Article ID: CBB480211234

Belmont in Context (2020)


Given its outsized influence as a core document in bioethics, it is worth reminding ourselves of the historical context in which the Belmont Report came to be. This article examines the societal forces that helped bring about the Belmont Report and that shaped its conception of ethical research. A product of a public investigation that included many nonscientists and espoused philosophical principles, the Report internalized a growing call in the late 1960s for oversight over the research enterprise, which had long been the private realm of physician-investigators. Belmont helped bring about a regulatory and oversight apparatus to the research enterprise, as well as a language and discipline of bioethics that added a multidisciplinary set of voices and decision-makers to discussions of what constitutes ethical research. Because it reflected the spirit of protectionism engendered by events of the 1960s and 1970s, Belmont also helped emphasize the importance of informed consent and the protection of vulnerable populations. But because the Report was a product of its time, contingent on historical developments and highly publicized events, it is not necessarily responsive to new factors that now condition the research enterprise. [End Page 220]

Citation URI

Similar Citations

Article Jake Earl; (2020)
The Belmont Report and Innovative Practice (/isis/citation/CBB040690748/)

Article Franklin G. Miller; (2020)
Revisiting the Distinction and the Connection Between Research and Practice (/isis/citation/CBB749659220/)

Article Tom L. Beauchamp; (2020)
The Origins and Drafting of the Belmont Report (/isis/citation/CBB975056514/)

Article Søren Holm; (2020)
Belmont in Europe: A Mostly Indirect Influence (/isis/citation/CBB647472223/)

Article Robert G. W. Kirk; Edmund Ramsden; (2021)
"Havens of mercy”: health, medical research, and the governance of the movement of dogs in twentieth-century America (/isis/citation/CBB713465624/)

Article Scott Y. H. Kim; (2016)
Clinical Trials Without Consent? (/isis/citation/CBB912944194/)

Article Jonathan D. Moreno; (2016)
Acid Brothers: Henry Beecher, Timothy Leary, and the psychedelic of the century (/isis/citation/CBB055543967/)

Article Fabrizio Benedetti; (2016)
Beecher as Clinical Investigator: Pain and the Placebo Effect (/isis/citation/CBB451797664/)

Article John Lantos; (2016)
Henry K. Beecher and the Oversight of Research in Children (/isis/citation/CBB814482608/)

Article Franklin G. Miller; John Lantos; (2016)
Editors’ Introduction (/isis/citation/CBB275166383/)

Article Franklin G. Miller; (2016)
Henry Beecher and Consent to Research: a critical re-examination (/isis/citation/CBB154641312/)

Article Jeffrey S. Flier; (2021)
Misconduct in Bioscience Research: a 40-year perspective (/isis/citation/CBB295426563/)

Article Christine Grady; Anthony S. Fauci; (2016)
The Role of the Virtuous Investigator in Protecting Human Research Subjects (/isis/citation/CBB205434089/)

Article Robert M. Veatch; (2016)
Henry Beecher’s Contributions to the Ethics of Clinical Research (/isis/citation/CBB073544643/)

Book Brendan Kelly; (2016)
Hearing Voices: The History of Psychiatry in Ireland (/isis/citation/CBB338641127/)

Article Franklin G. Miller; Jonathan Kimmelman; (2020)
Introduction to the Special Issue on the Belmont Report (/isis/citation/CBB685361978/)

Authors & Contributors
Miller, Franklin G.
Kimmelman, Jonathan
Lantos, John D.
Beauchamp, Tom L.
Fauci, Anthony S.
Kelly, Brendan D.
Perspectives in Biology and Medicine
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Rutgers University
Boydell & Brewer
Irish Academic Press
The University of North Carolina Press
Medical research
Medicine and ethics
Biology and ethics; bioethics
Moral and ethical aspects
Belmont Report (Bioethics)
Beecher, Henry Knowles
Leary, Timothy
Time Periods
20th century, late
21st century
20th century, early
19th century
20th century
United States
Edinburgh (Scotland)
Harvard University
Rockefeller Foundation

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment