Wylie, Caitlin Donahue (Author)
Science, Technology and Human Values
Volume: 43
Issue: 2
Pages: 324-348
New technologies can upset scientific workplaces’ established practices and social order. Scientists may therefore prefer preserving skilled manual work and the social status quo to revolutionary technological change. For example, digital imaging of rock-encased fossils is a valuable way for scientists to “see” a specimen without traditional rock removal. However, interviews in vertebrate paleontology laboratories reveal workers’ skepticism toward computed tomography (CT) imaging. Scientists criticize replacing physical fossils with digital images because, they say, images are more subjective than the “real thing.” I argue that these scientists are also implicitly supporting rock-removal technicians, who are skilled and trusted experts whose work would be made obsolete by widespread implementation of CT scanning. Scientists’ view of CT as a sometimes useful tool rather than a universal new approach to accessing fossils preserves the laboratory community’s social structure. Specifically, by privileging “real” specimens and trusted specimen-processing technicians over images and imaging experts, scientists preserve the lab community’s division of labor and skill, hierarchy between scientists and technicians, and these groups’ identity and mutual trust.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Robert G. W. Kirk;
(July 2018)
Recovering The Principles of Humane Experimental Technique: The 3Rs and the Human Essence of Animal Research
(/isis/citation/CBB661013428/)
Article
Elina I. Mäkinen;
(March 2018)
Action in the Space Between: From Latent to Active Boundaries
(/isis/citation/CBB718195671/)
Article
Nina Frahm;
Tess Doezema;
Sebastian Pfotenhauer;
(January 2022)
Fixing Technology with Society: The Coproduction of Democratic Deficits and Responsible Innovation at the OECD and the European Commission
(/isis/citation/CBB550648723/)
Article
Logan D. A. Williams;
(March 2018)
Mapping Superpositionality in Global Ethnography
(/isis/citation/CBB873960993/)
Article
Yoshio Nukaga;
(July 2016)
Ethics Expertise and Public Credibility: A Case Study of the Ethical Principle of Justice
(/isis/citation/CBB610704199/)
Book
A. Balmer;
K. Bulpin;
S. Molyneux-Hodgson;
(2016)
Synthetic Biology: A Sociology of Changing Practices
(/isis/citation/CBB471073110/)
Article
Mike Michael;
(November 2018)
On “Aesthetic Publics”: The Case of VANTAblack®
(/isis/citation/CBB312320431/)
Article
Eva Barlösius;
(2019)
Concepts of Originality in the Natural Science, Medical, and Engineering Disciplines: An Analysis of Research Proposals
(/isis/citation/CBB195775388/)
Article
Sampsa Saikkonen;
Esa Väliverronen;
(2022)
The trickle-down of political and economic control: On the organizational suppression of environmental scientists in government science
(/isis/citation/CBB033206075/)
Article
Lisa Sigl;
(May 2016)
On the Tacit Governance of Research by Uncertainty: How Early Stage Researchers Contribute to the Governance of Life Science Research
(/isis/citation/CBB119230475/)
Book
D'Andrea, Luciano;
(2009)
Handbook on the socialisation of scientific and technological research: A tool for promoting science and technology socialisation policies addressed to policy makers, research and innovation actors and stakeholders
(/isis/citation/CBB001181559/)
Article
Gerhard Dohrn-Van Rossum;
(2019)
Uhrmacher als Prototypen technischer Experten in der europäischen Vormoderne: das Zusammenwirken technischer Kompetenzen bei den Ingenieuren der Renaissance (Watchmakers as prototypes of technical experts in the European pre-modern era: the interaction of technical skills among Renaissance engineers)
(/isis/citation/CBB052698974/)
Article
Chan-Yuan Wong;
Sangook Park;
(2021)
Diverged Evolutionary Pathways of Two Public Research Institutes in Taiwan and Korea: Shared Missions and Varied Organizational Dynamics in ITRI and KIST
(/isis/citation/CBB754093581/)
Article
Rystedt, Hans;
Ivarsson, Jonas;
Asplund, Sara;
Johnsson, Åse Allansdotter;
Båth, Magnus;
(December 2011)
Rediscovering radiology: New technologies and remedial action at the worksite
(/isis/citation/CBB759149951/)
Article
Shobita Parthasarathy;
(2022)
How to Be an Epistemic Trespasser
(/isis/citation/CBB968694595/)
Article
Frédéric Bouchard;
(2016)
The Roles of Institutional Trust and Distrust in Grounding Rational Deference to Scientific Expertise
(/isis/citation/CBB417241096/)
Article
Maria do Mar Pereira;
(2019)
Boundary-work that Does Not Work: Social Inequalities and the Non-performativity of Scientific Boundary-work
(/isis/citation/CBB949567754/)
Article
John A. Alic;
(2022)
Engineering Intangibles: Technical Employment in the US Service Economy
(/isis/citation/CBB946192819/)
Article
Salla Sariola;
(2023)
Mistrust: Community engagement in global health research in coastal Kenya
(/isis/citation/CBB869316828/)
Article
David Demortain;
(2024)
Mistrust of the black box: The public auditing of private models in the chemicals regulatory space
(/isis/citation/CBB384424304/)
Be the first to comment!