‘A transverse scar on the neck’ – Psychosomatic approach in the differential diagnosis and surgical treatment of hyperthyroidism in post-war Finland (2021)
In the Finnish medical discussion during the middle decades of the twentieth century, the challenging differential diagnostics between hyperthyroidism and various neuroses was perceived to yield a risk of unnecessary surgical interventions of psychiatric patients. In 1963, the Finnish surgeon Erkki Saarenmaa claimed that ‘the most significant mark of a neurotic was a transverse scar on the neck’, a result of an unnecessary thyroid surgery. The utterance was connected to the complex nature of thyroid diseases, which seemed to be to ‘a great extent psychosomatic’. Setting forth from this statement, the article aims to decipher the connection between hyperthyroidism, unnecessary surgical treatment and the psychosomatic approach in Finnish medicine. Utilising a wide variety of published medical research and discussion in specialist journals, the article examines the theoretical debate around troublesome diagnostics of functional complaints. It focuses on the introduction of new medical ideas, namely the concepts of ‘psychosomatics’ and ‘stress’. In the process, the article aims to unveil a definition of psychosomatic illness that places it on a continuum between psychological and somatic illness. That psychosomatic approach creates a space with interpretative potential can be applied to the historiography of psychosomatic phenomena more generally. Further inquiry into the intersections of surgery and psychosomatics would enrich both historiographies. It is also argued that the historical study of psychosomatic syndromes may become skewed, if the term ‘psychosomatic’ is from the outset taken to signify something that is all in the mind.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Steffen Dörre;
(2021)
Epistemologische Neupositionierungen. Alexander Mitscherlich zwischen „naturwissenschaftlicher Methodik“, Psychoanalyse und Psychosomatischer Medizin
(/isis/citation/CBB497787903/)
Book
Raz, Mical;
(2013)
The Lobotomy Letters: The Making of American Psychosurgery
(/isis/citation/CBB001214411/)
Article
Volker Roelcke;
(2021)
Biografie, sozialer Kontext und Körper im Experiment: Evidenz durch integrierte Methodik am Beispiel der Blutdruckforschung bei Thure von Uexküll
(/isis/citation/CBB806766872/)
Article
Yorgos Dimitriadis;
(2020)
History of the opposition between psychogenesis and organogenesis in classic psychiatry: Part 2
(/isis/citation/CBB764779105/)
Article
Elisa Arnaudo;
(2018)
A history of psychogenic pain and its relevance for chronic pain medical understanding
(/isis/citation/CBB121363856/)
Thesis
Charlotte Mary Duffee;
(2022)
Fractures: A History and Philosophy of Patient Suffering in 20th-Century American Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB699793549/)
Article
Gilman, Sander L.;
(2008)
Electrotherapy and Mental Illness: Then and Now
(/isis/citation/CBB000950373/)
Article
Louise Hide;
(2012)
Making Sense of Pain: Delusions, Syphilis, and Somatic Pain in London County Council Asylums, c. 1900
(/isis/citation/CBB464595735/)
Article
Hayward, Rhodri;
(2009)
Enduring Emotions: James L. Halliday and the Invention of the Psychosocial
(/isis/citation/CBB000952988/)
Chapter
Beth Linker;
(2017)
Prosthetic Imaginaries: Spinal Surgery and Innovation from the Patient's Perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB901672688/)
Article
Dinges, Martin;
(2013)
Aufstieg und Fall des “Halbgottes in Weiß”? Gesellschaftliches Ansehen und Selbstverständnis von Ärzten (1800--2010)
(/isis/citation/CBB001421908/)
Article
Mauricio V Daker;
(2019)
The theory of symptom complexes, mind and madness
(/isis/citation/CBB264539507/)
Article
Elisabetta Basso Lorini;
(2017)
The erudite humility of the historian: the ‘critical epistemology’ of Georges Lantéri-Laura
(/isis/citation/CBB521505204/)
Article
Max Gawlich;
Ralph Höger;
(2021)
Recovery oder die Geschichte der psychiatrischen Heilung von ihrem Ende her erzählt?
(/isis/citation/CBB841738840/)
Book
Andrew Scull;
(2022)
Desperate Remedies: Psychiatry’s Turbulent Quest to Cure Mental Illness
(/isis/citation/CBB599271041/)
Chapter
Monika Ankele;
(2016)
The Patient's View of Work Therapy: The Mental Hospital Hamburg-Langenhorn During the Weimar Republic
(/isis/citation/CBB705274741/)
Article
Doyle, Dennis;
(2009)
“A Fine New Child”: The Lafargue Mental Hygiene Clinic and Harlem's African American Communities, 1946--1958
(/isis/citation/CBB000930501/)
Article
Balz, Viola;
(2013)
“Für einen Aktivisten wie mich muß es in einem sozialistischen Staat doch effektive Medikamente geben”
(/isis/citation/CBB001420971/)
Thesis
Doroshow, Deborah Blythe;
(2012)
Emotionally Disturbed Residential Treatment, Child Psychiatry, and the Creation of Normal Children in Mid-Twentieth Century America
(/isis/citation/CBB001567369/)
Chapter
Osamu Nakamura;
(2016)
Patient Work and Family Care at Iwakura, Japan, C. 1799-1970
(/isis/citation/CBB402213161/)
Be the first to comment!