Howard, Stephen (Author)
British Journal for the History of Philosophy
Volume: 25
Issue: 1
Pages: 22-40
Leibniz’s ‘new science of dynamics’ is typically taken to have been completed in the late monadological metaphysics. On this view, stemming from Martial Gueroult and continuing in the recent interpretations of Robert Adams and Pauline Phemister, Leibniz accomplished his dynamics in his later account of physical forces as merely phenomenal modifications of monadic, metaphysical forces. This paper argues, by contrast, that Leibniz considered the dynamics to be an unfinished project: this is evident in statements from throughout his mature period until his final months. Two possible reasons for the non-completion of the dynamics are discussed. The first is that his encounter with the superior physics of Newton’s Principia caused Leibniz to continually defer his own contribution. I argue, however, in favour of a second reason: that there are philosophical difficulties inherent in the science of dynamics that prevented its completion. These difficulties are found in the relation of dynamics to metaphysics, and in the more fundamental split within dynamics, into the doctrine of primitive and derivative forces. Through three late exchanges with de Volder, Wolff and Des Bosses, I show that the relation of primitive and derivative forces remained an unsolved – although not in principle unsolvable – problem for Leibniz.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Daniel Garber;
(2019)
La dynamique de Leibniz est-elle compatible avec sa monadologie ?
(/isis/citation/CBB392397811/)
Article
François Duchesneau;
(2019)
Le recours aux principes architectoniques dans la Dynamica de Leibniz
(/isis/citation/CBB978969993/)
Article
Dunlop, Katherine;
(2013)
Mathematical Method and Newtonian Science in the Philosophy of Christian Wolff
(/isis/citation/CBB001320268/)
Article
Pauline Phemister;
(2017)
Substance and Force: Or Why It Matters What We Think
(/isis/citation/CBB667612088/)
Article
Pauline Phemister;
Lloyd Strickland;
(2015)
Leibniz's Monadological Positive Aesthetics
(/isis/citation/CBB268974718/)
Article
Ohad Nachtomy;
(2018)
Monads at the Bottom, Monads at the Top, Monads All Over
(/isis/citation/CBB302983768/)
Article
Paola Rumore;
(2016)
Mechanism and Materialism in Early Modern German Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB613435200/)
Article
Belkind, Ori;
(2013)
Leibniz and Newton on Space
(/isis/citation/CBB001320865/)
Article
Vincenzo De Risi;
David Rabouin;
(2019)
Introduction
(/isis/citation/CBB534995802/)
Article
Miguel Escribano-Cabeza;
(2021)
Chemistry and dynamics in the thought of G.W. Leibniz II
(/isis/citation/CBB725308590/)
Article
Jean-Pascal Anfray;
(2020)
The Unity of Composite Substance: The Scholastic Background to the Vinculum Substantiale in Leibniz’s Correspondence with Des Bosses
(/isis/citation/CBB771436928/)
Article
Andrea Costa;
Enrico Pasini;
(2019)
L’édition critique de la Dynamica de potentia seu de legibus naturæ corporeæ de G. W. Leibniz
(/isis/citation/CBB564504353/)
Book
Richard T. W. Arthur;
(2022)
Leibniz on Time, Space, and Relativity
(/isis/citation/CBB492069997/)
Article
Ahnert, Thomas J.;
(2004)
Newtonianism in Early Enlightenment Germany, ca. 1720 to 1750: Metaphysics and the Critique of Dogmatic Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB000471141/)
Article
Park, Jeongwoo;
(2007)
Le Débat Wolffien Sur L'Idéalisme de Leibniz Lors de la Première Diffusion de la Monadologie Latine
(/isis/citation/CBB001252097/)
Article
Anne-Lise Rey;
(2019)
Les enjeux métaphysiques de la dynamique
(/isis/citation/CBB019359495/)
Article
Peter Simons;
(2015)
Bolzano's Monadology
(/isis/citation/CBB137993666/)
Article
Southgate, Henry Michael;
(2013)
Kant's Critique of Leibniz's Rejection of Real Opposition
(/isis/citation/CBB001211925/)
Chapter
Garber, Daniel;
(2012)
Leibniz, Newton and Force
(/isis/citation/CBB001500339/)
Article
Rey, Anne-Lise;
(2007)
Diffusion et Réception de la Dynamique La Correspondance Entre Leibniz et Wolff
(/isis/citation/CBB001252095/)
Be the first to comment!