Epigenesis has become a far more exciting issue in Kant studies recently, especially with the publication of Jennifer Mensch's Kant’ Organicism. In my commentary, I propose to clarify my own position on epigenesis relative to that of Mensch and others by once again considering the discourse of epigenesis in the wider eighteenth century. Historically, I maintain that Kant was never fully an epigenesist because he feared its materialist implications. This makes it highly unlikely that he drew heavily, as other interpreters like Dupont and Huneman have suggested, on Caspar Friedrich Wolff for his ultimate theory of “generic preformation.” In order to situate more precisely what Kant made of epigenesis, I distinguish his metaphysical use, as elaborated by Mensch, from his view of it as a theory for life science. In that light, I raise questions about the scope and authority of philosophy vis a vis natural science.
...MoreArticle Gaukroger, Stephen W.; Dalia Nassar (2016) Introduction: Kant and the Empirical Sciences. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science (pp. 55-56).
Similar Citations
Article
Michael J. Olson;
(2016)
Kant on Anatomy and the Status of the Life Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB742454603/)
Article
Dalia Nassar;
(2016)
Analogical Reflection as a Source for the Science of Life: Kant and the Possibility of the Biological Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB933801159/)
Book
Catherine Wilson;
(2022)
Kant and the Naturalistic Turn of 18th Century Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB775333088/)
Article
Daniela Helbig;
Dalia Nassar;
(2016)
The Metaphor of Epigenesis: Kant, Blumenbach and Herder
(/isis/citation/CBB685336938/)
Article
Udo Thiel;
(2020)
Priestley and Kant on Materialism
(/isis/citation/CBB616453784/)
Book
Parsons, Charles;
(2012)
From Kant to Husserl: Selected Essays
(/isis/citation/CBB001253011/)
Article
Witt, Elke;
(2008)
Form---A Matter of Generation: The Relation of Generation, Form, and Function in the Epigenetic Theory of Caspar F. Wolff
(/isis/citation/CBB000831765/)
Book
Amanda Jo Goldstein;
(2017)
Sweet Science: Romantic Materialism and the New Logics of Life
(/isis/citation/CBB350652099/)
Book
Paolo Pecere;
(2023)
La natura della mente. Da Cartesio alle scienze cognitive
(/isis/citation/CBB751480142/)
Article
Eric Watkins;
(2016)
Kant on Materialism
(/isis/citation/CBB543200392/)
Article
Boris Demarest;
(2017)
Kant’s Epigenesis: Specificity and Developmental Constraints
(/isis/citation/CBB625286946/)
Book
Mensch, Jennifer;
(2013)
Kant's Organicism: Epigenesis and the Development of Critical Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB001213143/)
Article
Moya, Eugenio;
(2005)
Epigénesis y validez: El papel de la embriología en el programa transcendental de Kant
(/isis/citation/CBB000933618/)
Chapter
Zammito, John;
(2006)
Kant's Early Views on Epigenesis: The Role of Maupertuis
(/isis/citation/CBB000771983/)
Article
Ingensiep, Hans Werner;
(2006)
Organism, Epigenesis, and Life in Kant's Thinking---Biophilosophy between Transcendental Philosophy, Intuitive Analogy, and Empirical Ontology
(/isis/citation/CBB000933665/)
Article
Zammito, John H.;
(2003)
“This Inscrutable Principle of an Original Organization”: Epigenesis and “Looseness of Fit” in Kant's Philosophy of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB000340872/)
Article
Cohen, Alix A.;
(2006)
Kant on Epigenesis, Monogenesis and Human Nature: The Biological Premises of Anthropology
(/isis/citation/CBB000770747/)
Article
Zammito, John H.;
(2012)
The Lenoir Thesis Revisited: Blumenbach and Kant
(/isis/citation/CBB001221595/)
Book
Michela Massimi;
Angela Breitenbach;
(2017)
Kant and the Laws of Nature
(/isis/citation/CBB352248455/)
Article
Gaukroger, Stephen W.;
(2016)
Kant and the Nature of Matter: Mechanics, Chemistry, and the Life Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB488505787/)
Be the first to comment!