Do the same epistemic standards govern scientific and religious belief? Or should science and religion operate in completely independent epistemic spheres? Commentators have recently been divided on William James’s answer to this question. One side depicts “The Will to Believe” as offering a separate-spheres defense of religious belief in the manner of Galileo. The other contends that “The Will to Believe” seeks to loosen the usual epistemic standards so that religious and scientific beliefs can both be justified by a unitary set of evidentiary rules. I argue that James did build a unitary epistemology but not by loosening cognitive standards. In his psychological research, he had adopted the Comtian view that hypotheses and regulative assumptions play a crucial role in the context of discovery even though they must be provisionally adopted before they can be supported by evidence. “The Will to Believe” relies on this methodological point to achieve a therapeutic goal—to convince despairing Victorians that religious faith can be reconciled with a scientific epistemology. James argues that the prospective theist is in the same epistemic situation with respect to the “religious hypothesis” as the scientist working in the context of discovery.
...MoreArticle David J. Stump (2015) Introduction to Forum: Pragmatism in the Philosophy of Science. HOPOS (pp. 70-71).
Similar Citations
Book
Michael Davis;
(2006)
George Eliot and Nineteenth-Century Psychology: Exploring the Unmapped Country
(/isis/citation/CBB890472950/)
Article
Weller, Dylan;
(2010)
William James, Pluralism, and the Science of Religious Experience
(/isis/citation/CBB001032381/)
Chapter
Grossman, Joan Delaney;
(2003)
Philosophers, Decadents, and Mystics: James's Russian Readers in the 1890's
(/isis/citation/CBB000410093/)
Article
Croce, Paul;
(2009)
Nature's Beloved Incarnations: Inquiry, Conviction, and William James
(/isis/citation/CBB001023429/)
Thesis
Knapp, Krister Dylan;
(2003)
To the Summerland: William James, Psychical Research and Modernity
(/isis/citation/CBB001561951/)
Article
Jessop, Ralph;
(2013)
Resisting the Enlightenment's Instrumentalist Legacy: James, Hamilton, and Carlyle on the Mechanisation of the Human Condition
(/isis/citation/CBB001201208/)
Book
Grossman, Joan Delaney;
Rischin, Ruth;
(2003)
William James in Russian Culture
(/isis/citation/CBB000302357/)
Article
Kosits, Russell D.;
(2004)
Of Faculties, Fallacies, and Freedom: Dilemma and Irony in the Secularization of American Psychology
(/isis/citation/CBB000501055/)
Article
Croce, Paul Jerome;
(2007)
Freeman Dyson and Humility Theology: Revised Editions of Some Old Ways of Thinking
(/isis/citation/CBB001023428/)
Article
Schmaus, Warren;
(2010)
Durkheim, Jamesian Pragmatism and the Normativity of Truth
(/isis/citation/CBB001035639/)
Book
Marialuisa Parise;
(2013)
La prima versione italiana del De dignitate et augmentis scientiarum di Francis Bacon tradotto da Antonio Pellizzari. Ms. 1408 - Biblioteca Comunale di Treviso.
(/isis/citation/CBB553610069/)
Book
Dario Generali;
(2016)
Le Radici della Razionalità Critica: Saperi, Pratiche, Teleologie. Studi offerti a Fabio Minazzi
(/isis/citation/CBB605863308/)
Book
Stuart Mathieson;
(2020)
Evangelicals and the Philosophy of Science: The Victoria Institute, 1865-1939
(/isis/citation/CBB676582188/)
Book
Weir, Todd H.;
(2012)
Monism: Science, Philosophy, Religion, and the History of a Worldview
(/isis/citation/CBB001201833/)
Article
Thorvaldsen, Steinar;
Øhrstrøm, Peter;
(2013)
Darwin's Perplexing Paradox: Intelligent Design in Nature
(/isis/citation/CBB001201341/)
Article
Noguera-Solano, Ricardo;
(2013)
The Metaphor of the Architect in Darwin: Chance and Free Will
(/isis/citation/CBB001201404/)
Article
Katasonov, V. N.;
(2002)
Pozitivizm i khristianstvo: Filosofiia i istoriia nauki P'era Dugema
(/isis/citation/CBB000203013/)
Article
Paul Eling;
Stanley Finger;
(2022)
Franz Joseph Gall on God and religion: “Dieu et Cerveau, rien que Dieu et cerveau!”
(/isis/citation/CBB938759518/)
Book
Ruse, Michael;
Richards, Robert J.;
(2008)
The Cambridge Companion to the Origin of Species
(/isis/citation/CBB000951129/)
Article
Marco Mazzeo;
(2013)
Gli errori di Darwin? Evoluzione e storia naturale
(/isis/citation/CBB744523130/)
Be the first to comment!