There are some crucial critiques on scientific inquiry and “the” Scientific Method in current science education. Recent research literature is replete with arguments against inquiry’s legitimacy to be included in science classes, and it has even been abandoned from the Next Generation Science Standards. Critics of scientific inquiry in schools blame it to be a caricature of authentic inquiry suffering from five shortcomings: (1) knowledge becomes desocialized from its generative contexts, (2) scientific inquiry in schools suggests methodological monism favoring (3) a primacy of experimentation, (4) which portrays scientific inquiry as a knowledge automaton (5) raising an illusion of determination with regard to the generation of knowledge. This article argues for a reorientation of scientific inquiry in schools tentatively embracing “the” Scientific Method anew since critics appear not to sufficiently consider that scientific inquiry operates differently in schools from science. It will be shown that most critiques can be defused when untangling such an illegitimate mix-up of science proper with school science. It will be argued that current (and recent) descriptions of how science generates knowledge lack authoritative validity and should be fundamentally revisited. “The” Scientific Method will be shown to be a valid idealization that can serve as a frame of reference for introductory science classes. Still, it is understood that science education needs to extend beyond “the” Scientific Method if it is to prepare for science-related careers.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Anja Sattelmacher;
Mario Schulze;
Sarine Waltenspül;
(2021)
Introduction: Reusing Research Film and the Institute for Scientific Film
(/isis/citation/CBB618455905/)
Article
Pierre Savaton;
(2015)
Les exercices pratiques de sciences naturelles de 1902 aux années 1930: Des textes aux pratiques
(/isis/citation/CBB631696484/)
Book
Douglas Allchin;
(2013)
Teaching the Nature of Science: Perspectives & Resources
(/isis/citation/CBB218504767/)
Article
Wonyong Park;
Jinwoong Song;
(2018)
Goethe’s Conception of “Experiment as Mediator” and Implications for Practical Work in School Science
(/isis/citation/CBB874433176/)
Article
Contakes, Stephen M.;
Kyle, Christopher;
(2011)
Josiah Parsons Cooke Jr.: Epistemology in the Service of Science, Pedagogy, and Natural Theology
(/isis/citation/CBB001210472/)
Article
Ayça Fackler;
(2021)
When Science Denial Meets Epistemic Understanding
(/isis/citation/CBB538668203/)
Book
Barbara Schneider;
Joseph Krajcik;
Jari Lavonen;
Katariina Salmela-Aro;
Margaret J. Geller;
(2020)
Learning Science: The Value of Crafting Engagement in Science Environments
(/isis/citation/CBB848656364/)
Article
Raffaele Pisano;
Philippe Vincent;
Kosta Dolenc;
Mateja Ploj Virtič;
(2020)
Historical Foundations of Physics & Applied Technology as Dynamic Frameworks in Pre-Service STEM
(/isis/citation/CBB700869647/)
Book
Joachim Schummer;
Tom Børsen;
(2021)
Ethics of Chemistry: From Poison Gas to Climate Engineering
(/isis/citation/CBB169665595/)
Article
Patricia J. Smith;
(2023)
ChemSource—A Resource for K-12 Teachers
(/isis/citation/CBB212577447/)
Article
Santilli, Haydée;
(2012)
Science and Technology, Autonomous and More Interdependent Every Time
(/isis/citation/CBB001250439/)
Article
David Brandon Dennis;
R. A. Lawson;
Jessica M. Pisano;
(2020)
Bringing History into the Lab: A New Approach to Scientific Learning in General Education
(/isis/citation/CBB574408801/)
Article
Forato, Thaís Cyrino de Mello;
Martins, Roberto de Andrade;
Pietrocola, Maurício;
(2012)
History and Nature of Science in High School: Building up Parameters to Guide Educational Materials and Strategies
(/isis/citation/CBB001250433/)
Article
Teixeira, Elder Sales;
Greca, Ileana Maria;
Freire, Olival, Jr.;
(2012)
The History and Philosophy of Science in Physics Teaching: A Research Synthesis of Didactic Intervention
(/isis/citation/CBB001250438/)
Article
Peng Dai;
Cody Tyler Williams;
Allison Michelle Witucki;
David Wÿss Rudge;
(2021)
Rosalind Franklin and the Discovery of the Structure of DNA
(/isis/citation/CBB767912949/)
Article
Daniel Gamito-Marques;
(2020)
In Praise of a Historical Storytelling Approach in Science Education
(/isis/citation/CBB988919539/)
Article
Pablo Antonio Archila;
Jorge Molina;
Anne-Marie Truscott de Mejía;
(2020)
Using Historical Scientific Controversies to Promote Undergraduates’ Argumentation
(/isis/citation/CBB633496806/)
Article
Braga, Marco;
Guerra, Andreia;
Reis, José Claudio;
(2012)
The Role of Historical-Philosophical Controversies in Teaching Sciences: The Debate between Biot and Ampère
(/isis/citation/CBB001250444/)
Article
Guerra-Ramos, Maria Teresa;
(2012)
Teachers' Ideas About the Nature of Science: A Critical Analysis of Research Approaches and Their Contribution to Pedagogical Practice
(/isis/citation/CBB001250432/)
Article
Robert G. W. Anderson;
(2022)
Epitomizing Chemistry for Changing Audiences in Britain, 1820-2020
(/isis/citation/CBB890259390/)
Be the first to comment!