While philosophers have subjected Galileo's classic thought experiments to critical analysis, they have tended to largely ignored the historical and intellectual context in which they were deployed, and the specific role they played in Galileo's overall vision of science. In this paper I investigate Galileo's use of thought experiments, by focusing on the epistemic and rhetorical strategies that he employed in attempting to answer the question of how one can know what would happen in an imaginary scenario. Here I argue we can find three different answers to this question in Galileo later dialogues, which reflect the changing meanings of ‘experience’ and ‘knowledge’ (scientia) in the early modern period. Once we recognise that Galileo's thought experiments sometimes drew on the power of memory and the explicit appeal to ‘common experience’, while at other times, they took the form of demonstrative arguments intended to have the status of necessary truths; and on still other occasions, they were extrapolations, or probable guesses, drawn from a carefully planned series of controlled experiments, it becomes evident that no single account of the epistemological relationship between thought experiment, experience and experiment can adequately capture the epistemic variety we find Galileo's use of imaginary scenarios. To this extent, we cannot neatly classify Galileo's use of thought experiments as either ‘medieval’ or ‘early modern’, but we should see them as indicative of the complex epistemological transformations of the early seventeenth century.
...More
Article
Raphael, Renée;
(2008)
Galileo's Discorsi and Mersenne's Nouvelles Pensées: Mersenne as a Reader of Galilean “Experience”
(/isis/citation/CBB000933722/)
Article
Marco Piccolino;
(2007)
I sensi, l'ambiguità, la conoscenza nell'opera di Galileo
(/isis/citation/CBB706125835/)
Essay Review
Maarten Van Dyck;
(2022)
Jochen Büttner, Swinging and Rolling: Unveiling Galileo's Unorthodox Path from a Challenging Problem to a New Science, Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer, 2019.
(/isis/citation/CBB028097226/)
Article
Finocchiaro, Maurice A.;
(2010)
Defending Copernicus and Galileo: Critical Reasoning and the Ship Experiment
(/isis/citation/CBB001032221/)
Article
Adam Fix;
(2019)
Esperienza, Teacher of All Things: Vincenzo Galilei’s Music as Artisanal Epistemology
(/isis/citation/CBB182945815/)
Chapter
Roy Sorensen;
(2012)
Veridical Idealizations
(/isis/citation/CBB197257981/)
Chapter
Yiftach Fehige;
Harald Wiltsche;
(2012)
The Body, Thought Experiments, and Phenomenology
(/isis/citation/CBB490701594/)
Chapter
Mark Shumelda;
(2012)
At the Limits of Possibility: Thought Experiments in Quantum
(/isis/citation/CBB190069058/)
Book
Mélanie Frappier;
James Robert Brown;
Letitia Meynell;
(2012)
Thought Experiments in Philosophy, Science, and the Arts
(/isis/citation/CBB107617511/)
Chapter
John D. Norton;
(2012)
Chasing the Light: Einstein’s Most Famous Thought Experiment
(/isis/citation/CBB201950329/)
Chapter
Geordie McComb;
(2012)
Thought Experiment, Definition, and Literary Fiction
(/isis/citation/CBB935102391/)
Chapter
James Robert Brown;
(2012)
What Do We See in a Thought Experiment?
(/isis/citation/CBB888317009/)
Chapter
Marco Buzzoni;
(2012)
Thought Experiments from a Kantian Point of View
(/isis/citation/CBB794939617/)
Chapter
Vrishali Subramanian;
Sanjay Chandrasekharan;
Nancy J. Nersessian;
(2012)
Computational Modeling: Is This the End of Thought Experiments in Science?
(/isis/citation/CBB739614030/)
Chapter
Richard T. W. Arthur;
(2012)
Can Thought Experiments Be Resolved by Experiment? The Case of Aristotle’s Wheel
(/isis/citation/CBB597559409/)
Chapter
Julian Reiss;
(2012)
Genealogical Thought Experiments in Economics
(/isis/citation/CBB482966499/)
Chapter
David Davies;
(2012)
Can Philosophical Thought Experiments Be ‘Screened’?
(/isis/citation/CBB334225094/)
Chapter
Nenad Miščević;
(2012)
Political Thought Experiments from Plato to Rawls
(/isis/citation/CBB233061316/)
Chapter
James W. McAllister;
(2012)
Thought Experiment and the Exercise of Imagination in Science
(/isis/citation/CBB240679175/)
Chapter
Palmerino, Carla Rita;
(2011)
Galileo's Use of Medieval Thought Experiments
(/isis/citation/CBB001321021/)
Be the first to comment!