In 2015, Tomasetti and Vogelstein published a paper in Science containing the following provocative statement: “… only a third of the variation in cancer risk among tissues is attributable to environmental factors or inherited predispositions. The majority is due to “bad luck,” that is, random mutations arising during DNA replication in normal, noncancerous stem cells.” The paper—and perhaps especially this rather coy reference to “bad luck”—became a flash point for a series of letters and reviews, followed by replies and yet further counterpoints. In this paper, I critically assess Tomasetti and Vogelstein's argument, discuss the meaning of “luck” (or, better: “chance”) in the context of the debate, and use this case study to address larger questions about methodological criteria for causal explanations of population level patterns in biomedicine.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Merlin, Francesca;
(2013)
Mutations et aléas: le hasard dans la théorie de l'évolution
Article
Tudor M. Baetu;
(2020)
Causal inference in biomedical research
Article
Alexander R. Fiorentino;
Olaf Dammann;
(2015)
Evidence, illness, and causation: An epidemiological perspective on the Russo–Williamson Thesis
Article
Peter Keating;
Alberto Cambrosio;
Nicole C. Nelson;
(2016)
“Triple negative breast cancer”: Translational research and the (re)assembling of diseases in post-genomic medicine
Article
Nikos Karfakis;
(2018)
The biopolitics of CFS/ME
Article
Shirley Sun;
Ann Hui Ching;
(2021)
Social Systems Matter: Precision Medicine, Public Health, and the Medical Model
Article
Lisa Lindén;
(July 2021)
Moving Evidence: Patients’ Groups, Biomedical Research, and Affects
Book
Carsten Timmermann;
(2020)
Moonshots at Cancer: The Roche Story
Thesis
Beza Merid;
(2015)
Performing Health: Stand-up Comedy and the Production of Biomedical Knowledge
Article
Alexander von Schwerin;
(2015)
Shaping Vulnerable Bodies at the Thin Boundary between Environment and Organism: Skin, DNA Repair, and a Genealogy of DNA Care Strategies
Book
Marta Bertolaso;
(2016)
Philosophy of Cancer: A Dynamic and Relational View
Article
Goldstein, Donna M.;
Stawkowski, Magdalena E.;
(2015)
James V. Neel and Yuri E. Dubrova: Cold War Debates and the Genetic Effects of Low-Dose Radiation
Book
Tina Young Choi;
(2021)
Victorian Contingencies: Experiments in Literature, Science, and Play
Book
Chris Talbot;
(2017)
David Bohm: Causality and Chance, Letters to Three Women
Article
Leonore Fleming;
Robert Brandon;
(2015)
Why flying dogs are rare: A general theory of luck in evolutionary transitions
Book
Dudley, John;
(2012)
Aristotle's Concept of Chance: Accidents, Cause, Necessity, and Determinism
Article
Creager, Angela N. H.;
(2015)
Radiation, Cancer, and Mutation in the Atomic Age
Article
Strauss, Bernard S.;
(2000)
The stability of the genome and the genetic instability of tumors
Article
Joana Formosinho;
Adam Bencard;
Louise Whiteley;
(2022)
Environmentality in biomedicine: Microbiome research and the perspectival body
Article
Hogan, Andrew J.;
(2014)
The “Morbid Anatomy” of the Human Genome: Tracing the Observational and Representational Approaches of Postwar Genetics and Biomedicine The William Bynum Prize Essay
Biology and Philosophy
East Asian Science, Technology and Society: An International Journal
Historical Studies in the Natural Sciences
Journal of the History of Biology
Medical History
Be the first to comment!