Michael James Griffin (Author)
Apeiron: Journal for Ancient Philosophy and Science
Volume: 56
Issue: 2
Pages: 261-297
At Aristotle, Metaphysics E.1, 1026a14, Schwegler’s conjectural emendation of the manuscript reading ἀχώριστα to χωριστά has been widely adopted. The objects of physical science are therefore here ‘separate’, or ‘independently existent’. By contrast, the manuscripts make them ‘not separate’, construed by earlier commentators as dependent on matter. In this paper, I offer a new defense of the manuscript reading. I review past defenses based on the internal consistency of the chapter, explore where they have left supporters of the emendation unpersuaded, and attempt to strengthen their appeal. I challenge Schwegler’s central case, developed by Ross and others, that the construction μὲν ἀλλ’ οὐκ demands an implausible ‘logical antithesis’ between inseparability and mobility. This is arguably the fundamental obstacle to the manuscript reading, and counterexamples have not to date convinced emenders. I offer a new, systematic review of Aristotle’s use of the phrase, including relevant cases from the Rhetoric, to show how its usual meaning in Aristotle supports the transmitted text; I also reply to possible objections. Finally, I explore the implications of this defense for the classification of the sciences in E.1.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Christos Panayides;
(2023)
The Dispute Over the Part-Whole Puzzle in Aristotelian Hylomorphism and Ackrill’s Problem: The Argument in Metaphysics Z 17, 1041b11-33
Article
Lo Presti, Roberto;
(2014)
Informing Matter and Enmattered Forms: Aristotle and Galen on the “Power” of the Seed
Article
Santiago Chame;
(2023)
The Non-kinetic Origins of Aristotle’s Concept of Ἐνέργεια
Article
Franziska van Buren;
(2023)
Circular Motion and Circular Thought: A Synthetic Approach to the Fifth Element in Aristotle’s de Philosophia and de Caelo
Article
Olfert, Meyvis;
(2014)
Incomplete Activities
Article
Caye, P.;
(2008)
Science and Effectivity: The Architectural Theory of Vitruvius as a Test of Aristotelian Metaphysics
Article
Dahl, Norman O.;
(2007)
Substance, Sameness, and Essence in Metaphysics vii 6
Book
Anna Marmodoro;
(2014)
Aristotle on Perceiving Objects
Article
Naoya Iwata;
(2021)
Aristotle on Geometrical Potentialities
Book
Rijk, Lambertus Marie de;
(2002)
Aristotle: Semantics and Ontology
Book
Aristotle, ;
Hecquet-Devienne, M.;
Stevens, A.;
(2008)
Metaphysique Gamma: Édition, Traduction, Études
Book
Cooper, John Madison;
(2004)
Knowledge, Nature, and the Good: Essays on Ancient Philosophy
Book
Wehrle, Walter E.;
(2000)
The Myth of Aristotle's Development and the Betrayal of Metaphysics
Article
Mercado, Juan André;
(2013)
Origin of the Metaphysics of the Living: From Plato to De Anima 2.5
Book
Harari, Orna;
(2004)
Knowledge and Demonstration: Aristotle's Posterior Analytics
Book
Zagal Arreguín, Héctor;
(2005)
Método y ciencia en Aristóteles
Article
Sharples, R. W.;
(2005)
Some Thoughts on Aristotelian Form: With Special Reference to Metaphysics Z 8
Chapter
Mueller, Ian;
(2007)
La physique et la philosophie: le tournant conceptuel du IVe siècle
Article
Berti, Enrico;
(2006)
Che cosa rimane oggi della Metafisica di Aristotele?
Book
Burns, Tony;
(2011)
Aristotle and Natural Law
Be the first to comment!