Kaltenbrunner, Wolfgang (Author)
De Rijcke, Sarah (Author)
Social Studies of Science
Volume: 49
Issue: 6
Pages: 863-883
Edition Details: Themed Issue: Academic Lives and Cultures
Language: English
In this article, we study the use of curricula vitae (CV) for competitive funding decisions in science. The typically sober administrative style of academic résumés evokes the impression of straightforwardly conveyed, objective evidence on which to base comparisons of past achievements and future potentials. We instead conceptualize the evaluation of biographical evidence as a generative interplay between an historically grown, administrative infrastructure (the CV), and a situated evaluative practice in which the representational function of that infrastructure is itself interpreted and established. The use of CVs in peer review can be seen as a doubly comparative practice, where referees compare not only applicants (among each other or to an imagined ideal of excellence), but also their own experience-based understanding of practice and the conceptual assumptions that underpin CV categories. Empirically, we add to existing literature on peer review by drawing attention to self-correcting mechanisms in the reproduction of the scientific workforce. Conceptually, we distinguish three modalities of how the doubly comparative use of CVs can shape the assessment of applicants: calibration, branching out, and repair. The outcome of this reflexive work should not be seen as predetermined by situational pressures. In fact, bibliographic categories such as authorship of publications or performance metrics may themselves come to be problematized and reshaped in the process.
...MoreArticle Sergio Sismondo (December 2019) Academic Lives and Cultures. Social Studies of Science (pp. 813-816).
Similar Citations
Article
Sarah R Davies;
Bao-Chau Pham;
(2023)
Luck and the ‘situations’ of research
(/isis/citation/CBB796332683/)
Article
Mariano Zukerfeld;
Santiago Liaudat;
María Sol Terlizzi;
Carolina Monti;
Carolina Unzurrunzaga;
(2022)
A specter is haunting science, the specter of piracy. A case study on the use of illegal routes of access to scientific literature by Argentinean researchers
(/isis/citation/CBB943097233/)
Article
Arbesman, Samuel;
Wray, K. Brad;
(April 2013)
Demographics and the fate of the young scientist (Research Note)
(/isis/citation/CBB117422278/)
Article
Wolfgang Kaltenbrunner;
Kean Birch;
Maria Amuchastegui;
(2022)
Editorial Work and the Peer Review Economy of STS Journals
(/isis/citation/CBB351753437/)
Article
Edward J. Hackett;
(July 2021)
The Ambivalence of Peer Review: Thank You ST&HV Reviewers 2019-2020
(/isis/citation/CBB912930423/)
Article
Mikko Lagerspetz;
(March 2021)
“The Grievance Studies Affair” Project: Reconstructing and Assessing the Experimental Design
(/isis/citation/CBB538391440/)
Article
Devasmita Chakraverty;
Sarah N. Newcomer;
Kelly Puzio;
Robert H. Tai;
(2018)
It Runs in the Family: The Role of Family and Extended Social Networks in Developing Early Science Interest
(/isis/citation/CBB531316217/)
Article
Clémence Pinel;
(March 2021)
Renting Valuable Assets: Knowledge and Value Production in Academic Science
(/isis/citation/CBB574556496/)
Article
Sarah R Davies;
(April 2021)
Atmospheres of science: Experiencing scientific mobility
(/isis/citation/CBB225400263/)
Article
Bruno M. L. Pinto;
José L. Costa;
Henrique N. Cabral;
(2017)
How Do Science Communication Practitioners View Scientists and Audiences in Relation to Public Engagement Activities? A Research Note Concerning the Marine Sciences in Portugal
(/isis/citation/CBB523457002/)
Article
Felicitas Hesselmann;
Martin Reinhart;
(June 2021)
Cycles of invisibility: The limits of transparency in dealing with scientific misconduct
(/isis/citation/CBB357048923/)
Article
Siyi Chen;
Yimeng Wei;
Hong, Wei;
(2023)
COVID-19 Making “Idols”: The Birth of Celebrity Scientists in China
(/isis/citation/CBB457087456/)
Article
James Powell;
(2017)
Scientists Reach 100% Consensus on Anthropogenic Global Warming
(/isis/citation/CBB664665682/)
Article
Margaret Sleeboom-Faulkner;
(June 2019)
Regulatory brokerage: Competitive advantage and regulation in the field of regenerative medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB470996355/)
Article
Dilshani Sarathchandra;
(2017)
Risky Science? Perception and Negotiation of Risk in University Bioscience
(/isis/citation/CBB691241938/)
Article
Sampsa Saikkonen;
Esa Väliverronen;
(2022)
The trickle-down of political and economic control: On the organizational suppression of environmental scientists in government science
(/isis/citation/CBB033206075/)
Article
Shana Lee Hirsch;
Jerrold Long;
(March 2021)
Adaptive Epistemologies: Conceptualizing Adaptation to Climate Change in Environmental Science
(/isis/citation/CBB087611495/)
Chapter
Gläser, Jochen;
Lange, Stefan;
Laudel, Grit;
Schimank, Uwe;
(2010)
Informed Authority? The Limited Use of Research Evaluation Systems for Managerial Control in Universities
(/isis/citation/CBB001420859/)
Article
Sergio Sismondo;
(December 2019)
Academic Lives and Cultures
(/isis/citation/CBB500921335/)
Article
Line Edslev Andersen;
K Brad Wray;
(December 2019)
Detecting errors that result in retractions
(/isis/citation/CBB480893444/)
Be the first to comment!