In 1931, Paneth identified a dual meaning of the term “chemical element,” translated as “basic substance” and “simple substance.” Since then multiple philosophers of chemistry have also identified ambiguities surrounding this concept, and the IUPAC still holds a double definition today. This paper aims to help resolve this ambiguity through an analysis and reinterpretation of the two meanings of the term “element” proposed by Paneth. It is important to distinguish between elements as substances and elements as constituents, because the elementary substances disappear when elements enter into compounds, whereas the constituent subsists. The notion of simple substance fails to capture the stability of the element as a constituent of matter, and Paneth’s metaphysical idea of basic substance is contradictory with a concept of element that evolved thanks to scientific practice, not independent of it. Since these meanings are mutually exclusive, their combination within one term is problematic; yet, this paper will show that neither of them individually suffice to qualify the element. Therefore, based on a brief analysis of the history of chemistry, I will propose a way of rethinking Paneth’s distinction in order to understand the different aspects of this complex chemical concept. Though there is a certain duality to the notion of element in the sense that it can be characterized both as an abstract constituent and as a chemical substance, the term “element” does not have two distinct meanings; it refers to the element in all forms of chemical combination.
...MoreBook Eric R. Scerri; Elena Ghibaudi (2020) What Is A Chemical Element? A Collection of Essays by Chemists, Philosophers, Historians, and Educators.
Similar Citations
Chapter
Eric R. Scerri;
(2020)
The Many Questions Raised by the Dual Concept of “Element”
(/isis/citation/CBB802086327/)
Chapter
Elena Ghibaudi;
Alberto Regis;
Ezio Roletto;
(2020)
The Dual Conception of the Chemical Element: Epistemic Aspects and Implications for Chemical Education
(/isis/citation/CBB012361300/)
Book
Eric R. Scerri;
Elena Ghibaudi;
(2020)
What Is A Chemical Element? A Collection of Essays by Chemists, Philosophers, Historians, and Educators
(/isis/citation/CBB142422947/)
Chapter
Joseph E. Earley;
(2020)
Origins of the Ambiguity of the Current Definition of Chemical Element
(/isis/citation/CBB476358998/)
Chapter
Robin Findlay Hendry;
(2020)
The Existence of Elements, and the Elements of Existence
(/isis/citation/CBB387242449/)
Article
John Emsley;
(2019)
The Development of the Periodic Table and its Consequences
(/isis/citation/CBB224151752/)
Chapter
Farzad Mahootian;
(2020)
Kant, Cassirer, and the Idea of Chemical Element
(/isis/citation/CBB657452257/)
Article
Earley, Joseph E., Sr.;
(2009)
How Chemistry Shifts Horizons: Element, Substance, and the Essential
(/isis/citation/CBB000932192/)
Article
Ann E. Robinson;
(2019)
Order From Confusion: International Chemical Standardization and the Elements, 1947-1990
(/isis/citation/CBB340408815/)
Article
Rayner-Canham, Geoff;
Zheng, Zheng;
(2008)
Naming Elements after Scientists: An Account of a Controversy
(/isis/citation/CBB000930615/)
Chapter
Guillermo Restrepo;
(2020)
A Formal Approach to the Conceptual Development of Chemical Element
(/isis/citation/CBB000603082/)
Article
Juergen Heinrich Maar;
Alexander Maar;
(2019)
The Periodic Table and its Iconicity: an Essay
(/isis/citation/CBB599518974/)
Article
Mahootian, Farzad;
(2013)
Paneth's Epistemology of Chemical Elements in Light of Kant's Opus postumum
(/isis/citation/CBB001212048/)
Article
Ronei Clécio Mocellin;
Martín Labarca;
(2024)
For a Dialogue Between the Teaching of Chemistry and the History and Philosophy of Chemistry: the Case of the Concept of 'Chemical Element'
(/isis/citation/CBB618298771/)
Chapter
Bernardette Bensaude-Vincent;
(2020)
From Simple Substance to Chemical Element
(/isis/citation/CBB327497668/)
Chapter
Joachim Schummer;
(2020)
The Operational Definition of the Elements: A Philosophical Reappraisal
(/isis/citation/CBB928776970/)
Article
Helge Kragh;
(2017)
On the Ontology of Superheavy Elements
(/isis/citation/CBB177176432/)
Article
Lafont, Olivier;
(2007)
Vie et mort des radicaux
(/isis/citation/CBB000933364/)
Chapter
Jean-Pierre Llored;
(2020)
Substance and Function: The Case of Chemical Elements
(/isis/citation/CBB986119517/)
Article
Alfio Zambon;
(2019)
Periodicity Trees in a Secondary Criterion of Periodic Classification: Its Implications for Science Teaching and Communication
(/isis/citation/CBB365718021/)
Be the first to comment!