Positivism, Science and 'The Scientists' in Porfirian Mexico: The Philosophy of Herbert Spencer in the Historiography of Mexico (2016)
Priego, Natalia (Author)
Liverpool University Press
Physical Details: 272 pp.
Language: English
This innovative monograph is of major significance for not only all students and academics who undertake research on the history of Mexico during the half-century prior to the onset in 1910 of the Mexican Revolution but also the parallel community of scholars who specialise in the history of ideas, philosophy and science throughout Latin America in this period. Its principal purpose is to revisit the influential thesis of the Mexican philosopher Leopoldo Zea that the political-ideological group dubbed 'the scientists' by their opponents were guided by positivist ideas, especially those of the English philosopher Herbert Spencer. Its structure embraces, first, an overview of previous research upon the formation and differentiation of 'the scientists' and the black legend surrounding their legitimisation of the dictatorship of Porfirio Díaz, president of Mexico for 31 years until going into exile in 1911 after 27 uninterrupted years in the presidency, followed by an analysis, based upon primary sources that include Spencer's journal articles, of the origins of the theory of evolution long before Darwin and, in particular, the significant impact of Bacon and Newton upon the philosophy of Spencer. Having established what Spencer actually believed and wrote, the book then provides an analysis of the prolific writings, both published and archival, of two of the leading, although ideologically different, representatives of 'the scientists', Francisco Bulnes and Justo Sierra, demonstrating that their eclectic discourses used the ideas of the American Social Darwinists, and those from Spencer, Charles Darwin, Auguste Comte, and other European writers whose ideas reached them in a fragmented and second-hand fashion in an arbitrary fashion to support their conservative views of the need to promote political order and socio-economic progress, notwithstanding their belief that the ethnic make-up of Mexican society was a barrier to the country's modernisation. It concludes that far from forming a homogeneous elite guided by positivist ideas, 'the scientists' lacked a clear leader, and had an ambivalent relationship with Díaz. This revisionist book is of relevance for not only Mexicanists but also students of positivism in other Latin American countries - notably Brazil, because hitherto Zea's assessment of the Spencerianism of 'the scientists' has tended to be applied to the region as a whole by a process of inaccurate extrapolation.
...MoreReview Andres Rios‐Molina (2017) Review of "Positivism, Science and 'The Scientists' in Porfirian Mexico: The Philosophy of Herbert Spencer in the Historiography of Mexico". Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences (pp. 389-391).
Similar Citations
Article
Corr, John;
(2014)
The Enlightenment Surfaces in Nineteenth-Century Mexico: Scientific Thinking Attempts to Deliver Order and Progress
(/isis/citation/CBB001420241/)
Book
Canadelli, Elena;
(2013)
Più positivo dei positivisti: Antropologia, psicologia, evoluzionismo in Tito Vignoli
(/isis/citation/CBB001450137/)
Article
Montserrat, Marcelo;
(1986)
La presencia evolucionista en el positivismo argentino
(/isis/citation/CBB000044800/)
Chapter
Ruiz Gutierrez, Rosaura;
(1995)
Gabino Barreda and the introduction of Darwinism in Mexico: Positivism and evolution
(/isis/citation/CBB000070724/)
Chapter
Gissis, Snait B.;
(2011)
Lamarckism and the Constitution of Sociology
(/isis/citation/CBB001500088/)
Book
Beck, Naomi;
(2014)
La gauche évolutionniste. Spencer et ses lecteurs en France et en Italie
(/isis/citation/CBB001510177/)
Article
Hlade, Josef;
(2019)
Die Wiener Hirnforschung und die Entstehung des österreichischen Positivismus (Viennese Brain Research and the Formation of Austrian Positivism)
(/isis/citation/CBB816306816/)
Book
Francis, Mark;
(2007)
Herbert Spencer and the Invention of Modern Life
(/isis/citation/CBB000774196/)
Book
W. J. Mander;
(2014)
The Oxford Handbook of British Philosophy in the Nineteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB624199481/)
Article
Michael Kent;
Vivette García-Deister;
Carlos López-Beltrán;
Ricardo Ventura Santos;
Ernesto Schwartz-Marín;
Peter Wade;
(2015)
Building the Genomic Nation: ‘Homo Brasilis’ and the ‘Genoma Mexicano’ in Comparative Cultural Perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB543686037/)
Book
Marcos Cueto;
Eden Medina;
Ivan da Costa Marques;
Christina Holmes;
(2014)
Beyond Imported Magic: Essays on Science, Technology, and Society in Latin America
(/isis/citation/CBB341148554/)
Book
Livio Sansone;
(2022)
La Galassia Lombroso
(/isis/citation/CBB789501643/)
Article
Foschi, Renato;
(2016)
La rappresentazione psico-antropologica dei meridionali tra Ottocento e Novecento
(/isis/citation/CBB415529966/)
Article
Matthew Wilson;
(2019)
Labour, Utopia and Modern Design Theory: The Positivist Sociology of Frederic Harrison
(/isis/citation/CBB874563046/)
Article
Santos, Fabiane Vinente dos;
(2007)
Sexualidade e civilização nos trópicos: gênero, medicina e moral na imprensa de Manaus (1895--1915)
(/isis/citation/CBB000831574/)
Article
Leporiere, Lorenzo;
(2016)
Filippo Bottazzi e le sue indagini sulla ‘medianità’ di Eusapia Palladino.
(/isis/citation/CBB424502076/)
Book
Johannes Feichtinger;
Franz L. Fillafer;
Jan Surman;
(2018)
The Worlds of Positivism: A Global Intellectual History, 1770–1930
(/isis/citation/CBB298923215/)
Book
Leonardo Ciacci;
(2023)
Patrick Geddes
(/isis/citation/CBB502845517/)
Chapter
Koch, Carl Henrik;
(1998)
To generationer i københavnsk filosofi: Post-spekulationens og positivismens tidsalder 1880--1945
(/isis/citation/CBB000503178/)
Article
Ryan M. Jones;
(2023)
Defeating the ‘social danger’ of homosexuality while ‘forging the fatherland’: Sexual science and biotypology in Mexico’s national development, 1927–57
(/isis/citation/CBB380525448/)
Be the first to comment!