In this paper, I compare Pierre-Simon Laplace's celebrated formulation of the principle of determinism in his 1814 Essai philosophique sur les probabilités with the formulation of the same principle offered by Roger Joseph Boscovich in his Theoria philosophiae naturalis, published 56 years earlier. This comparison discloses a striking general similarity between the two formulations of determinism as well as certain important differences. Regarding their similarities, both Boscovich's and Laplace's conceptions of determinism involve two mutually interdependent components—ontological and epistemic—and they are both intimately linked with the principles of causality and continuity. Regarding their differences, however, Boscovich's formulation of the principle of determinism turns out not only to be temporally prior to Laplace's but also—being founded on fewer metaphysical principles and more rooted in and elaborated by physical assumptions—to be more precise, complete and comprehensive than Laplace's somewhat parenthetical statement of the doctrine. A detailed analysis of these similarities and differences, so far missing in the literature on the history and philosophy of the concept of determinism, is the main goal of the present paper.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Strien, Marij van;
(2014)
On the Origins and Foundations of Laplacian Determinism
(/isis/citation/CBB001320768/)
Article
Philippe Stamenkovic;
(2017)
Retour sur la philosophie de la physique quantique d’Ernst Cassirer
(/isis/citation/CBB115699306/)
Chapter
Robin Findlay Hendry;
(2020)
The Existence of Elements, and the Elements of Existence
(/isis/citation/CBB387242449/)
Chapter
Farzad Mahootian;
(2020)
Kant, Cassirer, and the Idea of Chemical Element
(/isis/citation/CBB657452257/)
Chapter
Guillermo Restrepo;
(2020)
A Formal Approach to the Conceptual Development of Chemical Element
(/isis/citation/CBB000603082/)
Book
R. Paul Thompson;
Ross Upshur;
(2017)
Philosophy of Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB407177138/)
Article
Tomislav Petković;
(2015)
R.J. Boscovich’s Achievement in Natural Philosophy in Relation to the Development of Modern Particle Physics
(/isis/citation/CBB558686511/)
Article
Craik, Alex D. D.;
(2013)
“Continuity and Change”: Representing Mass Conservation in Fluid Mechanics
(/isis/citation/CBB001211054/)
Chapter
Haaparanta, Leila;
(2009)
The Relations between Logic and Philosophy, 1874--1931
(/isis/citation/CBB001210347/)
Article
Raphael Scholl;
(2020)
Unwarranted assumptions: Claude Bernard and the growth of the vera causa standard
(/isis/citation/CBB697599592/)
Article
Bednarczyk, A.;
(2007)
Georges Louis Leclerc de Buffon (1701--1788): The Main Ideas of His Science of Life. On the Tricentenary of the French Naturalist's Birthday
(/isis/citation/CBB000931661/)
Article
Paoletti, Cristina;
(2011)
Causes as Proximate Events: Thomas Brown and the Positivist Interpretation of Hume on Causality
(/isis/citation/CBB001024139/)
Article
Elisa Patergnani;
Luigi Pepe;
(2021)
Les mathématiciens français et italiens du «siècle long»: 1700-1814
(/isis/citation/CBB124027972/)
Article
Marij van Strien;
(2021)
Was physics ever deterministic? The historical basis of determinism and the image of classical physics
(/isis/citation/CBB256271933/)
Article
Jean-Pierre Cléro;
(2017)
Laplace, le “ Newton français ”
(/isis/citation/CBB383726679/)
Chapter
Schneider, Ivo;
(1999)
Stochastik von Laplace bis Poincaré
(/isis/citation/CBB000450073/)
Book
Hahn, Roger;
(2004)
Le Système du Monde: Pierre Simon Laplace. Un itinéraire dans la science
(/isis/citation/CBB000471550/)
Book
Hahn, Roger;
(2013)
Correspondance de Pierre Simon Laplace (1749--1827)
(/isis/citation/CBB001211954/)
Article
Hahn, Roger;
(2010)
Laplace's Private Religious Discomfort
(/isis/citation/CBB001220613/)
Chapter
Tom Archibald;
(2015)
Saturn’s Rings from Laplace to Poincaré
(/isis/citation/CBB776089038/)
Be the first to comment!