This paper reinforces the current consensus against the applicability of the selected effect theory of function in ecology. It does so by presenting an argument which, in contrast with the usual argument invoked in support of this consensus, is not based on claims about whether ecosystems are customary units of natural selection. Instead, the argument developed here is based on observations about the use of the function concept in functional ecology, and more specifically, research into the relationship between biodiversity and ecosystem functioning. It is argued that a selected effect account of ecological functions is made implausible by the fact that it would conflict with important aspects of the understanding of function and ecosystem functional organization which underpins functional ecology's research program. Specifically, it would conflict with (1) Functional ecology's adoption of a context-based understanding of function and its aim to study the functional equivalence between phylogenetically-divergent organisms; (2) Functional ecology's attribution to ecosystems of a lower degree of part-whole integration than the one found in paradigm individual organisms; and (3) Functional ecology's adoption of a physiological or metabolic perspective on ecosystems rather than an evolutionary one.
...More
Article
Reuss, Martin;
Bernhardtb, Emily;
Bunna, Stuart E.;
Hartc, David D.;
Björn Malmqvistd, Timo Muotkae;
Naimanf, Robert J.;
Pringleg, Catherine;
Wilgeni, Brian van;
(2006)
Perspective: The Challenge of Ecologically Sustainable Water Management
(/isis/citation/CBB001180773/)
Article
Palomares, Maria Lourdes D.;
Heymans, Johanna J.;
Pauly, Daniel;
(2007)
Historical Ecology of the Raja Ampat Archipelago, Papua Province, Indonesia
(/isis/citation/CBB000831351/)
Article
van der Valk, Arnold G.;
(2014)
From Formation to Ecosystem: Tansley's Response to Clements' Climax
(/isis/citation/CBB001214554/)
Article
Hedin, Lars O.;
(2012)
F. Herbert Bormann (1922--2012)
(/isis/citation/CBB001320470/)
Thesis
Herron, John Paul;
(2001)
“The reality of living”: Science, gender, and nature in American culture, 1865-1965
(/isis/citation/CBB001560932/)
Article
Schizas, Dimitris G.;
Stamou, George P.;
(2006)
The Concept of Life and Its Significance in the Construction of the New Ecosystem Ecology of Bernard Patten, Sven Jørgensen and Milan Straškraba
(/isis/citation/CBB000740908/)
Article
Höhler, Sabine;
(2010)
The Environment as a Life Support System: The Case of Biosphere 2
(/isis/citation/CBB001030021/)
Article
Sörlin, Sverker;
(2007)
Ekologins amerikanska historia. Rötter i storstad och öken
(/isis/citation/CBB001220356/)
Book
West, Paige;
(2006)
Conservation is Our Government Now: The Politics of Ecology in Papua New Guinea
(/isis/citation/CBB000772104/)
Book
Maclaurin, James;
Sterelny, Kim;
(2008)
What Is Biodiversity?
(/isis/citation/CBB000954230/)
Article
Simberloff, Daniel;
(2012)
Integrity, Stability, and Beauty: Aldo Leopold's Evolving View of Nonnative Species
(/isis/citation/CBB001232543/)
Article
Aaron Wells;
(2020)
Kant, Linnaeus, and the economy of nature
(/isis/citation/CBB872058525/)
Article
Latorre, Juan Garcia;
Picon, Andres Sanchez;
Latorre, Jesus Garcia;
(2001)
The Man-Made Desert: Effects of Economic and Demographic Growth on the Ecosystems of Arid Southeastern Spain
(/isis/citation/CBB000101031/)
Book
Chazdon, Robin L.;
Whitmore, T. C.;
(2001)
Foundations of Tropical Forest Biology: Classic Papers with Commentaries
(/isis/citation/CBB000102621/)
Book
Carmel Finley;
(2017)
All the Boats on the Ocean: How Government Subsidies Led to Global Overfishing
(/isis/citation/CBB479199142/)
Article
Taylor, Peter;
(2000)
Socio-Ecological Webs and Sites of Sociality: Levins' Strategy of Model Building Revisited
(/isis/citation/CBB000111091/)
Book
Vetter, Jeremy;
(2010)
Knowing Global Environments: New Historical Perspectives in the Field Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB001021712/)
Book
Coleman, David C.;
(2010)
Big Ecology: The Emergence of Ecosystem Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001020904/)
Article
Jørgensen, Dolly;
(2009)
An Oasis in a Watery Desert? Discourses on an Industrial Ecosystem in the Gulf of Mexico Rigs-to-Reefs Program
(/isis/citation/CBB000954323/)
Essay Review
Hagen, Joel B.;
(2014)
Emerging Ecologies: Past, Present, and Future
(/isis/citation/CBB001566303/)
Be the first to comment!