The European politics of animal experimentation: From Victorian Britain to ‘Stop Vivisection’ (2017)
Germain, Pierre-Luc (Author)
Chiapperino, Luca (Author)
Testa, Giuseppe (Author)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Volume: 64
Pages: 75-87
This paper identifies a common political struggle behind debates on the validity and permissibility of animal experimentation, through an analysis of two recent European case studies: the Italian implementation of the European Directive 2010/63/EC regulating the use of animals in science, and the recent European Citizens' Initiative (ECI) 'Stop Vivisection'. Drawing from a historical parallel with Victorian antivivisectionism, we highlight important threads in our case studies that mark the often neglected specificities of debates on animal experimentation. From the representation of the sadistic scientist in the XIX century, to his/her claimed capture by vested interests and evasion of public scrutiny in the contemporary cases, we show that animals are not simply the focus of the debate, but also a privileged locus at which much broader issues are being raised about science, its authority, accountability and potential misalignment with public interest. By highlighting this common socio-political conflict underlying public controversies around animal experimentation, our work prompts the exploration of modes of authority and argumentation that, in establishing the usefulness of animals in science, avoid reenacting the traditional divide between epistemic and political fora.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Guerrini, Anita;
(2003)
Experimenting with Humans and Animals: From Galen to Animal Rights
(/isis/citation/CBB000330970/)
Book
Rudacille, Deborah;
(2000)
The Scalpel and the Butterfly: The Conflict Between Animal Research and Animal Protection
(/isis/citation/CBB000101123/)
Article
Machado, Carlos José Saldanha;
Filipecki, Ana Tereza Pinto;
Teixeira, Márcia de Oliveira;
Klein, Helena Espellet;
(2010)
A regulação do uso de animais no Brasil do século XX e o processo de formação do atual regime aplicado à pesquisa biomédica
(/isis/citation/CBB001420444/)
Article
Carvalho, André Luis de Lima;
Waizbort, Ricardo;
(2010)
A dor além dos confins do homem: aproximações preliminares ao debate entre Frances Power Cobbe e os darwinistas a respeito da vivissecção na Inglaterra vitoriana (1863--1904)
(/isis/citation/CBB001420463/)
Chapter
Guerrini, Anita;
(2008)
Animal Experiments and Anitvivisection Debates in the 1820s
(/isis/citation/CBB000760393/)
Article
Preece, Rod;
(2003)
Darwinism, Christianity, and the Great Vivisection Debate
(/isis/citation/CBB000774479/)
Article
Shira Shmuely;
(2020)
Curare: The Poisoned Arrow that Entered the Laboratory and Sparked a Moral Debate
(/isis/citation/CBB410699994/)
Chapter
Francesca Orestano;
(2014)
Il caso di Snitter e Rowf (e di molti altri animali): scienza e crudeltà in The Plague Dogs di Richard Adams.
(/isis/citation/CBB399375847/)
Article
Boddice, Rob;
(2011)
Vivisecting Major: A Victorian Gentleman Scientist Defends Animal Experimentation, 1876--1885
(/isis/citation/CBB001034548/)
Thesis
Shira Dina Shmuely;
(2017)
The Bureaucracy of Empathy: Vivisection and the Question of Animal Pain in Britain, 1876-1912
(/isis/citation/CBB762286081/)
Article
Beregoy, Natalia E.;
(2009)
Charles Darwin, Vivisection and the History of Victorian Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001421097/)
Article
Tarquin Holmes;
(2021)
Science, sensitivity and the sociozoological scale: Constituting and complicating the human-animal boundary at the 1875 Royal Commission on Vivisection and beyond
(/isis/citation/CBB079918903/)
Book
Gernhardt, Matthias Michael;
Fleck, Christian;
(2000)
Der Tierversuch: seine ethische Abwägung aus theologischer, philosophischer-historischer und medizinischer Sicht. Eine Bestandsaufnahme und Analyse
(/isis/citation/CBB000501146/)
Article
Finn, Michael A.;
Stark, James F.;
(2015)
Medical Science and the Cruelty to Animals Act 1876: A Re-Examination of Anti-Vivisectionism in Provincial Britain
(/isis/citation/CBB001422111/)
Article
Beaufays, Joseph-Paul;
(2005)
L'animal au service de l'homme?
(/isis/citation/CBB000670013/)
Article
Hua, Julietta;
Ahuja, Neel;
(2013)
Chimpanzee Sanctuary: “Surplus” Life and the Politics of Transspecies Care
(/isis/citation/CBB001201820/)
Book
Rob Boddice;
(2022)
Humane Professions: The Defense of Experimental Medicine, 1876–1914
(/isis/citation/CBB789019091/)
Article
Bittel, Carla Jean;
(2005)
Science, Suffrage, and Experimentation: Mary Putnam Jacobi and the Controversy over Vivisection in Late Nineteenth-Century America
(/isis/citation/CBB000800010/)
Article
Lisner, Wiebke;
(2009)
Experimente am lebendigen Leib: Zur Frage der Vivisektion in deutschen und britischen medizinischen Wochenschriften 1919--1939
(/isis/citation/CBB001220576/)
Article
Lee, Jack;
(2008)
How Should Animals Be Treated?
(/isis/citation/CBB001031197/)
Be the first to comment!