Synthetic biology as a technoscience: The case of minimal genomes and essential genes (2021)
Simons, Massimiliano (Author)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Volume: 85
Pages: 127-136
This article examines how minimal genome research mobilizes philosophical concepts such as minimality and essentiality. Following a historical approach the article aims to uncover what function this terminology plays and which problems are raised by them. Specifically, four historical moments are examined, linked to the work of Harold J. Morowitz, Mitsuhiro Itaya, Eugene Koonin and Arcady Mushegian, and J. Craig Venter. What this survey shows is a historical shift away from historical questions about life or descriptive questions about specific organisms towards questions that explore biological possibilities: what are possible forms of minimal genomes, regardless of whether they exist in nature? Moreover, it highlights a fundamental ambiguity at work in minimal genome research between a universality claim and a standardization claim: does a minimal genome refer to the minimal gene set for any organism whatsoever? Or does it refer rather to a gene set that will provide stable, robust and predictable behaviour, suited for biotechnological applications? Two diagnoses are proposed for this ambiguity: a philosophical diagnosis of how minimal genome research either misunderstands the ontology of biological entities or philosophically misarticulates scientific practice. Secondly, a historical diagnosis that suggests that this ambiguity is part of a broader shift towards technoscience.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Ishiida, Tomoko;
(September 2017)
Gene: From Demarcation to Dynamic Meanings
Book
Venkatesh Narayanamurti;
Jeffrey Y. Tsao;
(2021)
The Genesis of Technoscientific Revolutions: Rethinking the Nature and Nurture of Research
Book
Alessandro Minelli;
(2015)
Descrivere e interpretare il vivente
Article
Kowal, Emma;
Radin, Joanna;
Reardon, Jenny;
(August 2013)
Indigenous Body Parts, Mutating Temporalities, and the Half-Lives of Postcolonial Technoscience
Article
Mette N. Svendsen;
Laura E. Navne;
(2023)
Citizen-Person: The “Me” in the “We” in Danish Precision Medicine
Article
Papadopoulos, Dimitris;
(April 2011)
Alter-ontologies: Towards a constituent politics in technoscience
Chapter
W. Ford Doolittle;
(2012)
Craig Venter’s New Life: the Realization of Some Thought Experiments in Biological Ontology
Article
Chen, Ruey-Lin;
(September 2017)
A Linguistic or an Ontological Problem? Some Comments
Article
Olga A. Pilkington;
(2019)
Definitions of Scientific Terminology in Popular Science Books: An Examination of Definitional Chains
Article
Dmitriy Myelnikov;
Sara Peres;
(2023)
The Cold Futures of Mouse Genetics: Modes of Strain Cryopreservation Since the 1970s
Article
Carmen Romero-Bachiller;
Pablo Santoro;
(2023)
The Cryopolitics of Human Milk: Thermal Assemblages of Breast Milk in Donation, Banking, and Bioindustrial Research
Article
T. Y. Branch;
G. M. Duché;
(2024)
Affective Labor in Integrative STS Research
Article
Christine Aicardi;
Tara Mahfoud;
(2024)
Formal and Informal Infrastructures of Collaboration in the Human Brain Project
Article
Ruth Falkenberg;
Maximilian Fochler;
(2024)
Innovation in Technology Instead of Thinking? Assetization and Its Epistemic Consequences in Academia
Article
Hub Zwart;
(2020)
Friedrich Engels and the Technoscientific Reproducibility of Life: Synthetic Cells as Case Material for Practicing Dialectics of Science Today
Article
Gregory Hollin;
Isla Forsyth;
Eva Giraud;
Tracey Potts;
(December 2017)
(Dis)entangling Barad: Materialisms and ethics
Article
van Heur, Bas;
Leydesdorff, Loet;
Wyatt, Sally;
(June 2013)
Turning to ontology in STS? Turning to STS through ‘ontology’
Book
Kostas Kampourakis;
(2017)
Making Sense of Genes
Article
Pierrel, Jérôme;
(2012)
An RNA Phage Lab: MS2 in Walter Fiers' Laboratory of Molecular Biology in Ghent, from Genetic Code to Gene and Genome, 1963--1976
Article
Bostanci, Adam;
Calvert, Jane;
(2008)
Invisible Genomes: The Genomics Revolution and Patenting Practice
Be the first to comment!