Showing and hiding: The flickering visibility of earth workers in the archives of earth science (2020)
This essay interrogates the motives of eighteenth-century European naturalists to alternately show and hide their laboring-class fossil suppliers. Focusing on rare moments of heightened visibility, I ask why gentlemen naturalists occasionally, deliberately, and even performatively made visible the marginalized science workers on whom they crucially depended but more typically ignored or effaced. Comparing archival fragments from elite works of natural history across a considerable stretch of time and space, including Italy, France, Switzerland, Britain, Ireland, Germany, Spain, and French, Spanish, and British America, this essay sketches the contours of a disparate group of people I term ‘earth workers’: laborers of very low social rank, such as quarrymen, shepherds, ditch-diggers, and fieldworkers, whose daily labor in and on the earth enabled the discovery of subterranean specimens. At the same time, archival traces of laboring lives ultimately reveal more about the naturalists who created them than they do about the marginalized laborers whose lives they faintly record. Cultural norms of elite masculinity and scholarly self-presentation in the Republic of Letters help us to understand why some eighteenth-century naturalists felt they had to publicly disavow a form of labor that would come to be recognized as a crucial and skilled part of scientific fieldwork in the modern era. Compared to other kinds of invisible labor that historians of science have brought into view, the social meaning of earth work rendered it uniquely visible in some ways and uniquely invisible in others.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Francesco Luzzini;
(2013)
Il miracolo inutile. Antonio Vallisneri e le scienze della Terra in Europa tra XVII e XVIII secolo
(/isis/citation/CBB451473673/)
Book
Griffin, Emma;
(2013)
Liberty's Dawn: A People's History of the Industrial Revolution
(/isis/citation/CBB001552839/)
Article
Alix Cooper;
(2021)
Natural History as a Family Enterprise: Kinship and Inheritance in Eighteenth-Century Science
(/isis/citation/CBB200681045/)
Chapter
Paolo Mazzarello;
(2015)
I viaggi scientifici di Lazzaro Spallanzani
(/isis/citation/CBB109834687/)
Article
Marianne Klemun;
(2020)
‘Humboldtian Science’ and beyond. The Humboldtian way of seeing and knowing in Vienna and in Franz Unger’s and Friedrich Simony’s earth sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB712710967/)
Article
Scott, Andrew C.;
(2001)
Federico Cesi and his field studies on the origin of fossils between 1610 and 1630
(/isis/citation/CBB000100428/)
Book
Ian D. Hodkinson;
(2019)
Natural Awakenings: Early Naturalists in Lakeland
(/isis/citation/CBB425907142/)
Book
Allen, David Elliston;
(2001)
Naturalists and Society: The Culture of Natural History in Britain, 1700-1900
(/isis/citation/CBB000100994/)
Article
Sequeira Fernandes, Antonio Carlos;
Telles Antunes, Miguel;
Brandão, José Manuel;
Rodriguez Cabral Ramos, Renato;
(2012)
O Monstro de Prados e Simão Pires Sardinha: considerações sobre o primeiro relatório de registro de um fóssil brasileiro
(/isis/citation/CBB001212022/)
Article
Dominik Hünniger;
(2021)
Visible Labour? Productive Forces and Imaginaries of Participation in European Insect Studies, ca. 1680–1810
(/isis/citation/CBB509322382/)
Book
Blok, Aad;
Downey, Greg;
(2003)
Uncovering labor in information revolutions, 1750--2000
(/isis/citation/CBB001180030/)
Book
Cohen, Claudine;
(2011)
La méthode de Zadig: La trace, le fossile, la preuve
(/isis/citation/CBB001221122/)
Book
Rudwick, Martin J. S.;
(2014)
Earth's Deep History: How It Was Discovered and Why It Matters
(/isis/citation/CBB001422030/)
Chapter
Ferdinando Abbri;
(2005)
Giovanni Targioni Tozzetti, la storia naturale e la geotermia
(/isis/citation/CBB418178503/)
Article
Domenico Laurenza;
(2019)
The study of fossils in Leibniz's Protogaea: towards a reconctruction of the role of technological models in early modern paleontology
(/isis/citation/CBB565261905/)
Chapter
Kempe, Michael;
(2006)
Die Gedächtnisspur der Berge und Fossilien. Johann Jakob Scheuchzers Sintfluttheorie als Theologie der Erdgeschichte
(/isis/citation/CBB001221572/)
Chapter
Alessandro Ottaviani;
(2022)
Monti, fossili ed “epoche” della natura in Arcadia
(/isis/citation/CBB840927043/)
Article
Varela, Alex Gonçalves;
(2010)
Um manuscrito inédito do naturalista Manuel Ferreira da Câmara: “nota sobre a extração das minas do Principado da Transilvânia” (1796)
(/isis/citation/CBB001420450/)
Article
Zinsser, Judith P.;
(2014)
Imagining Patterns of Learned Culture: A Cross-Cultural View
(/isis/citation/CBB001550125/)
Chapter
Simona Boscani Leoni;
Sarah Baumgartner;
Meike Knittel;
(2021)
Introduction: From Switzerland to the Indies
(/isis/citation/CBB610089546/)
Be the first to comment!