Mathematical Selves and the Shaping of Mathematical Modernism: Conflicting Epistemic Ideals in the Emergence of Enumerative Geometry (1864–1893) (2021)
Nicolas, Michèle (Author)
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Volume: 112
Issue: 1
Pages: 68-92
For more than three decades, fierce debates raged both in private letters and across public spaces over a formula expressed in 1864 by the French geometer Michel Chasles. Proofs and refutations thereof abounded, to no avail: the formula was too useful to be abandoned by its defenders, too elusive to be made rigorous for its detractors. The disputes over Chasles’s formula would not be solved by a definitive proof or rebuttal; rather, the core epistemic issues at stake shifted from generality to rigor and from truth to geometrical significance. This essay tracks the main lines of circulation of Chasles’s formula and shows how the disputes to which it gave rise embody conflicting mathematical selves—that is to say, different normative accounts of what being a mathematician entails. This perspective allows for a renewed understanding of what historians have described as the conflicted rise of modernism in mathematics and a firmer rooting of it within broader late nineteenth-century cultural trends.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Nicolas Michel;
(2020)
The Values of Simplicity and Generality in Chasles’s Geometrical Theory of Attraction
(/isis/citation/CBB544814881/)
Article
Jansley Alves Chaves;
Gerard Emile Grimberg;
(2020)
Os pontos imaginários nas obras de Poncelet, Chasles e Lague
(/isis/citation/CBB360245623/)
Article
Paolo Bussotti;
(2019)
Michel Chasles’ Foundational Programme for Geometry Until the Publication of His Aperçu Historique
(/isis/citation/CBB639114546/)
Article
Emingera, Stefanie;
(2012)
Viribus unitis! shall be our watchword: The First International Congress of Mathematicians, Held 9--11 August 1897 in Zurich
(/isis/citation/CBB001212293/)
Article
Brazil, Marcus;
Graham, Ronald L.;
Thomas, Doreen A.;
Zachariasen, Martin;
(2014)
On the History of the Euclidean Steiner Tree Problem
(/isis/citation/CBB001214201/)
Article
Bruneau, Olivier;
(2011)
Le De Linearum de MacLaurin: entre Newton et Poncelet
(/isis/citation/CBB001034692/)
Article
Katz, Mikhail G.;
(2013)
Almost Equal: The Method of Adequality from Diophantus to Fermat and Beyond
(/isis/citation/CBB001213903/)
Article
Nicolas Michel;
Ivahn Smadja;
(2021)
Mathematics in the archives: Deconstructive historiography and the shaping of modern geometry (1837–1852)
(/isis/citation/CBB873256279/)
Article
Nabonnand, Philippe;
(2000)
La polémique entre Poincaré et Russell au sujet du statut des axiomes de la géométrie
(/isis/citation/CBB000770897/)
Book
Alberto Cogliati;
(2024)
La geometria non euclidea. Una breve storia dall’antichità a Poincaré
(/isis/citation/CBB276091257/)
Book
Hyder, David Jalal;
(2009)
The Determinate World: Kant and Helmholtz on the Physical Meaning of Geometry
(/isis/citation/CBB001252396/)
Article
Miled, Marouane ben;
(2008)
Mesurer le continu, dans la tradition arabe des livres V et X des Éléments
(/isis/citation/CBB000774169/)
Article
Wang, Xiao-qin;
(2005)
Michel Chasles: a learned mathematician and naive collector of old manuscripts
(/isis/citation/CBB000650792/)
Chapter
Freguglia, Paolo;
(2008)
Les équations algébriques et la géométrie chez les algébristes du XVIe siècle et chez Viète
(/isis/citation/CBB000952197/)
Book
Berlinski, David;
(2013)
The King of Infinite Space: Euclid and His Elements
(/isis/citation/CBB001213232/)
Book
de Saint-Gervais, Henri Paul;
Poincaré, Henri;
Klein, Christian Felix;
(2010)
Uniformisation des surfaces de Riemann retour sur un théorème centenaire
(/isis/citation/CBB001551391/)
Book
Senechal, Marjorie;
(2013)
I Died for Beauty: Dorothy Wrinch and the Cultures of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001213181/)
Article
Goldstein, Catherine;
(2013)
Routine Controversies: Mathematical Challenges in Mersenne's Correspondence
(/isis/citation/CBB001213939/)
Article
Hollings, Christopher;
(2014)
Investigating a Claim for Russian Priority in the Abstract Definition of a Ring
(/isis/citation/CBB001420039/)
Article
Darrigol, Olivier;
(2015)
The Mystery of Riemann's Curvature
(/isis/citation/CBB001551387/)
Be the first to comment!