David Reinecke (Author)
Bimm, Jordan (Author)
Social Studies of Science
Volume: 52
Issue: 2
Pages: 199-226
How do scientists maintain their research programs in the face of not finding anything? Continual failure to produce results can result in declining support, scientific controversy and credibility challenges. We elaborate on a crucial mechanism for sustaining the credibility of research programs through periods of non-detection: the maintenance of ambiguity. By this, we refer to scientific strategies that resist closure or an experiment’s premature end by creating doubt in negative findings and fostering hope for future positive results. To illustrate this concept, we draw upon the recent history of Martian exobiology. Since the 1960s, planetary scientists have continually tried and failed to find evidence of life on Mars. And yet, interest in extraterrestrial life detection remains high, with more missions to Mars underway. Through three destabilizing events of non-detection, we show how exobiologists sustained the search for Martian life by casting doubt on negative findings, pointing to other possible unexplored routes to success, and finally reconfiguring operations around new methods or goals. New approaches may take the form of shifts in scale, method and object of interest. By pivoting to a different scale, method or object, exobiologists have continued to study a subject continually lacking proof of existence and made important discoveries about life on Earth.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Lisa Messeri;
(2016)
Placing Outer Space: An Earthly Ethnography of Other Worlds
(/isis/citation/CBB151926948/)
Book
Steven J. Dick;
(2020)
Space, Time, and Aliens: Collected Works on Cosmos and Culture
(/isis/citation/CBB216626146/)
Article
Claire Isabel Webb;
(2021)
Gaze-scaling: Planets as Islands in Exobiologists’ Imaginaries
(/isis/citation/CBB206683727/)
Book
Wade Roush;
(2020)
Extraterrestrials
(/isis/citation/CBB810763664/)
Book
Vakoch, Douglas A.;
(2013)
Astrobiology, History, and Society: Life beyond Earth and the Impact of Discovery
(/isis/citation/CBB001510141/)
Book
Jörg Matthias Determann;
(2024)
Islamic Theology and Extraterrestrial Life: New Frontiers in Science and Religion
(/isis/citation/CBB727800166/)
Thesis
Dana I. Burton;
(2023)
Evidencing Life: Thresholds of Biology and Scientific Operations Beyond Earth
(/isis/citation/CBB867761351/)
Article
David Reinecke;
(October 2021)
When funding fails: Planetary exploration at NASA in an era of austerity, 1967–1976
(/isis/citation/CBB136979511/)
Book
William Sheehan;
Sanjay Shridhar Limaye;
(2022)
Venus
(/isis/citation/CBB124332579/)
Book
Battrick, Bruce;
Conroy, L.;
(2005)
The extended ESA history project: Proceedings of the concluding workshop: 13--14 April 2005, ESA headquarters, Paris
(/isis/citation/CBB001181635/)
Article
Martin Schneider;
(2023)
Der Mars zwischen Phantasie und Fakt: Vom antiken Gott über den feindlichen Nachbarn zum Objekt astronomischer Forschung (Mars between fantasy and fact: from ancient god to hostile neighbor to object of astronomical research)
(/isis/citation/CBB712521228/)
Book
Geppert, Alexander C. T.;
(2012)
Imagining Outer Space: European Astroculture in the Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001252921/)
Chapter
Briot, Danielle;
(2013)
The Creator of Astrobotany, Gavriil Adrianovich Tikhov
(/isis/citation/CBB001510149/)
Book
James E Christie;
(2019)
From Influence to Inhabitation: The Transformation of Astrobiology in the Early Modern Period
(/isis/citation/CBB433487312/)
Book
Vera M. Kolb;
(2019)
Handbook of Astrobiology
(/isis/citation/CBB040487767/)
Book
Jörg Matthias Determann;
(2020)
Islam, Science Fiction and Extraterrestrial Life: The Culture of Astrobiology in the Muslim World
(/isis/citation/CBB306747175/)
Article
Lisa Messeri;
(February 2017)
Extra-terra incognita: Martian maps in the digital age
(/isis/citation/CBB974270108/)
Book
Stephen James O'Meara;
(2020)
Mars
(/isis/citation/CBB601250085/)
Article
William Sheehan;
(2019)
Treading carefully: V.M. Slipher, C.O. Lampland, E.C. Slipher and their ambivalent relationship with Percival Lowell's Mars
(/isis/citation/CBB025175687/)
Article
Jennifer Putnam;
William Sheehan;
(2021)
A complicated relationship: An introduction to the correspondence between Percival Lowell and Giovanni Virginio Schiaparelli
(/isis/citation/CBB031685528/)
Be the first to comment!