The environments of reproductive and birth defects research in the U.S. and West Germany (c. 1955–1975) (2022)
Nemec, Birgit (Author)
Dron, Heather A. (Author)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Volume: 95
Pages: 50-63
Most historiographies of the crossroads of environmental and reproductive health in 20th century start and end with the case of thalidomide. Despite its global scope, thalidomide today stands for sharp contrasts: in the numbers of victims, in institutional responses to the disaster, and also—more generally—in regulatory approaches to potential risks and national cultures of reproductive justice and disability rights. This paper takes a closer look at two countries that have been seen as emblematic of this divide in regulatory frameworks, despite similarities and interconnections in other areas, such as (pharma)industrial production, science, and robust feminist environmental health movements: the U.S. and West Germany. It argues that thalidomide needs to be historically contextualized within a broad framework of concepts and models of environment from research on exogenous reproductive effects. To do so, it reconstructs what counted as environment in research on reproductive health and birth defects in these two national settings in the postwar decades. It looks at transformations made across multifaceted initiatives, studying collective landscapes and workplaces as potentially dangerous “outer worlds,” as well as smaller scale and more individualized environments, i.e., the maternal metabolism, uterus, lifestyle, or social interactions. The article thereby aims to explicate concepts and debates about the environment that influenced later national divisions in politics of science and technology, hinting of the democratic challenges these posed.
...MoreArticle Jan Baedke; Tatjana Buklijas (2023) Where organisms meet the environment: Introduction to the special issue ‘What counts as environment in biology and medicine: Historical, philosophical and sociological perspectives’. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science (pp. 4-9).
Similar Citations
Book
Hampton, Jameel;
(2016)
Disability and the Welfare State in Britain: Changes in Perception and Policy 1948-1979
(/isis/citation/CBB478296537/)
Article
Martin, Aryn;
Holloway, Kelly;
(2014)
“Something There Is That Doesn't Love a Wall”: Histories of the Placental Barrier
(/isis/citation/CBB001421096/)
Book
Reagan, Leslie J.;
(2010)
Dangerous Pregnancies: Mothers, Disabilities, and Abortion in Modern America
(/isis/citation/CBB001023264/)
Book
Sara Matthiesen;
(2021)
Reproduction Reconceived: Family Making and the Limits of Choice after Roe v. Wade
(/isis/citation/CBB740318677/)
Article
Sarah F. Rose;
(2024)
“The Workmen’s Compensation Law Is a Direct Slap in the Face”: Industrial Medicine, Safety Engineering, and the Problem of Disabled Workers, 1910s–1940s
(/isis/citation/CBB723380993/)
Thesis
Halfmann, Drew T.;
(2001)
Interests in Contexts and Institutional Democracy: The Politics of Abortion Policy in Liberal Welfare States, 1950--2000
(/isis/citation/CBB001562377/)
Article
Schmalzer, Sigrid;
(2013)
Insect Control in Socialist China and the Corporate United States: The Act of Comparison, the Tendency to Forget, and the Construction of Difference in 1970s U.S.--Chinese Scientific Exchange
(/isis/citation/CBB001320193/)
Article
Kleinman, Daniel Lee;
Kinchy, Abby J.;
(2003)
Why Ban Bovine Growth Hormone? Science, Social Welfare, and the Divergent Biotech Policy Landscapes in Europe and the United States
(/isis/citation/CBB000640418/)
Article
Marcus, Gail H.;
(Fall 2001)
Technology, Safety, Human Resources, and Nuclear Power
(/isis/citation/CBB400599084/)
Chapter
Elsbeth Bösl;
(2014)
The Contergan Scandal: Media, Medicine, and Thalidomide in 1960s West Germany
(/isis/citation/CBB578697680/)
Article
Lohmeier, Jens;
Gross, Dominik;
(2013)
Der Diskurs über die rechtliche Regelung der Organtransplantation in West- und Ostdeutschland (1960--1989): Eine vergleichende Studie
(/isis/citation/CBB001212616/)
Article
Schramm, Manuel;
(2005)
Präzision als Leitbild? Carl Zeiss und die deutsche Innovationskultur in Ost und West, 1945-1990
(/isis/citation/CBB000830972/)
Article
Maria Cristina Galmarini-Kabala;
(2019)
Between Defectological Narratives and Institutional Realities: The "Mentally Retarded" Child in the Soviet Union of the 1930s
(/isis/citation/CBB577164168/)
Thesis
Heather A. Dron;
(2016)
Teratology Transformed: Uncertainty, Knowledge, and Conflict over Environmental Etiologies of Birth Defects in Midcentury America
(/isis/citation/CBB332636641/)
Article
Giulia Bovone;
(2023)
Non solo talidomide: Tetracicline, Fenmetrazina e Aminofillina. L’altra faccia delle malformazioni fetali negli anni Cinquanta
(/isis/citation/CBB331834173/)
Article
Maud Anne Bracke;
(2022)
Family Planning and Reproductive Agency in France: Demography, Gender, and Race, 1950s–1970s
(/isis/citation/CBB639631222/)
Article
Agata Ignaciuk;
(2021)
In Sickness and in Health: Expert Discussions on Abortion Indications, Risks, and Patient-Doctor Relationships in Postwar Poland
(/isis/citation/CBB543154930/)
Chapter
Michaels, Paula A.;
(2012)
Pain and Blame: Psychological Approaches to Obstetric Pain, 1950--1980
(/isis/citation/CBB001214272/)
Book
Sandra Bärnreuther;
(2021)
Substantial Relations: Making Global Reproductive Medicine in Postcolonial India
(/isis/citation/CBB296718154/)
Book
Miranda R. Waggoner;
(2017)
The Zero Trimester: Pre-Pregnancy Care and the Politics of Reproductive Risk
(/isis/citation/CBB589678157/)
The Bridge: Journal of the National Academy of Engineering
French Historical Studies
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Osiris: A Research Journal Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Science as Culture
Be the first to comment!