Patient Expectations: How Economics, Religion, and Malpractice Shaped Therapeutics in Early America (2015)
Thompson, Catherine L. (Author)
University of Massachusetts Press
Physical Details: 192 pages
Language: English
During the first half of the nineteenth century a major shift occurred in the medical treatment of illness in the United States, as physicians abandoned the use of "heroic" depletive therapies -- the pukes and purges made famous in the 1790s by Dr. Benjamin Rush of Philadelphia -- in favor of a let-nature-take-its-course approach to most diseases. Standard histories of American medicine have long attributed this shift to new theories and training methods as well as increased competition from homeopaths and botanical doctors. In this book, Catherine L. Thompson challenges that interpretation by emphasizing the role of patients as active participants in their own health care rather than passive objects of medical treatment. Focusing on Massachusetts, then as now a center of U.S. medical education and practice, Thompson draws on data from patients' journals, medical account ledgers, physicians' daybooks, and court records to link changes in medical treatment to a gradual evolution of patient expectations across varied populations. Specifically, she identifies three developments -- the increasing use of cash in medical transactions, growing religious pluralism, and the rise of malpractice suits -- as key factors in transforming patients into active medical consumers unwilling to submit to doctors' advice without considering alternatives. By showing how nineteenth-century patients shaped therapeutic practice "through the medical choices they made or didn't make," Thompson's study alters our understanding of American medicine in the past and has implications for its present and future.
...MoreReview Matthew Warner Osborn (2017) Review of "Patient Expectations: How Economics, Religion, and Malpractice Shaped Therapeutics in Early America". American Historical Review (pp. 174-175).
Review Melissa Grafe (2016) Review of "Patient Expectations: How Economics, Religion, and Malpractice Shaped Therapeutics in Early America". Social History of Medicine (pp. 229-230).
Review Matthew Reeves (2017) Review of "Patient Expectations: How Economics, Religion, and Malpractice Shaped Therapeutics in Early America". Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences (pp. 352-354).
Review Norman Gevitz (2016) Review of "Patient Expectations: How Economics, Religion, and Malpractice Shaped Therapeutics in Early America". Bulletin of the History of Medicine (pp. 727-727).
Similar Citations
Thesis
Kiran Sambhaji Kumbhar;
(2022)
Healing and Harming: The "Noble Profession" of Medicine in Post-Independence India, 1947-2015
(/isis/citation/CBB683556461/)
Book
Marec, Yannick;
(2007)
Accueillir ou soigner? L'hôpital et ses alternatives du Moyen Âge à nos jours
(/isis/citation/CBB001020240/)
Chapter
Daniela Rigato;
(2021)
Medico divino e razionale, carnifex e amicus: a chi dare fiducia?
(/isis/citation/CBB127543352/)
Article
Maria Pia Donato;
(2022)
Medicine and Religion at the Early Modern Deathbed: How Can We Reframe the Narrative?
(/isis/citation/CBB103659660/)
Chapter
Domenico Roccolo;
(2023)
Confraternite e malati a Roma nell'età moderna
(/isis/citation/CBB551431790/)
Chapter
Kristin Peterson;
(2016)
Volatility, Speculation, and Therapeutic Revolutions in Nigerian Drug Markets
(/isis/citation/CBB789076062/)
Book
Stefano Calabrese;
Valentina Conti;
Chiara Fioretti;
(2022)
Che cos'è la medicina narrativa
(/isis/citation/CBB159018057/)
Article
Adam Mohr;
(2021)
The Economic Rationality of Religious-Based Medical Abstinence in the Early Twentieth Century: The Case of Philadelphia's Faith Tabernacle Congregation
(/isis/citation/CBB873154426/)
Article
Laura Kelly;
(2020)
The Contraceptive Pill in Ireland c.1964–79: Activism, Women and Patient–Doctor Relationships
(/isis/citation/CBB546149788/)
Book
Francesco Lopez;
(2016)
Democede di Crotone e Udjahorresnet di Saïs: medici primari alla corte achemenide di Dario il Grande
(/isis/citation/CBB110188086/)
Book
Alessandra Quaranta;
(2019)
Medici italiani eretici nella seconda metà del Cinquecento: Esperienze d'esilio e rapporti culturali e scientifici con il mondo di lingua tedesca
(/isis/citation/CBB378668825/)
Book
Stephen Brogan;
(2015)
The Royal Touch in Early Modern England: Politics, Medicine and Sin
(/isis/citation/CBB880289845/)
Chapter
Giuseppe Squillace;
(2020)
Tra Asclepio e Ippocrate. Brevi considerazioni su medicina religiosa e medicina laica nel mondo greco
(/isis/citation/CBB548680270/)
Chapter
María Paz de Hoz;
(2014)
Lucian's Podagra, Asclepius and Galen. The Popularisation of Medicine in the Second Century AD
(/isis/citation/CBB170283387/)
Book
Elisa Novi Chavarria;
(2020)
Accogliere e curare. Ospedali e culture delle nazioni nella Monarchia ispanica (secc. XVI-XVII)
(/isis/citation/CBB491582261/)
Book
Tommaso Duranti;
(2023)
Ammalarsi e curarsi nel medioevo. Una storia sociale
(/isis/citation/CBB741950970/)
Book
Giovanni Cipriani;
(2015)
La via della salute. Studi e ricerche di storia della farmacia
(/isis/citation/CBB733953315/)
Article
Geneviève McCready;
Marie-Claude Thifault;
(2020)
Travailler auprès des familles indigentes: Les gardes-malades catholiques à l’avant-garde de la santé communautaire au Canada (1934–1959)
(/isis/citation/CBB464976023/)
Chapter
M. Aliverti;
(2013)
Religiosity and Magic in Some Lithoiatric Practices of European Folk Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB743336342/)
Article
Arsenio Ferraces Rodríguez;
(2017)
Contaminación textual y censura ideológica en la Epistula Hipparchi de taxone (Montecassino, Biblioteca dell'Abbazia, V. 97, pp. 532B-533A)
(/isis/citation/CBB076068637/)
Be the first to comment!