Mankind and its Histories: William Robertson, Georg Forster, and a Late Eighteenth-Century German Debate (2013)
The Scottish historian William Robertson's works on European encounter with non-European civilizations (History of America, 1777; Historical Disquisition […] of India, 1791) received a great deal of attention in contemporary Germany. Through correspondence with Robertson, as well as by reviewing and translating his texts, Johann Reinhold Forster and his son Georg took an active part in this process. The younger Forster also became simultaneously involved in a debate which was unfolding on the German intellectual scene concerning the different or equal “value” (Wert) of the various “races of mankind” (Menschenrassen), engaging especially the relevant views advanced by the Göttingen historian Christoph Meiners and Immanuel Kant. The debate was firmly embedded in the context of an emerging ‘science of man’ in the German Enlightenment, to which Forster contributed an almost incomparable richness of empirical knowledge as well as theoretical sophistication. Forster's direct engagement with Robertson's work during the same period (mid-1780s to the early 1790s) creates a context through which the Wissenschaft vom Menschen in the Aufklärung and the Scottish version of the science of man – built on the neighbour disciplines to which Robertson's historiography was crucially indebted – is set in an interesting comparative light. This paper, part of a comprehensive project tracing the German reception of Robertson as an instance of inter-cultural exchange in the Enlightenment, will exploit the opportunities presented by one particular and documented case for a general comparison of enlightened ‘sciences of man’.
...MoreArticle Alexander Cook; Ned Curthoys (2013) Introduction. Intellectual History Review (pp. 285-288).
Similar Citations
Chapter
Bödeker, Hans Erich;
(1999)
Aufklärerische ethnologische Praxis: Johann Reinhold Forster und Georg Forster
Book
Julian Drews;
Ottmar Ette;
Tobias Kraft;
Barbara Schneider-Kempf;
Jutta Weber;
(2017)
Forster - Humboldt - Chamisso: Weltreisende im Spannungsfeld der Kulturen
Article
Dawson, Ruth;
(1979)
Collecting with Cook: The Forsters and their artifact sales
Chapter
Thomas, Nicholas;
(1996)
Liberty and licence: The Forsters' account of New Zealand sociality
Book
Hauser-Schäublin, Brigitta;
Krüger, Gundolf;
(1998)
James Cook: Gifts and treasures from the South Seas: The Cook/Forster Collection, Göttingen
Article
Wolloch, Nathaniel;
(2012)
Animals in Enlightenment Historiography
Article
Rookmaaker, L.C.;
(1985)
The zoological notes by Johann Reinhold and Georg Forster included in Buffon's Histoire naturelle (1782)
Book
Hoare, Michael E.;
(1976)
“Three men in a boat”: The Forsters and New Zealand science
Book
Hoare, Michael E.;
(1979)
Enlightenment and New Zealand, 1773-1774: Essays commemorating the visit of Johann Reinhold Forster and George Forster to Queen Charlotte and Dusky Sounds
Book
Carhart, Michael C.;
(2007)
The Science of Culture in Enlightenment Germany
Article
Strack, Thomas;
(1996)
Philosophical anthropology on the eve of biological determinism: Immanuel Kant and Georg Forster on the moral qualities and biological characteristics of the human race
Book
Anne Mariss;
(2015)
'A World of New Things': Praktiken der Naturgeschichte bei Johann Reinhold Forster
Book
Pietro Daniel Omodeo;
(2016)
Duncan Liddel (1561-1613): Networks of Polymathy and the Northern European Renaissance
Article
de Bont, Raf;
(2013)
“Writing in Letters of Blood”: Manners in Scientific Dispute in Nineteenth-Century Britain and the German Lands
Article
Bont, Raf de;
(2013)
“Writing in Letters of Blood”: Manners in Scientific Dispute in Nineteenth-Century Britain and the German Lands
Article
Riedel, Manfred;
(1980)
Historizismus und Kritizismus: Kants Streit mit G. Forster und J. G. Herder
Article
Canizares, Jorge;
(1991)
Entre Maquiavelo y la jurisprudencia nacional: William Robertson y la disputa del Nuevo Mundo
Article
Martin Liebscher;
(2017)
German Émigré Psychologists in Tel Aviv (1934–58): Max M. Stern and Margarete Braband-Isaac in Conflict with Erich Neumann
Article
Jacques Gapaillard;
(2021)
The heliocentric path of the Moon
Article
Sebastiano Gino;
(2020)
Scottish Common Sense, Association of Ideas and Free Will
Be the first to comment!