The Bayesian approach to forensic evidence: Evaluating, communicating, and distributing responsibility (October 2013)
This article draws attention to communication across professions as an important aspect of forensic evidence. Based on ethnographic fieldwork in the Swedish legal system, it shows how forensic scientists use a particular quantitative approach to evaluating forensic laboratory results, the Bayesian approach, as a means of quantifying uncertainty and communicating it accurately to judges, prosecutors, and defense lawyers, as well as a means of distributing responsibility between the laboratory and the court. This article argues that using the Bayesian approach also brings about a particular type of intersubjectivity; in order to make different types of forensic evidence commensurable and combinable, quantifications must be consistent across forensic specializations, which brings about a transparency based on shared understandings and practices. Forensic scientists strive to keep the black box of forensic evidence – at least partly – open in order to achieve this transparency.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Nadine Levin;
Sabina Leonelli;
(March 2017)
How Does One “Open” Science? Questions of Value in Biological Research
(/isis/citation/CBB290502459/)
Article
Knaapen. Loes;
(October 2013)
Being ‘evidence-based’ in the absence of evidence: The management of non-evidence in guideline development
(/isis/citation/CBB444983980/)
Article
María Fernanda Olarte-Sierra;
(2019)
Of flesh and bone: Emotional and affective ethnography of forensic anthropology practices amidst an armed conflict
(/isis/citation/CBB046116318/)
Article
Julia Alejandra Morales-Fontanilla;
Santiago Martínez-Medina;
(2019)
Corpo-real ethnographies: Bodies, dissection planes, and cutting. Ethnography from the anatomy laboratory and the public morgues in Colombia
(/isis/citation/CBB581409108/)
Article
Alison Cool;
(August 2019)
Impossible, unknowable, accountable: Dramas and dilemmas of data law
(/isis/citation/CBB709306750/)
Article
Lambros Roumbanis;
(2022)
Disagreement and Agonistic Chance in Peer Review
(/isis/citation/CBB437513195/)
Article
Cornelius Schubert;
Andreas Kolb;
(May 2021)
Designing Technology, Developing Theory: Toward a Symmetrical Approach
(/isis/citation/CBB107590623/)
Article
Robin S. Gregory;
(January 2017)
The Troubling Logic of Inclusivity in Environmental Consultations
(/isis/citation/CBB229498527/)
Article
Sabina Leonelli;
Brian Rappert;
Gail Davies;
(March 2017)
Data Shadows: Knowledge, Openness, and Absence (Special Issue Introduction)
(/isis/citation/CBB950275922/)
Book
Suzuki, Mai;
(2017)
Kagaku kantei no esunogurafī: Nyūjīrando niokeru houkagaku raboratorī no jissen 科学鑑定のエスノグラフィ ニュージーランドにおける法科学ラボラトリーの実践 [An Ethnography of Forensic Science: Practices in the Forensic Laboratories of New Zealand]
(/isis/citation/CBB012530887/)
Article
Lambros Roumbanis;
(February 2017)
Academic judgments under uncertainty: A study of collective anchoring effects in Swedish Research Council panel groups
(/isis/citation/CBB341757393/)
Article
Marko Monteiro;
(2018)
Ethnography and interdisciplinary work: Experiences from the US and Brazil
(/isis/citation/CBB616934249/)
Article
Edwards, Paul N.;
Mayernik, Matthew S.;
Batcheller, Archer L.;
Bowker, Geoffrey C.;
Borgman, Christine L.;
(October 2011)
Science friction: Data, metadata, and collaboration
(/isis/citation/CBB261989499/)
Article
Victor Toom;
(July 2016)
Whose Body Is It? Technolegal Materialization of Victims’ Bodies and Remains after the World Trade Center Terrorist Attacks
(/isis/citation/CBB903588937/)
Article
Jialin Li;
(January 2021)
Cloaking the Pregnancy: Scientific Uncertainty and Gendered Burden among Middle-class Mothers in Urban China
(/isis/citation/CBB427082772/)
Article
Alice Street;
(December 2011)
Artefacts of not-knowing: The medical record, the diagnosis and the production of uncertainty in Papua New Guinean biomedicine
(/isis/citation/CBB480850883/)
Article
Federico Brandmayr;
(May 2017)
How Social Scientists Make Causal Claims in Court: Evidence from the L’Aquila Trial
(/isis/citation/CBB603433424/)
Article
Vivette García Deister;
(2023)
Critical contacts: making STS public amid Mexico’s forensic crisis
(/isis/citation/CBB673784229/)
Article
Erik Børve Rasmussen;
(December 2020)
Making and managing medical anomalies: Exploring the classification of ‘medically unexplained symptoms’
(/isis/citation/CBB131501262/)
Article
Jorge Castillo-Sepúlveda;
Francisco Tirado;
Ana Gálvez;
(2023)
Biopolitics and speculative objects in Chilean health projects
(/isis/citation/CBB679456149/)
Be the first to comment!