IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB436109207

Whewell on classification and consilience (2017)

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Volume: 64
Pages: 65-74

URI: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1369848617300663

DOI: 10.1016/j.shpsc.2017.06.007

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Properties of matter Geometry Natural theology Chemistry Reductionism Classification Teleology Mineralogy 19th century 18th century Whewell, William

In this paper I sketch William Whewell's attempts to impose order on classificatory mineralogy, which was in Whewell's day (1794–1866) a confused science of uncertain prospects. Whewell argued that progress was impeded by the crude reductionist assumption that all macroproperties of crystals could be straightforwardly explained by reference to the crystals' chemical constituents. By comparison with biological classification, Whewell proposed methodological reforms that he claimed would lead to a natural classification of minerals, which in turn would support advances in causal understanding of the properties of minerals. Whewell's comparison to successful biological classification is particularly striking given that classificatory biologists did not share an understanding of the causal structure underlying the natural classification of life (the common descent with modification of all organisms). Whewell's key proposed methodological reform is consideration of multiple, distinct principles of classification. The most powerful evidence in support of a natural classificatory claim is the consilience of claims arrived at through distinct lines of reasoning, rooted in distinct conceptual approaches to the target objects. Mineralogists must consider not only elemental composition and chemical affinities, but also symmetry and polarity. Geometrical properties are central to what makes an individual mineral the type of mineral that it is. In Whewell's view, function and organization jointly define life, and so are the keys to understanding what makes an organism the type of organism that it is. I explain the relationship between Whewell's teleological account of life and his natural theology. I conclude with brief comments about the importance of Whewell's classificatory theory for the further development of his philosophy of science and in particular his account of consilience.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB436109207/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Book Eddy, Matthew D.; (2008)
The Language of Mineralogy: John Walker, Chemistry and the Edinburgh Medical School, 1750--1800 (/isis/citation/CBB000951069/)

Essay Review Oldroyd, David; (2011)
Mineralogy, Chemistry, Botany, Medicine, Geology, Agriculture, Meteorology, Classification,…: The Life and Times of John Walker (1730--1803), Professor of Natural History at Edinburgh University (/isis/citation/CBB001566752/)

Book Fors, Hjalmar; (2015)
The Limits of Matter: Chemistry, Mining, and Enlightenment (/isis/citation/CBB001510055/)

Thesis St. Clair, Charles Spencer; (1966)
The Classification of Minerals: Some Representative Mineral Systems from Agricola to Werner (/isis/citation/CBB283605591/)

Book Paley, William; Eddy, Matthew; Knight, David M.; (2006)
Natural Theology: Or, Evidence of the Existence and Attributes of the Deity, Collected from the Appearances of Nature (/isis/citation/CBB001022579/)

Article Gill, Mary Louise; (2014)
The Limits of Teleology in Aristotle's Meteorology IV.12 (/isis/citation/CBB001421728/)

Article Márcia H. M. Ferraz; Ana M. Alfonso-Goldfarb; (2015)
Chemistry and the Definition and Isolation of ‘Active Principles’ of Plants in the Late 18th and Early-19th Centuries (/isis/citation/CBB958147529/)

Article Charlotte A. Abney Salomon; (2019)
The Pocket Laboratory: The Blowpipe in Eighteenth-Century Swedish Chemistry (/isis/citation/CBB762575960/)

Article Maddalena Napolitani; (2018)
'Born with the Taste for Science and the Arts': The Science and the Aesthetics of Balthazar-Georges Sage's Mineralogy Collections, 1783–18251 (/isis/citation/CBB175466446/)

Article Mary Jo Nye; Stephen J. Weininger; (2018)
Paper Tools from the 1780s to the 1960s: Nomenclature, Classification, and Representations (/isis/citation/CBB524633710/)

Book Steven Turner; (2020)
The Science of James Smithson: Discoveries from the Smithsonian Founder (/isis/citation/CBB562434087/)

Article Giovanni Ferraris; (2019)
Early contributions of crystallography to the atomic theory of matter (/isis/citation/CBB126628917/)

Article Kleeberg, Bernhard; (2007)
God-Nature Progressing: Natural Theology in German Monism (/isis/citation/CBB000850279/)

Article Nomura, Tsunehiko; (2007)
Mathematical Significance of Charles Babbage's The Ninth Bridgewater Treatise (/isis/citation/CBB000930005/)

Article Rapp, George; (2014)
William Whewell: Professor of Mineralogy [and Crystallography] Cambridge University 1828--1834 (/isis/citation/CBB001214309/)

Article Mayer, Wolf; (2009)
The Geological Work of the Baudin Expedition in Australia (1801--1803): The Mineralogists, the Discoveries and the Legacy (/isis/citation/CBB000932615/)

Article Hoquet, Thierry; (2010)
Darwin Teleologist? Design in the Orchids (/isis/citation/CBB001211672/)

Article Akeroyd, Michael; (2010)
The Philosophical Significance of Mendeleev's Successful Predictions of the Properties of Gallium and Scandium (/isis/citation/CBB001034532/)

Article Sarikaya, Mustafa; (2013)
A View about the Short Histories of the Mole and Avogadro's Number (/isis/citation/CBB001211808/)

Article Veljko Dragojlovic; (2023)
First 60 Years of Melting Point in Organic Chemistry, 1790-1850 (/isis/citation/CBB729479208/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}