Citizen Science in News Media: Boundary Mediation of Public Participation in Health Expertise (2024)
Elizabeth Carolina Mayes (Author)
Science, Technology, and Human Values
Volume: 49
Issue: 2
Pages: 211-237
In this article, I examine how scientific boundary work describes or represents citizen science as credible forms of expertise. Citizen science is an ambiguous concept, and I leverage that ambiguity to examine citizen science as a proxy for nonprofessional or noninstitutional scientific practices more generally. I argue that media representations of citizen science perform boundary work through different articulations of institutional “buy-in” to the legitimacy or credibility of citizen science. Using a discourse analysis of mainstream news media, I trace three framings of citizen science’s relationship to institutional networks, which I describe as subservient to, corrective to, and exceeding the norms of institutional expertise. I find that the perspectives of professional, credentialed scientists dominate public discourse concerning citizen science and perform different adjudications of how citizen science contributes to networks of expertise. By focusing on citizen science concerning human health and medicine, I additionally show how mainstream framings of citizen science engage with overlapping media representations of personal health responsibility and patient empowerment. I suggest that representations of citizen science as a form of “missing expertise” can conflict with portrayals of citizen science as “going too far” in the pursuit of treatments or interventions.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Sedona Chinn;
P. Sol Hart;
Stuart Soroka;
(2020)
Politicization and Polarization in Climate Change News Content, 1985-2017
Article
Ivanka Pjesivac;
Marlit A. Hayslett;
Matthew T. Binford;
(2020)
To Eat or Not to Eat: Framing of GMOs in American Media and Its Effects on Attitudes and Behaviors
Article
Sarah Schönbauer;
Ruth Müller;
(2021)
A Risky Object? How Microplastics Are Represented in the German Media
Article
Khudejah Ali;
Khawaja Zain-ul-abdin;
Cong Li;
Lisa Johns;
Ayesha Aziz Ali;
Nicholas Carcioppolo;
(2019)
Viruses Going Viral: Impact of Fear-Arousing Sensationalist Social Media Messages on User Engagement
Article
P. Sol Hart;
Sedona Chinn;
Stuart Soroka;
(2020)
Politicization and Polarization in COVID-19 News Coverage
Article
Jacob B. Rode;
Saad Iqbal;
Brendon J. Butler;
Peter H. Ditto;
(2021)
Using a News Article to Convey Climate Science Consensus Information
Article
Zongya Li;
(2021)
Role of Affective Mediators in the Effects of Media Use on Proenvironmental Behavior
Article
Michael F. Dahlstrom;
Zhe Wang;
Sonja Lindberg;
Kasey Opfer;
Christopher L. Cummings;
(2023)
The Media’s Taste for Gene-Edited Food: Comparing Media Portrayals within US and European Regulatory Environments
Article
Timothy K. F. Fung;
Kang Namknoong;
Jiyoun Kim;
Po Yan Lai;
(2022)
Linking Psychometric Paradigm of Risk and Issue Attention Cycle: Risk Information in News Coverage of Avian and Swine Influenza Global Outbreaks
Article
Jan-Peter Voß;
Nina Amelung;
(October 2016)
Innovating public participation methods: Technoscientization and reflexive engagement
Article
Norma Möllers;
(June 2016)
Shifting in and out of context: Technoscientific drama as technology of the self
Article
Chelsea L. Ratcliff;
(2021)
Communicating Scientific Uncertainty Across the Dissemination Trajectory: A Precision Medicine Case Study
Article
Jonas Rüppel;
(2019)
“Now Is a Time for Optimism”: The Politics of Personalized Medicine in Mental Health Research
Article
Toby Bolsen;
Risa Palm;
Justin T. Kingsland;
(2020)
Framing the Origins of COVID-19
Article
Yan Huang;
Chun Yang;
(2020)
A Metacognitive Approach to Reconsidering Risk Perceptions and Uncertainty: Understand Information Seeking During COVID-19
Article
Nicole Kashian;
Tala Mirzaei;
(2019)
Understanding Communication Effectiveness, Communication Satisfaction, Self-Efficacy, and Self-Care Management Among Patients With Chronic Disease
Article
Mette N. Svendsen;
Laura E. Navne;
(2023)
Citizen-Person: The “Me” in the “We” in Danish Precision Medicine
Article
Sara Lafuente-Funes;
(2023)
The Role of Vitrification in Spanish Reproductive Labs: A Cryo-revolution Led by Strategic Freezing
Article
Abigail H. Neely;
Laura A. Meek;
(2024)
African Experiments in Health and Healing: Science from the Home and Homestead
Article
Bianca Jansky;
(2024)
Digitized Patients: Elaborative Tinkering and Knowledge Practices in the Open-source Type 1 Diabetes “Looper Community”
Be the first to comment!