IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB369219796

Locating the ‘culture wars’ in laboratory animal research: National constitutions and global competition (2021)

Davies, Gail (Author)

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Volume: 89
Pages: 177-187

URI: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0039368121001266

DOI: 10.1016/j.shpsa.2021.08.010

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

The increasingly global scope of biomedical research and testing using animals is generating disagreement over the best way to regulate laboratory animal science and care. Despite many common aims, the practices through which political and epistemic authority are allocated in the regulations around animal research varies internationally, coming together in what can be identified as different national constitutions. Tensions between these periodically erupt within the laboratory animal research community as a ‘cultural war’ between those favouring centralised control and those advocating local flexibility. Drawing on long-term engagement with key events and actors in these policy debates, I propose these national differences in the constitution of animal research can be understood through the intersection of two key variables: i) the location of institutional responsibility to permit research projects and ii) the distribution of epistemic authority to shape research practices. These variables are used to explain the development of different policy frameworks in the UK, Europe, and the USA, and identify where there is convergence and divergence in practice. Concluding, I suggest the way these approaches are combined and enacted in different countries reflects different national civic epistemologies, which are coming into conflict in the increasingly global networks of laboratory animal science.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB369219796/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Simon Lohse; (2021)
Scientific inertia in animal-based research in biomedicine (/isis/citation/CBB124857110/)

Article Per-Anders Svärd; Helena Tinnerholm Ljungberg; (2021)
Fetal and animal research in Sweden: The construction of viable lives in regulatory policy debates, 1970–1980 (/isis/citation/CBB965696186/)

Article Rebecca A. Hardesty; (2018)
Much ado about mice: Standard-setting in model organism research (/isis/citation/CBB487976291/)

Article Brad Bolman; (2022)
Dogs for Life: Beagles, Drugs, and Capital in the Twentieth Century (/isis/citation/CBB399574473/)

Article Karen A. Rader; (2022)
Reflections on Making Mice (2004) (/isis/citation/CBB321873815/)

Article Tarquin Holmes; (2017)
The wild type as concept and in experimental practice: A history of its role in classical genetics and evolutionary theory (/isis/citation/CBB016897194/)

Article Brad Bolman; (2021)
Pig Mentations: Race and Face in Radiobiology (/isis/citation/CBB398870305/)

Article Colleen Lanier-Christensen; (September 2021)
Creating Regulatory Harmony: The Participatory Politics of OECD Chemical Testing Standards in the Making (/isis/citation/CBB606231580/)

Article Hannah Landecker; (2016)
It is what it eats: Chemically defined media and the history of surrounds (/isis/citation/CBB598422047/)

Article Christine Hauskeller; Nicole Baur; Jean Harrington; (2019)
Standards, Harmonization and Cultural Differences: Examining the Implementation of a European Stem Cell Clinical Trial (/isis/citation/CBB953736485/)

Article David J. Gerber; (Winter 2019)
Prisms of Distance and Power: Viewing the U.S. Regulatory Tradition (/isis/citation/CBB183281762/)

Book Rachel K. Gibson; (2020)
When the Nerds Go Marching In: How Digital Technology Moved from the Margins to the Mainstream of Political Campaigns (/isis/citation/CBB385530642/)

Article Robert G. W. Kirk; Edmund Ramsden; (2021)
"Havens of mercy”: health, medical research, and the governance of the movement of dogs in twentieth-century America (/isis/citation/CBB713465624/)

Article Angela N. H. Creager; (2022)
Model Organisms Unbound (/isis/citation/CBB532396920/)

Article Brad Bolman; (2022)
Introduction: What Right? Which Organisms? Why Jobs? (/isis/citation/CBB702630053/)

Article Lene Koch; Mette N. Svendsen; (May 2015)
Negotiating Moral Value: A Story of Danish Research Monkeys and Their Humans (/isis/citation/CBB281898023/)

Article Pilgrim, David; (2014)
Historical Resonances of the DSM-5 Dispute: American Exceptionalism or Eurocentrism? (/isis/citation/CBB001420217/)

Article deJong-Lambert, William; Krementsov, Nikolai; (2012)
On Labels and Issues: The Lysenko Controversy and the Cold War (/isis/citation/CBB001250824/)

Thesis Alexis J. Abboud; (2018)
A Biography of Endocrine Disruptors: The Narrative Surrounding the Appearance and Regulation of a New Category of Toxic Substances (/isis/citation/CBB313774069/)

Article Adam Hedgecoe; (July 2017)
Scandals, Ethics, and Regulatory Change in Biomedical Research (/isis/citation/CBB888213703/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}