Turing and Church formulated two different formal accounts of computability that turned out to be extensionally equivalent. Since the accounts refer to different properties they cannot both be adequate conceptual analyses of the concept of computability. This insight has led to a discussion concerning which account is adequate. Some authors have suggested that this philosophical debate—which shows few signs of converging on one view—can be circumvented by regarding Church’s and Turing’s theses as explications. This move opens up the possibility that both accounts could be adequate, albeit in their own different ways. In this paper, I focus on the question of whether Church’s thesis can be seen as an explication in the precise Carnapian sense. Most importantly, I address an additional constraint that Carnap puts on the explicative power of axiomatic systems—an axiomatisation explicates when it is clear which mathematical entities form the theory’s intended model—and that implicitly applies to axiomatisations of recursion theory used in Church’s account of computability. To overcome this difficulty, I propose two possible clarifications of the pre-systematic concept of “computability” that can both be captured in recursion theory, and I show how both clarifications avoid an objection arising from Carnap’s constraint.
...More
Book
B. Jack Copeland;
Carl J. Posy;
Oron Shagrir;
(2015)
Computability: Turing, Gödel, Church, and Beyond
(/isis/citation/CBB900019272/)
Book
Turing, Alan Mathison;
Appel, Andrew W.;
Feferman, Solomon;
(2012)
Alan Turing's Systems of Logic: The Princeton Thesis
(/isis/citation/CBB001213136/)
Book
Jack Copeland;
Jonathan Bowen;
Mark Sprevak;
Robin Wilson;
(2017)
The Turing Guide
(/isis/citation/CBB709222979/)
Book
Rod Adams;
(2011)
An Early History of Recursive Functions and Computability from Godel to Turing
(/isis/citation/CBB059820056/)
Book
Hodges, Andrew;
(2000)
Alan Turing: the Enigma
(/isis/citation/CBB000110152/)
Article
Copeland, B. Jack;
Proudfoot, Diane;
(2011-2012)
Alan Turing, Father of the Modern Computer
(/isis/citation/CBB001210378/)
Book
Copeland, B. Jack;
(2012)
Turing: Pioneer of the Information Age
(/isis/citation/CBB001253045/)
Book
Giovanni Sommaruga;
Thomas Strahm;
(2016)
Turing’s Revolution: The Impact of His Ideas about Computability
(/isis/citation/CBB732084224/)
Article
Hodges, Andrew;
(2012)
Beyond Turing's Machines
(/isis/citation/CBB001320475/)
Article
Sojo, Aurea Anguera de;
Ares, Juan;
Lara, Juan A.;
Lizcano, David;
Martínez, María A.;
Pazos, Juan;
(2013)
Turing and the Serendipitous Discovery of the Modern Computer
(/isis/citation/CBB001320868/)
Book
Turing, Sara;
(2012)
Alan M. Turing
(/isis/citation/CBB001251444/)
Article
Cassou-Noguès, Pierre;
(2008)
Gödel et la thèse de Turing
(/isis/citation/CBB000930661/)
Article
Alessio Persichetti;
(2021)
The later Wittgenstein’s guide to contradictions
(/isis/citation/CBB312904403/)
Book
Andrew Hodges;
Douglas Hofstadter;
(2014)
Alan Turing: The Enigma: The Book That Inspired the Film "The Imitation Game"
(/isis/citation/CBB485951446/)
Article
Stillwell, John;
(2004)
Emil Post and His Anticipation of Gödel and Turing
(/isis/citation/CBB000771953/)
Article
Aldrich, John;
(2009)
England and Continental Probability in the Inter-War Years
(/isis/citation/CBB001021431/)
Chapter
Field, J. V.;
(2009)
British Cryptanalysis: The Breaking of “Fish” Traffic
(/isis/citation/CBB000960225/)
Book
Jan Von Plato;
(2017)
The Great Formal Machinery Works: Theories of Deduction and Computation at the Origins of the Digital Age
(/isis/citation/CBB573478690/)
Book
McKay, Sinclair;
(2010)
The Secret Life of Bletchley Park: The History of the Wartime Codebreaking Centre by the Men and Women Who Were There
(/isis/citation/CBB001212751/)
Article
Petrovic, Aleksander;
(2004)
Development of the First Hydraulic Analog Computer
(/isis/citation/CBB000770607/)
Be the first to comment!