Sociotechnical imaginaries of low-carbon waste-energy futures: UK techno-market fixes displacing public accountability (August 2020)
Levidow, Les (Author)
Sujatha Raman (Author)
Social Studies of Science
Volume: 50
Issue: 4
Pages: 609-641
Edition Details: Sociotechnical imaginaries: An accidental themed issue
Language: English
To implement EU climate policy, the UK’s New Labour government (1997–2010) elaborated an ecomodernist policy framework. It promoted technological innovation to provide low-carbon renewable energy, especially by treating waste as a resource. This framework discursively accommodated rival sociotechnical imaginaries, understood as visions of feasible and desirable futures available through technoscientific development. According to the dominant imaginary, techno-market fixes stimulate low-carbon technologies by making current centralized systems more resource-efficient (as promoted by industry incumbents). According to the alternative eco-localization imaginary, a shift to low-carbon systems should instead localize resource flows, output uses and institutional responsibility (as promoted by civil society groups). The UK government policy framework gained political authority by accommodating both imaginaries. As we show by drawing on three case studies, the realization of both imaginaries depended on institutional changes and material-economic resources of distinctive kinds. In practice, financial incentives drove technological design towards trajectories that favour the dominant sociotechnical imaginary, while marginalizing the eco-localization imaginary and its environmental benefits. The ecomodernist policy framework relegates responsibility to anonymous markets, thus displacing public accountability of the state and industry. These dynamics indicate the need for STS research on how alternative sociotechnical imaginaries mobilize support for their realization, rather than be absorbed into the dominant imaginary.
...MoreArticle Sergio Sismondo (August 2020) Sociotechnical imaginaries: An accidental themed issue. Social Studies of Science (pp. 505-507).
Similar Citations
Article
Benjamin K Sovacool;
Noam Bergman;
Debbie Hopkins;
Kirsten EH Jenkins;
Sabine Hielscher;
Andreas Goldthau;
Brent Brossmann;
(August 2020)
Imagining sustainable energy and mobility transitions: Valence, temporality, and radicalism in 38 visions of a low-carbon future
(/isis/citation/CBB482828082/)
Article
Yannick Rumpala;
(2017)
Alternative Forms of Energy Production and Political Reconfigurations: Exploring Alternative Energies as Potentialities of Collective Reorganization
(/isis/citation/CBB017232330/)
Article
Reihana Mohideen;
Pankaj Batra;
Prabhjot Khan;
(March 2020)
Low-Carbon Energy Transition in India: Implications for Gender Equality and Social Inclusion
(/isis/citation/CBB075250690/)
Article
Amelia Mutter;
Harald Rohracher;
(January 2022)
Competing Transport Futures: Tensions between Imaginaries of Electrification and Biogas Fuel in Sweden
(/isis/citation/CBB470368196/)
Article
Sara Heidenreich;
(May 2018)
Outreaching, Outsourcing, and Disembedding: How Offshore Wind Scientists Consider Their Engagement with Society
(/isis/citation/CBB093525125/)
Article
Caroline White-Nockleby;
(2022)
Grid-scale batteries and the politics of storage
(/isis/citation/CBB962097904/)
Book
Sheila Jasanoff;
Sang-Hyun Kim;
(2015)
Dreamscapes of Modernity: Sociotechnical Imaginaries and the Fabrication of Power
(/isis/citation/CBB690565115/)
Article
Maxime Polleri;
(August 2020)
Post-political uncertainties: Governing nuclear controversies in post-Fukushima Japan
(/isis/citation/CBB107146947/)
Article
Chih-yuan Yang;
Bronislaw Szerszynski;
Brian Wynne;
(September 2018)
The Making of Power Shortage: The Sociotechnical Imaginary of Nationalist High Modernism and Its Pragmatic Rationality in Electricity Planning in Taiwan
(/isis/citation/CBB183913124/)
Article
John Gardner;
(September 2017)
Accelerating Innovation in the Creation of Biovalue: The Cell and Gene Therapy Catapult
(/isis/citation/CBB000462445/)
Article
White, Stacey Swearingen;
Brown, J. Christopher;
Gibson, Jane W.;
Hanley, Eric;
Earnhart, Dietrich H.;
(2009)
Planting Food or Fuel: Developing an Interdisciplinary Approach to Understanding the Role of Culture in Farmers' Decisions to Grow Second-Generation, Biofuel Feedstock Crops
(/isis/citation/CBB193389379/)
Article
Pursell, Carroll W.;
(1993)
The rise and fall of the appropriate technology movement in the United States, 1965--1985
(/isis/citation/CBB001180246/)
Article
Jessica M. Smith;
Abraham S.D. Tidwell;
(June 2016)
The everyday lives of energy transitions: Contested sociotechnical imaginaries in the American West
(/isis/citation/CBB037435071/)
Article
Hirsh, Richard F.;
(2009)
Beyond batteries: An examination of the benefits and barriers to plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs) and a vehicle-to-grid (V2G) transition
(/isis/citation/CBB001180130/)
Article
Efrain O'Neill-Carrillo;
Emmanuel Mercado;
Oscar Luhring;
Isaac Jordan;
Agustin Irizarry-Rivera;
(September 2019)
Community Energy Projects in the Caribbean: Advancing Socio-Economic Development and Energy Transitions
(/isis/citation/CBB741220720/)
Article
Pierce, John C.;
Steel, Brett S.;
(2009)
Introduction to the Symposium: Cultural Considerations in Alternative-Energy Transfer
(/isis/citation/CBB106813235/)
Article
Markus S. Schulz;
(March 2018)
Museum Review: Imagining Futures of Energy: Views from Central Asia
(/isis/citation/CBB479784384/)
Article
Erik van der Vleuten;
(2018)
Technology, Societal Challenges, and Global Sustainability History (Essay)
(/isis/citation/CBB909811233/)
Article
Friedman, Robert;
Smith, Hamilton O.;
(Summer 2003)
Biological Solutions to Renewable Energy
(/isis/citation/CBB378983648/)
Article
Pierce, John C.;
Steel, Brent S.;
Warner, Rebecca L.;
(2009)
Knowledge, Culture, and Public Support for Renewable-Energy Policy
(/isis/citation/CBB844357836/)
Be the first to comment!