Technological Fix or Divisible Object of Collective Concern? Histories of Conflict over the Geological Disposal of Nuclear Waste in Sweden and France (2020)
Barthe, Yannick (Author)
Elam, Mark (Author)
Sundqvist, Göran (Author)
Science as Culture
Volume: 29
Issue: 2
Pages: 196-218
Science and technology studies (STS) has cultivated a positive vision of technological controversies. By raising new issues to address, controversies are seen as generating more thorough and exhaustive processes of technology assessment. However, the ability to view controversies in this light remains dependent upon how technology is collectively imagined and understood. If it is envisioned as a classic technological fix then broader controversy is just what is intended to be overcome, not positively indulged. Albert Hirschman’s distinction between divisible and non-divisible conflicts captures such varying evaluations of controversy. In particular, it helps analyse how the long-standing fix of geological disposal of nuclear waste has been persistently defended as a non-negotiable object of technological concern – a recipe for escaping controversy by permanently isolating nuclear waste from the biosphere. Comparing the Swedish and French programmes for the geological disposal of nuclear waste shows how defending the technological integrity of a non-divisible disposal concept has remained an institutional fixation for Swedish nuclear waste management for over 30 years. In contrast, legislative demands for a reversible disposal concept introduced in France in the late 1990s have arguably served to unravel a technological fix into a divisible object of collective concern.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Evans, Joshua;
Garvin, Theresa;
(2009)
“You're In Oil Country”: Moral Tales of Citizen Action against Petroleum Development in Alberta, Canada
(/isis/citation/CBB001031184/)
Book
Doyle, Timothy;
(2013)
Environmental Movements around the World: Shades of Green in Politics and Culture
(/isis/citation/CBB001213198/)
Book
Charles Halvorson;
(2021)
Valuing Clean Air: The EPA and the Economics of Environmental Protection
(/isis/citation/CBB488007911/)
Article
Cabin, Robert J.;
(2013)
Nature Is Dead. Long Live Nature!
(/isis/citation/CBB001320839/)
Article
Alfred Lameli;
(2018)
Alte Karten, neue Daten. Zur Transformation eines historischen Grundlagenwerks der Sprachwissenschaft
(/isis/citation/CBB380372109/)
Book
Sarah Farmer;
(2020)
Rural Inventions: The French Countryside after 1945
(/isis/citation/CBB137637811/)
Article
Mathieu Gervais;
(2021)
The Spiritualization of Ecology and (De)politicization
(/isis/citation/CBB370840329/)
Book
McCutcheon, Charles;
(2002)
Nuclear Reactions: The Politics of Opening a Radioactive Waste Disposal Site
(/isis/citation/CBB000301968/)
Thesis
Richter, Jennifer;
(2013)
New Mexico's Nuclear Enchantment: Local Politics, National Imperatives, and Radioactive Waste Disposal
(/isis/citation/CBB001567530/)
Article
Cittadino, Eugene;
(2015)
Paul Sears and the Plowshare Advisory Committee: “Subversive” Ecologist Endorses Nuclear Excavation?
(/isis/citation/CBB001552127/)
Chapter
Yves Bouvier;
(2012)
Filming Electrical Consumption: EDF’s Promotional Films (1946-2004)
(/isis/citation/CBB509113873/)
Article
Knight, Catherine;
(2010)
The Nature Conservation Movement in Post-War Japan
(/isis/citation/CBB001231342/)
Article
Dale, Ann;
Ling, Chris;
Newman, Lenore;
(2008)
Does Place Matter? Sustainable Community Development in Three Canadian Communities
(/isis/citation/CBB001031189/)
Article
Marcin Krasnodębski;
(2018)
Throwing Light on Photonics: The Genealogy of a Technological Paradigm
(/isis/citation/CBB299212489/)
Chapter
Kasperski, Tatiana;
Matthew Cotton;
Markku Lehtonen;
(2021)
Trust and Mistrust in Radioactive Waste Management:
Historical Experience from High- and Low-Trust Contexts
(/isis/citation/CBB735818295/)
Book
Paddy Woodworth;
(2013)
Our Once and Future Planet: Restoring the World in the Climate Change Century
(/isis/citation/CBB765014471/)
Chapter
Jørgensen, Finn Arne;
(2013)
The Backbone of Everyday Environmentalism: Cultural Scripting and Technological Systems
(/isis/citation/CBB001420341/)
Article
Brockington, Dan;
Sachedina, Hassan;
Scholfield, Katherine;
(2008)
Preserving the New Tanzania: Conservation and Land Use Change
(/isis/citation/CBB001031166/)
Book
Rangan, Haripriya;
(2000)
Of Myths and Movements: Rewriting Chipko into Himalayan History
(/isis/citation/CBB000650492/)
Book
Simone Schleper;
(2019)
Planning for the Planet: Environmental Expertise and the International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources, 1960–1980
(/isis/citation/CBB601917974/)
Be the first to comment!