The Power and Politics of Engineering Education Research Design: Saving the ‘Small N’ (2018)
Slaton, Amy E. (Author)
Alice L. Pawley (Author)
Engineering Studies
Volume: 10
Issue: 2-3
Pages: 133-157
For decades, American researchers have brought intellectual, financial and labor resources to understanding minority underrepresentation in engineering, including through studies of persistent racial and gender discrimination in higher engineering education. This paper considers prevailing standards for legitimate and significant research in this area and the persistent stigma associated with the study of small populations. The preference among many engineering education research producers and consumers for the ‘large-n’ brings with it presumptions about human differences including ideas of race, gender, disability and other categories by which subjects are customarily sorted for analytic purposes. This paper asks how such epistemic preferences enact power, showing how taxonomic inclinations may prevent incisive understanding of demographic privilege in U.S. higher technical education. We offer an illustrative contrast to such studies, describing a qualitative research project on underrepresented minorities in U.S. engineering schools, called ‘Learning from Small Numbers’. This project shows the analytic value of intersectional, Queer, and Disabilities Studies theories to interrogate inequity in engineering education. We argue that the reflexivity and indeterminacy supported by these theories illuminates the ruling relations of academic social sciences overall, while also reflecting on our own research preferences. There is no feature of an investigative project, including definitions of subject populations and choice of research methodology, that is not actively chosen by researchers, and it is the profound social consequences of these choices in equity-focused engineering education research that we want to consider.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Chapter
Gabriel Recchia;
(2020)
The Fall and Rise of AI: Investigating AI Narratives with Computational Methods
(/isis/citation/CBB072412898/)
Article
Coleen Carrigan;
Saejin Kwak Tanguay;
Joyce Yen;
Julie Simmons Ivy;
Cara Margherio;
M. Claire Horner-Devine;
Eve A. Riskin;
Christine S. Grant;
(2023)
Negotiating boundaries: an intersectional collaboration to advance women academics in engineering
(/isis/citation/CBB975394998/)
Article
Stephen Secules;
(2019)
Making the Familiar Strange: An Ethnographic Scholarship of Integration Contextualizing Engineering Educational Culture as Masculine and Competitive
(/isis/citation/CBB166860909/)
Article
Christine Winberg;
(2021)
The Making of Engineering Technicians: Ontological Formation in Laboratory Practice
(/isis/citation/CBB179651316/)
Article
Anders Buch;
Loren Mark Ramsay;
Hanne Løje;
(2022)
Discursive Enactments of Knowledge Production in Engineering Education
(/isis/citation/CBB600570309/)
Article
Venla Oikkonen;
(October 2017)
Affect, technoscience and textual analysis: Interrogating the affective dynamics of the Zika epidemic through media texts
(/isis/citation/CBB210701382/)
Article
Yowell, Janet L.;
Sullivan, Jacquelyn F.;
(Summer 2011)
Who Should Be an Engineer? Messaging as a Tool for Student Recruitment and Retention
(/isis/citation/CBB245900927/)
Article
Jackson, Shirley Ann;
(Winter 2020)
Why Not Change the World?
(/isis/citation/CBB461937397/)
Article
Malcom-Piqueux, Lindsey E.;
Malcom, Shirley;
(Spring 2013)
Engineering Diversity: Fixing the Educational System to Promote Equity
(/isis/citation/CBB871636948/)
Article
Dempsey, Ron;
(Summer 2017)
Gateway or Gatekeeper: Engineering Technology as a Pathway for African Americans into the Field of Engineering
(/isis/citation/CBB351238450/)
Article
Vest, Charles;
(Summer 2011)
The Image Problem for Engineering: An Overview
(/isis/citation/CBB770684007/)
Article
Dana Zarhin;
(March 2018)
“I Don’t Want to See Myself as a Disabled Person”: Continuous Positive Airway Pressure Devices and the Emergence of (Dis)ability as Subjectivity
(/isis/citation/CBB369463842/)
Article
Londa Schiebinger;
(2021)
Gendered Innovations: Integrating sex, gender, and intersectional analysis into science, health & medicine, engineering, and environment
(/isis/citation/CBB110743695/)
Article
van Heur, Bas;
Leydesdorff, Loet;
Wyatt, Sally;
(June 2013)
Turning to ontology in STS? Turning to STS through ‘ontology’
(/isis/citation/CBB199076323/)
Article
Anna Molas;
Laura Perler;
(2020)
Selecting women, taming bodies? Body ontologies in egg donation practices in Spain
(/isis/citation/CBB375247286/)
Article
Lehr, Jane L.;
(2015)
Co-creating liberal studies in engineering program(s) – a perspective from Ethnic Studies, Women's & Gender Studies, and Science & Technology Studies
(/isis/citation/CBB700204449/)
Article
Chris Gewirtz;
Marie C. Paretti;
(2021)
Becoming after College: Agency and Structure in Transitions to Engineering Work
(/isis/citation/CBB503377392/)
Article
Héctor Gustavo Giuliano;
Leandro Ariel Giri;
Fernando Gabriel Nicchi;
Walter Mario Weyerstall;
Lydia Fabiana Ferreira Aicardi;
Martín Parselis;
Federico Vasen;
(2022)
Critical Thinking and Judgment on Engineer's Work: Its Integration in Engineering Education
(/isis/citation/CBB052545076/)
Article
Wylie, Caitlin Donahue;
(December 2019)
Socialization through stories of disaster in engineering laboratories
(/isis/citation/CBB871313365/)
Article
Amy Cox Hall;
(2018)
Archival labyrinth: Words, things and bodies in epistemic formation
(/isis/citation/CBB653625786/)
Be the first to comment!