora Doyle;
(2018)
Maternal Bodies: Redefining Motherhood in Early America
Article
Genter, Robert;
(2010)
“We All Go a Little Mad Sometimes”: Alfred Hitchcock, American Psychoanalysis, and the Construction of the Cold War Psychopath
Article
Peter J. Koehler;
Bregt Lameris;
(2016)
The Magnus-Rademaker Scientific Film Collection: Ethical Issues on Animal Experimentation (1908–1940)
Article
Eleanor Louson;
(2018)
Taking Spectacle Seriously: Wildlife Film and the Legacy of Natural History Display
Article
Oliver Gaycken;
(2021)
Film ist. (1–6): An Exemplary Use of the Encyclopaedia Cinematographica
Book
Rockett, Kevin;
Rockett, Emer;
(2011)
Magic Lantern, Panorama and Moving Picture Shows in Ireland, 1786--1909
Article
Jackson, J. Kasi;
(2008)
Gender, Mad Scientists and Nanotechnology
Article
Katie Joice;
(2021)
Mothering in the frame: Cinematic microanalysis and the pathogenic mother, 1945–67
Article
Grant, Jane;
(2013)
Soft Moon: Exploring Matter and Mutability in Narratives and Histories of the Earth-Moon System
Article
Seth Barry Watter;
(2024)
The discovery of synchrony: By means of the projector as a scientific instrument
Chapter
Samantha Evans;
(2017)
Observing Humans
Chapter
Endo, Yukihide;
(2011)
Women and Science in Japanese Anime: A Challenge to the Traditional Construction of Female Identity
Article
Laura Tisdall;
(2021)
‘We have come to be destroyed’: The ‘extraordinary’ child in science fiction cinema in early Cold War Britain
Article
Janet Harbord;
(2024)
The visualization of autism: Filming children at the Maudsley Hospital, London, 1957–8
Article
Tim Snelson;
William R. Macauley;
(2021)
Demons of the mind: The ‘psy’ sciences and film in the long 1960s
Article
Pasqualini, Mauro;
(2013)
Psychoanalysis to the People! Alienation, Anguish, and the Unconscious in a Review of the Italian Left, 1961--9
Article
Bonnie Evans;
(2024)
Child development, film evidence, and epidemiological sciences: Elwyn James Anthony and the 1957 Zurich International Congress of Psychiatry
Be the first to comment!