Article ID: CBB374064986

Pluralization Through Epistemic Competition: Scientific Change in Times of Data-Intensive Biology (2019)

unapi

We present two case studies from contemporary biology in which we observe conflicts between established and emerging approaches. The first case study discusses the relation between molecular biology and systems biology regarding the explanation of cellular processes, while the second deals with phylogenetic systematics and the challenge posed by recent network approaches to established ideas of evolutionary processes. We show that the emergence of new fields is in both cases driven by the development of high-throughput data generation technologies and the transfer of modeling techniques from other fields. New and emerging views are characterized by different philosophies of nature, i.e. by different ontological and methodological assumptions and epistemic values and virtues. This results in a kind of conflict we call “epistemic competition” that manifests in two ways: On the one hand, opponents engage in mutual critique and defense of their fundamental assumptions. On the other hand, they compete for the acceptance and integration of the knowledge they provide by a broader scientific community. Despite an initial rhetoric of replacement, the views as well as the respective audiences come to be seen as more clearly distinct during the course of the debate. Hence, we observe—contrary to many other accounts of scientific change—that conflict results in the formation of new niches of research, leading to co-existence and perceived complementarity of approaches. Our model thus contributes to the understanding of the pluralization of the scientific landscape.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB374064986/

Similar Citations

Article Anu Masso; Maris Männiste; Andra Siibak; (2020)
‘End of Theory’ in the Era of Big Data: Methodological Practices and Challenges in Social Media Studies (/isis/citation/CBB632756299/)

Book Michel Morange; (2020)
The Black Box of Biology: A History of the Molecular Revolution (/isis/citation/CBB035364586/)

Article Jessica Pykett; Mark Paterson; (2022)
Stressing the ‘body electric’: History and psychology of the techno-ecologies of work stress (/isis/citation/CBB933468112/)

Article Cornelius Borck; (2022)
Tactile Vision, Epistemic Things and Data Visualization (/isis/citation/CBB349465898/)

Book Federico Boem; (2023)
Pensare per mappe. Ontologie per una pratica scientifica (/isis/citation/CBB601271154/)

Article O'Malley, Maureen A.; Soyer, Orkun S.; (2012)
The Roles of Integration in Molecular Systems Biology (/isis/citation/CBB001221587/)

Article Elliott, Kevin C.; (2012)
Epistemic and Methodological Iteration in Scientific Research (/isis/citation/CBB001221695/)

Essay Review Huggett, Nick; Smith, George E; Miller, David Marshall; Harper, William; (2013)
On Newton's Method (/isis/citation/CBB001500196/)

Book Sara Green; (2016)
Philosophy of Systems Biology: Perspectives from Scientists and Philosophers (/isis/citation/CBB545077792/)

Book Sabina Leonelli; (2016)
Data-Centric Biology: A Philosophical Study (/isis/citation/CBB591798110/)

Article María Elissa Torres Carrasco; (2022)
Neoconservative camouflage: The datafication of abortion debates in Ecuador (/isis/citation/CBB507888120/)

Book Germaine Halegoua; (2020)
Smart Cities (/isis/citation/CBB219487083/)

Article Włodzimierz Gogołek; (2017)
Refining Big Data (/isis/citation/CBB158654943/)

Article James Justus; Samantha Wakil; (2021)
The algorithmic turn in conservation biology: Characterizing progress in ethically-driven sciences (/isis/citation/CBB088304027/)

Authors & Contributors
Siibak, Andra
Włodzimierz Gogołek
Boem, Federico
Jessica Pykett
Casini, Silvia
Flis, Ivan
Concepts
Data analysis
Data collection; methods
Biology
Philosophy of science
Big data
Systems biology
Time Periods
21st century
20th century, late
20th century
19th century
18th century
17th century
Places
Scotland
Ecuador
Institutions
University of Aberdeen
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment