Article ID: CBB349569304

Goltz against cerebral localization: Methodology and experimental practices (2020)

unapi

In the late 19th century, physiologists such as David Ferrier, Eduard Hitzig, and Hermann Munk argued that cerebral brain functions are localized in discrete structures. By the early 20th century, this became the dominant position. However, another prominent physiologist, Friedrich Goltz, rejected theories of cerebral localization and argued against these physiologists until his death in 1902. I argue in this paper that previous historical accounts have failed to comprehend why Goltz rejected cerebral localization. I show that Goltz adhered to a falsificationist methodology, and I reconstruct how he designed his experiments and weighted different kinds of evidence. I then draw on the exploratory experimentation literature from recent philosophy of science to trace one root of the debate to differences in how the German localizers designed their experiments and reasoned about evidence. While Goltz designed his experiments to test hypotheses about the functions of predetermined cerebral structures, the localizers explored new functions and structures in the process of constructing new theories. I argue that the localizers relied on untested background conjectures to justify their inferences about functional organization. These background conjectures collapsed a distinction between phenomena they produced direct evidence for (localized symptoms) and what they reached conclusions about (localized functions). When citing this paper, please use the full journal title Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB349569304/

Similar Citations

Article Finkelstein, Gabriel; (2014)
Emil du Bois-Reymond on “The Seat of the Soul” (/isis/citation/CBB001213875/)

Book Stanley Finger; Paul Eling; (2019)
Franz Joseph Gall: Naturalist of the Mind, Visionary of the Brain (/isis/citation/CBB973892972/)

Article Smith, C. U. M.; (2012)
Philosophy's Loss, Neurology's Gain: The Endeavor of John Hughlings-Jackson (/isis/citation/CBB001201292/)

Book LaPointe, Leonard L.; (2012)
Paul Broca and the Origins of Language in the Brain (/isis/citation/CBB001213879/)

Article Eling, Paul; Draaisma, Douwe; Conradi, Matthijs; (2011)
Gall's Visit to the Netherlands (/isis/citation/CBB001034913/)

Article Gross, Alan G.; (2008)
The Brains in Brain: The Coevolution of Localization and Its Images (/isis/citation/CBB000831407/)

Article Domanski, Cezary W.; (2014)
Post Scriptum to the Biography of Monsieur Leborgne (/isis/citation/CBB001213877/)

Article Josef Hlade; (2021)
Reconsidering “Brain mythology” (/isis/citation/CBB117316646/)

Article Eadie, M. J.; (2009)
The Role of Focal Epilepsy in the Development of Jacksonian Localization (/isis/citation/CBB000953426/)

Article Forest, Denis; (2004)
Le concept de proprioception dans l'histoire de la sensibilité interne (/isis/citation/CBB000551126/)

Article Norrsell, Ulf; (2010)
Color Vision and Frithiof Holmgren's Discordant Retinal Microstimulation Findings (/isis/citation/CBB001034928/)

Thesis Symons, John Francis; (2002)
Computational Theories of Vision and the Problem of Explanation in Neuroscience (/isis/citation/CBB001562404/)

Authors & Contributors
Eling, Paul
Lazar, J. Wayne
Hlade, Josef
Smith, C. U. M.
Wurm, Barbara
Symons, John Francis
Concepts
Neurosciences
Brain localization
Psychology
Medicine
Human physiology
Biographies
Time Periods
19th century
20th century
21st century
20th century, early
18th century
Places
London (England)
Netherlands
Sweden
Russia
Germany
Great Britain
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment