Buchanan, Roderick D. (Author)
Bradley, James (Author)
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Volume: 108
Issue: 3
Pages: 529-552
The suggestion that Darwin delayed publishing his species theory has long occupied a central part of his biographical storyline. The notion of a fretful delay reached a melodramatic apogee in Adrian Desmond and James Moore’s best-selling 1991 biography. Janet Browne’s acclaimed work downplayed the pathos but depicted a somewhat hesitant Darwin. In 2007 John van Wyhe upended this tableau, arguing that there was no evidence to support a secretive, fear-based delay. Contrary to van Wyhe, this essay suggests that Darwin was only selectively and strategically open about his belief in transmutation prior to his barnacle project. The 1844 appearance of the anonymously published Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation was one in a series of blows that prompted Darwin to reappraise the evidential requirements of his species theory. Nonetheless, much depends on how one interprets the barnacle project. Darwin’s decision to take on the whole group guaranteed its lengthy duration and effectively delayed his species work. The barnacle project could not be considered a necessary preparation, since it was not undertaken to address species theory problems. The evidence and insights Darwin gained from it were largely incidental and came after his decision to tackle the whole group. However, the credentialing motivations behind it were driven by field-generated self-doubts that are difficult to separate from fear. Darwin gained much-needed confidence from it and was far more open about his species theorizing afterward. The project helped Darwin become the authoritative figure he needed to be.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Bowler, Peter J.;
(1976)
Malthus, Darwin, and the concept of struggle
(/isis/citation/CBB000011623/)
Book
Barbara Larson;
Sabine Flach;
(2013)
Darwin and Theories of Aesthetics and Cultural History
(/isis/citation/CBB412176834/)
Book
Duncan Porter;
Peter Graham;
(2015)
Darwin's Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB157464904/)
Book
J. David Archibald;
(2017)
Origins of Darwin's Evolution: Solving the Species Puzzle Through Time and Place
(/isis/citation/CBB621122134/)
Chapter
Roberts, Jon H.;
(2010)
Religious Reactions to Darwin
(/isis/citation/CBB001031850/)
Book
Johnson, Curtis N.;
(2015)
Darwin's Dice: The Idea of Chance in the Thought of Charles Darwin
(/isis/citation/CBB001551961/)
Article
Breuer, Hans-Peter;
(1987)
Darwinism in Victorian letters
(/isis/citation/CBB000041151/)
Article
Hajo Greif;
(2015)
The Darwinian tension: Romantic science and the causal laws of nature
(/isis/citation/CBB515135796/)
Article
Pan, Jixing;
(1984)
Charles Darwin's Chinese sources
(/isis/citation/CBB000010428/)
Book
Marius De Biasi;
(2019)
Il bisogno di Dio: Darwin, pensiero religioso, umanizzazione
(/isis/citation/CBB185664884/)
Book
Corbett, David;
(1980)
Darwin and evolution
(/isis/citation/CBB000005169/)
Chapter
Herkner, Bernd;
(2009)
The World of Charles Darwin
(/isis/citation/CBB001031463/)
Book
Elder, Gregory P.;
(1996)
Chronic vigour: Darwin, Anglicans, Catholics, and the development of a doctrine of providential evolution
(/isis/citation/CBB000068701/)
Book
Janet Browne;
Jeremy DeSilva;
(2021)
A Most Interesting Problem: What Darwin’s Descent of Man Got Right and Wrong about Human Evolution
(/isis/citation/CBB973350869/)
Book
Michael Ruse;
(2016)
Darwinism as Religion: What Literature Tells Us about Evolution
(/isis/citation/CBB247868178/)
Thesis
Jeffrey Thomas Wright;
(2016)
Darwin, Huxley, and the Nineteenth-Century Rhetoric of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB948034428/)
Article
Kathryn Tabb;
(2016)
Darwin at Orchis Bank: Selection after the Origin
(/isis/citation/CBB704610076/)
Article
Cornell, John F.;
(1984)
Analogy and technology in Darwin's vision of nature
(/isis/citation/CBB000013314/)
Thesis
Varno, Theodore James;
(2011)
The Nature of Tomorrow: Inbreeding in Industrial Agriculture and Evolutionary Thought in Britain and the United States, 1859--1925
(/isis/citation/CBB001567261/)
Article
Ulrich Krohs;
(2022)
Darwin’s empirical claim and the janiform character of fitness proxies
(/isis/citation/CBB424930844/)
Literature and Medicine
Journal of the History of Ideas
Journal of the History of Biology
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Biology and Philosophy
Be the first to comment!