Evaluating Evidential Pluralism in Epidemiology: Mechanistic Evidence in Exposome Research (2019)
In current philosophical discussions on evidence in the medical sciences, epidemiology has been used to exemplify a specific version of evidential pluralism. According to this view, known as the Russo–Williamson Thesis, evidence of both difference-making and mechanisms is produced to make causal claims in the health sciences. In this paper, I present an analysis of data and evidence in epidemiological practice, with a special focus on research on the exposome, and I cast doubt on the extent to which evidential pluralism holds in this case. I start by focusing on the claim that molecular data allows for the production of mechanistic evidence. On the basis of a close look at the ways in which molecular data is used in exposome research, I caution against interpretations in terms of mechanistic evidence. Secondly, I expand my critical remarks on the thesis by addressing the conditions under which data is categorised as evidence in exposome research. I argue that these show that the classification of a dataset as a type of evidence is dependent on the ways in which the data is used. This is in contrast with the approach of evidential pluralism, where evidence is classified in different types on the basis of its intrinsic properties. Finally, I come back to what I consider the core of the thesis and suggest that the epidemiological research analysed in the paper indicates different interpretations of evidential pluralism and its applicability in the health sciences.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Stefano Canali;
(2020)
Making evidential claims in epidemiology: Three strategies for the study of the exposome
(/isis/citation/CBB477913919/)
Book
Alex Broadbent;
(2019)
Philosophy of Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB569956645/)
Article
Alexander R. Fiorentino;
Olaf Dammann;
(2015)
Evidence, illness, and causation: An epidemiological perspective on the Russo–Williamson Thesis
(/isis/citation/CBB556890631/)
Article
Susanne Bauer;
(2021)
Pandemic infrastructure: Epidemiology as compartmentalization
(/isis/citation/CBB933898213/)
Article
Kowalenko, Robert;
(2011)
The Epistemology of Hedged Laws
(/isis/citation/CBB001024188/)
Article
Fridolin Gross;
Nina Kranke;
Robert Meunier;
(2019)
Pluralization Through Epistemic Competition: Scientific Change in Times of Data-Intensive Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB374064986/)
Book
Donald Gillies;
(2018)
Causality, Probability, and Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB579737775/)
Article
Anu Masso;
Maris Männiste;
Andra Siibak;
(2020)
‘End of Theory’ in the Era of Big Data: Methodological Practices and Challenges in Social Media Studies
(/isis/citation/CBB632756299/)
Chapter
Fabrizio Baldassarri;
(2021)
Elements of Descartes’ Medical Scientia: Books, Medical Schools, and Collaborations
(/isis/citation/CBB030659484/)
Book
Anya Plutynski;
(2018)
Explaining Cancer: Finding Order in Disorder
(/isis/citation/CBB100511988/)
Article
Alex Broadbent;
(2015)
Causation and prediction in epidemiology: A guide to the “Methodological Revolution”
(/isis/citation/CBB373868659/)
Article
Crignon, Claire;
(2013)
The Debate about methodus medendi during the Second Half of the Seventeenth Century in England: Modern Philosophical Readings of Classical Medical Empiricism in Bacon, Nedham, Willis and Boyle
(/isis/citation/CBB001213580/)
Article
Cooper, Glen M.;
(2014)
Rational and Empirical Medicine in Ninth-Century Baghdad: Qustā Ibn Lūqā's Questions on the Critical Days in Acute Illnesses
(/isis/citation/CBB001321038/)
Book
Gabriella Zuccolin;
(2019)
I gemelli nel Medioevo. Questioni filosofiche, mediche e teologiche
(/isis/citation/CBB456218709/)
Book
Fabrizio Baldassarri;
(2021)
Il metodo al tavolo anatomico: Descartes e la medicina
(/isis/citation/CBB773621333/)
Article
Nikos Giatrakos;
Nikos Katzouris;
Antonios Deligiannakis;
Alexander Artikis;
Minos Garofalakis;
George Paliouras;
Holger Arndt;
Raffaele Grasso;
Ralf Klinkenberg;
Miguel Ponce De Leon;
Gian Gaetano Tartaglia;
Alfonso Valencia;
Dimitrios Zissis;
(June 2019)
Interactive Extreme-Scale Analytics: Towards Battling Cancer
(/isis/citation/CBB319384817/)
Article
Dishman, Eric;
(Spring 2019)
Supporting Precision Aging: Engineering Health and Lifespan Planning for All of Us
(/isis/citation/CBB071431083/)
Article
Little, Lester K.;
(2013)
Plague Historians in Lab Coats
(/isis/citation/CBB001200343/)
Article
Katrin Amelang;
Susanne Bauer;
(August 2019)
Following the algorithm: How epidemiological risk-scores do accountability
(/isis/citation/CBB077353059/)
Book
Fernando Rosa;
Alessandra Parodi;
(2024)
Essere in una pandemia. Filosofia, medicina e Covid-19
(/isis/citation/CBB335674855/)
Be the first to comment!